The use of
punishment as a deterrent, and the effect of the penal system upon persons and society as a whole, raise issues for moral judgment.
For those who view deterrence as the primary purpose of punishment, the uncertainty of capital
punishment as a deterrent provides the fatal argument against it.
But research shows individual
punishment as a deterrent rarely works.
Using
punishment as a deterrent for bad behaviour will cultivate hatred and fear towards you in the long run.
Not exact matches
As for your seriously off base torture comparison, if we saw a drastic increase in violent crimes, and there was a public outcry for harsher punishments to try and serve as a deterrent, and the Bill was drafted, made open to the public, and the solid majority of the population didn't turn against it with protests, signatures, and contacting their representatives; maybe a torture law could make it (though it would never get past the Supreme Court as the Consttution is now, but we'll let that slide as a hypothetical
As for your seriously off base torture comparison, if we saw a drastic increase in violent crimes, and there was a public outcry for harsher
punishments to try and serve
as a deterrent, and the Bill was drafted, made open to the public, and the solid majority of the population didn't turn against it with protests, signatures, and contacting their representatives; maybe a torture law could make it (though it would never get past the Supreme Court as the Consttution is now, but we'll let that slide as a hypothetical
as a
deterrent, and the Bill was drafted, made open to the public, and the solid majority of the population didn't turn against it with protests, signatures, and contacting their representatives; maybe a torture law could make it (though it would never get past the Supreme Court
as the Consttution is now, but we'll let that slide as a hypothetical
as the Consttution is now, but we'll let that slide
as a hypothetical
as a hypothetical).
Capital
punishment's lack of demonstrated superiority
as a
deterrent (the evidence for its effectiveness being at best mixed), the capacity of society to protect itself equally well by permanently imprisoning those who are currently being executed (which is possible at limited marginal cost, especially when one takes into account the cost of the extended trial procedures and interminable appeals and reviews which usually accompany capital
punishment)-- all these points are important, but their utility is chiefly
as rebuttal arguments in response to the empirically weak but emotionally strong claims made on behalf of capital
punishment.
While over half of the world's nations have abolished capital
punishment, and while international criticism of the U.S. has been intense, America continues to condemn the poor and racial minorities (particularly those who kill whites) in disproportionate numbers,
as well
as the mentally ill, the mentally retarded, juveniles (here the U.S. leads the world) and sometimes the innocent — and all this to no apparent
deterrent effect.
The actual loss of a first - round pick would have made much more sense, though, both
as a
deterrent and
as a
punishment for a scouting director having more resources for the 2015 draft than the other 29 scouting directors.
The plain truth is, though, that even if
punishment was effective
as a
deterrent, a gentle response to physical aggression is literally the only response that a parent can make that won't actually reinforce the aggression.
However whether or not it «suits the crime» or has an effect long - term, the threat of
punishment in society is supposed to serve
as a
deterrent to some who might otherwise commit crimes.
«The Commissioner of Police said the
punishments handed down to the unruly officers would serve
as a
deterrent to others who may wish to toe the path of ignominy.»
«On that basis alone I would support the reintroduction of capital
punishment to serve
as a
deterrent.»
Peter Hodgkinson of the Centre for Capital
Punishment Studies used the example of the US
as a
deterrent to those in the UK who may be tempted to see the practice through rose - tinted spectacles.
According to him, the «bar needed to be raised» this time because «if you raise the bar in the issue of contempt, then we should also raise the bar of the
punishment a bit so that perhaps this one will truly serve
as a
deterrent».
PP on crime: «If you had the ultimate
punishment for the murder of policemen and other heinous crimes, I am sure it would act
as a
deterrent.
The idea of capital
punishment as both reliable, objective justice and effective
deterrent is shown to be dangerously absurd, and its abolition does not signal an instant cultural shift.
'' (g) The total
deterrent effect of other
punishment imposed upon the defendant
as a result of the misconduct, including, but not limited to, punitive damage awards to
Punitive damages are meant
as a
punishment and a
deterrent for future negligence.
Punitive damages are meant
as a
punishment to the defendant
as well
as a
deterrent to others.
The second, however, remains a challenge, particularly
as one moves away from relying on the knowledge of the possibility of ex post adjudication and
punishment having a
deterrent effect, and towards ex ante identification and intercession.
As with any injunctive relief, the point is about
deterrent and facilitating effective
punishment for the respondent when it is appropriate to do so.