It has lost this in two different ways: one is through
the psychologizing of religion, whereby the church becomes basically a therapeutic agency, and the other through the politicizing of religion, whereby the church becomes an agent of change, a political institution.
Biblically conservative Christians today rightly reject recreational sex as
a psychologizing of Scripture if undisciplined sexual behavior is justified by conclusions drawn from modern theories about sexual repression.
I would agree, but I would supplement this narrative by pointing to
the psychologizing of human identity and political struggle over the last century.
Through
the psychologizing of the moment its total content is reflected upon and reduced to a process or experience of the soul.
Augustine's
psychologizing of love, removing it from biblical, prophetic justice, has done the West more harm than good in the long run.
Not exact matches
In relation to the contemporary tendency to
psychologize the sacrament, this understanding
of the reality
of the past and its causally effective presence supports the theological consensus
of a presence not dependent on the subjective state
of the worshipers.
While rejecting
psychologizing, this view
of real presence also opposes the magical tendencies
of some traditional doctrines.
Augustine seems to have held a
psychologized version
of such a view.
The invocation
of the speech
of heaven has become
psychologized, privatized, and powerless.
By means
of his theological understanding he is able to reject doctrines
of the Eucharist which are guilty
of «
psychologizing» it as merely a memory
of a past event on the one hand, and «magical tendencies
of some traditional doctrines» on the other (PPE 229).
Rigorous use
of biblical criticism prevents
psychologizing and allegorizing, insofar as the attempt is made to recover what Jesus actually taught and how the church in fact interpreted his teaching, and only then to inquire into its psycho - social and symbolic meaning, both for Jesus and the church, and for us today.
A further factor at work in the situation was the feeling that a discussion
of «faith» in the teaching
of Jesus would lead to a discussion
of Jesus» faith and this would be an illegitimate
psychologizing about Jesus.
Instead
of beginning with an image derived from prophetic discourse, that
of another voice behind the prophet's voice, and extending it by analogy to narration, prescriptive saying, wisdom literature, hymnic compositions, and so on, we are delivered from
psychologizing interpretations
of revelation to a sensitivity to the sense
of the text, to the world - reference it opens up before it.
This was, if anything, even farther from the truth about the special problem
of the modern middle - class American woman than the Freudian - type
psychologizing, and even less helpful in offering her an understanding
of it.
The subject no longer discovers mystery from without but produces the effect
of mystery from within by what sociologist Philip Rieff calls «
psychologizing interminably» about its own interiority.
Bultmann has reacted very sharply against this development, which he accuses
of psychologizing about Jesus in the manner
of an already discredited liberalism.
It is not a case
of psychologizing about Jesus but
of recognizing that a person is necessarily involved in his word, that the message necessarily involves the messenger, that a message challenging to faith necessarily involves a witnessing to faith on the part
of the messenger.
Even if steps are taken to avoid
psychologizing, to give due emphasis to the eschatology, etc., the fundamental weakness remains the fact that the deliberate elevation
of a historically reconstructed figure to the central concern
of faith must inevitably lead to the confusion
of two quite separate functions: the reconstruction
of a historical figure and what we shall call the construction
of a faith - image.
The self - consciousness
of Jesus, however, is not a legitimate concern, because we have no sources for such knowledge, and when we supply the deficiency by analogy from other historical individuals, we are
psychologizing about Jesus.
Much
of what will be said in this chapter may be condemned as unwarranted «
psychologizing»; but when a meticulous academic procedure has taken us as far as it can go, there is still a legitimate place for imagination, properly guarded.
The escalation
of marketplace conflict is related to the emergence
of sexuality as the political issue
of the day, combined with a
psychologized (and thus subjective and selective) view
of oppression.
Plowing ahead with abandon, like the kids who scamper their way through it, The Florida Project is a snapshot portrait
of Americans living on the margins that has no time for
psychologizing.
Armchair
psychologizing is always a dangerous game, but my best hunch is that a kind
of moral panic has set in among certain reformers — on both sides
of the aisle, though it seems more pronounced on the Left.
At the same time
psychologizing and seduced by her subject, the artist finds herself in a double bind, a dilemma that resonates with the muddled desire that animates her protagonist as he drifts from abject rants to declamations
of heroic poetry or unashamed self - praise.
Her paintings offer a heavy dose
of London School
psychologizing in the vein
of Lucian Freud and Paula Rego and some
of the gross - out tactics practiced by artists like Jenny Saville and Cecily Brown.