In a recent New York Times opinion piece even Bill Gates, a harsh critic of the old system of teacher evaluation, cautions against shaming educators by
publishing teacher scores in the media.
Several New York City newspapers have previously
published teacher scores, with the names attached.
Not exact matches
«However, contrary to all standards of decency in a democratic setting and in spite of the service of Court process on the Kaduna State government, you have gone ahead to
publish on your tweeter handle, a list of
teachers who purportedly passed the competency test by
scoring 75 per cent and above.
A second study, recently
published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by Gary Chamberlain, using the same data as Chetty and his colleagues, provides fodder both for skeptics and supporters of the use of value - added: while confirming Chetty's finding that the
teachers who have impacts on contemporaneous measures of student learning also have impacts on earnings and college going, Chamberlain also found that test -
scores are a very imperfect proxy for those impacts.
In a recently
published study in Economics of Education Review, we follow the trajectories of 2.9 million public school students in Florida over a seven - year time period and compare their standardized test
scores in years when they had a
teacher of the same ethnicity to school years when they did not.
For the past three years, I have worked as a sixth - and seventh - grade math
teacher in Brooklyn, N.Y. I have had two value - added
scores published on the New York Times SchoolBook website which received the
scores from the New York City Department of Education through a Freedom of Information Act request.
The paper used seven years of reading and math
scores to calculate performance for individual
teachers who've taught grades three through five, and plans to
publish the effectiveness ratings with the
teacher's names.
In our new study,
published today in Education Next, my colleagues and I found that only 22 percent of
teachers were evaluated based on test
score gains in the four urban school districts we studied.
,»
published by the Consortium on Chicago School Research, students whose
teachers routinely gave «authentic intellectual assignments» increased their
scores on the Iowa Test of Basic Skills (a widely used standardized test) by 20 percent more than the average increase in
scores nationally.
A study of 1,450 Virginia secondary schools,
published this month in Psychological Science, suggests that students»
scores on state tests may be partly a function of where they live, how poor their classmates are, and whether they have access to competent
teachers.
In February 2012, the New York Times took the unusual step of
publishing performance ratings for nearly 18,000 New York City
teachers based on their students» test -
score gains, commonly called value - added (VA) measures.
What's more, that improvement in
teacher qualifications, observed from 2000 to 2005, could have caused a simultaneously observed increase in student test
scores, say authors of the report,
published last month in the National Bureau of Economic Research's working - paper series.
The results,
published in 2007 in the Journal of Early Childhood
Teacher Education, showed that the storytelling students
scored significantly better on vocabulary and reading «readiness» tests than the control group.
The Los Angeles
teachers union president said Sunday he was organizing a «massive boycott» of The Times after the newspaper began
publishing a series of articles that uses student test
scores to estimate the effectiveness of district
teachers.
The Times will
publish the database later this month after
teachers have been given a chance to view and comment on their
scores.
Giving
teachers both the lesson plans and support had a positive, significant effect on students» end - of - year math test
scores, according to the study, which was
published as a working paper by the National Bureau of Economic Research.
Los Angeles Times
publishes teacher evaluations based on test
scores.
A study by Kirabo Jackson
published in the Fall 2008 issue of Ed Next found that a program that paid students and
teachers for passing
scores on Advanced Placement tests produced meaningful increases in participation in the AP program and improvements in other critical education outcomes.
A second study, recently
published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by Gary Chamberlain, using the same data as Chetty and his colleagues, provides fodder both for skeptics and supporters of the use of value - added: while confirming Chetty's finding that the
teachers who have impacts on contemporaneous measures of student learning also have impacts on earnings and college going, Chamberlain also found that test
scores are a very imperfect proxy for those impacts.
Later this month, The Times will
publish a database of more than 6,000 elementary school
teachers ranked by their ability to improve students»
scores on standardized tests, marking the first time such information had been released publicly.
For example, a detailed study of new
teachers in New York state,
published in December 2014 in Educational Researcher, found that at the worst point — in 1999 — almost 30 percent of new
teachers came from the bottom third, as measured by SAT
scores.
, recently
published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by Gary Chamberlain, using the same data as Chetty and his colleagues, provides fodder both for skeptics and supporters of the use of value - added: while confirming Chetty's finding that the
teachers who have impacts on contemporaneous measures of student learning also have impacts on earnings and college going, Chamberlain also found that test
scores are a very imperfect proxy for those impacts.
Education Week: Your husband has written a few op - eds expressing reservationswith some of the ways states and districts are carrying out
teacher evaluation —
publishing of
scores, for instance.
Newspapers across the country have
published accounts of extraordinary
teachers whose evaluations, based on their students» state test
scores, seem completely out of sync with the reality of their practice.
Most of these media outlets
published lists of individual
teachers and their
scores.
In 2012, a pair of analyses
published by Harvard University's Strategic Data Project found that the students of Board - certified
teachers in the Los Angeles Unified School District and in Gwinnett County, Georgia, outperformed their peers by approximately two months in math and one month in English Language Arts, based on gains in student test
scores.
See the article «Judge Sides with Loudoun Parent Seeking
Teachers» Names, Student Test
Scores,»
published yesterday in a local Loudon, Virginia news outlet.
The Times began
publishing articles in August using value - added analysis to estimate the effectiveness of thousands of district
teachers in raising test
scores.
The debate erupted in August, when The Times
published a database of the value - added
scores of about 6,000 elementary school
teachers based on seven years of testing data, prompting union protests and vows by the district to raise the issue during contract negotiations.
The effort to release the data began in 2010 after the Los Angeles Times and other media
published the
scores of thousands of
teachers in the Los Angeles school district.
The Los Angeles Times calculated their own value - added
scores based on test
scores obtained from the Los Angeles school district, and
published them, complete with
teacher names, last summer.
The NY Post, another subsidiary of News Corp, recently provoked controversy by
publishing teacher data reports based on student test
scores in its paper, and running inflammatory articles about
teachers who received low
scores.
Related, I should note that in a few places the authors exaggerate how, for example,
teachers» effects on their students» achievement are so tangible, without any mention of contrary reports, namely as
published by the American Statistical Association (ASA), in which the ASA evidenced that these (oft - exaggerated)
teacher effects account for no more than 1 % -14 % of the variance in students» growth
scores (see more information here).
Back to the issue at hand, why should test
score data, even crunched in a value - added way, be
published in the paper alongside the names of individual
teachers?
But I have to disagree on this new drive to
publish (in newspapers) the student test
scores of individual
teachers, even in a value - added way.
New York is not the first city where media outlets have taken action to
publish value - added
scores for individual
teachers.
And won't we, by focusing so much on test
scores — especially if we're going to
publish them by
teachers» names — motivate
teachers to want to teach in the grades that aren't part of the number - crunching?
(Much more controversial was when the LA Times won for
publishing teachers» value - added
scores in 2010.)
The state, which promised to improve education school accountability in its Race to the Top grant, has since stopped
publishing the results in anticipation of the state's new
teacher evaluation process, which will use student test
scores to rate
teachers.
The Post and Courier in Charleston, S.C., filed a request to obtain value - added
scores for Charleston
teachers and
published a database using the material.
By August 27, 2010, the Economic Policy Institute
published an open letter, Problems with Using Student Test
Scores to Evaluate
Teachers.
They have done this repeatedly since 2011 — the first time the Los Angeles Times hired external contractors to calculate LAUSD
teachers» value - added
scores, so that they could
publish the
teachers» value - added
scores on their Los Angeles
Teacher Ratings website.
In 2013, two education economists
published a working paper suggesting that D.C.'s
teacher evaluation system induced
teachers with low evaluation
scores to voluntarily leave DCPS, and improved the performance of
teachers who stayed.
Education Secretary Arne Duncan said that the
publishing of the individual
teacher's
scores is just fine.
I currently work as a Special Education in Boston, and MA is working on a piece of legislation that would
publish the student test
scores of each classroom
teacher.
The study,
published last week in the journal Educational Researcher, looks at the average SAT
scores of newly certified and hired
teachers in New York state over the past 25 years.
A well liked 5th Grade
Teacher committed suicide in 2010 after the Los Angeles Times
published the VAM
scores of all of the
teachers in Los Angeles.
Just a few years ago, prominent leaders were calling to
publish teachers» VAM
scores, so that parents and taxpayers could better hold public school
teachers accountable.
CAP's report notes that the discussion of
publishing teachers» names along with their value - added
score (a measure of a
teacher's efficacy, relative to other
teachers in the group, in promoting student achievement) began when the Los Angeles Times
published a report featuring the performance ratings for Los Angeles Unified School District
teachers.
For example, when researchers used a different model to recalculate the value - added
scores for
teachers that were
published in The Los Angeles Times in 2011, they found that from 40 to 55 percent of them would get noticeably different
scores using a VA model that accounted for student assignments in a different way.