With this decison, the Ontario Court of Appeal specifically acknowledged the appropriateness of
punitive damages awards against employers who discriminate, harass or fail to accommodate disabled employees.
This was done during a time when a $ 50 million
punitive damage award against Massey Coal was being appealed to that Supreme Court.
Only lawyer in Canada who has won, on three separate occasions,
punitive damage awards against insurance companies for the manner in which the insurers treated their policy holders
Among other significant matters, she secured a historic victory for State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, when the U.S. Supreme Court reversed a $ 145 million
punitive damages award against the company as unconstitutionally excessive.
Insurers are vocally opposed, even though they are prohibited outright under California law from covering
punitive damage awards against their insureds.
It also provides a precedent (i) for holding the director of the corporate debtor personally liable for oppressive acts, and (ii) for claiming a large
punitive damages award against an evasive judgment debtor.
But because the broker had actively supported the fair housing laws, the appellate court overturned the trial court's
punitive damage award against him and the company.
Not exact matches
In no event shall the arbitrator be entitled to
award either party exemplary, treble or any other form of
punitive damages against the other, regardless of the claims raised.
Noting that Goico's $ 2.5 million
award includes $ 1.5 million in
punitive damages against Wichita's largest employer, Brantner writes:
While Oregon's judicial review ensures that
punitive damages are not
awarded against defendants entirely innocent of conduct warranting exemplary
damages, Oregon, unlike the common law, provides no assurance that those whose conduct is sanctionable by
punitive damages are not subjected to
punitive damages of arbitrary amounts.
Plaintiffs
awarded punitive damages by a jury
against their insurers should expect to face an appeal, Toronto personal injury lawyer Gary Will tells AdvocateDaily.com.
Punitive damages are
awarded against parties in order to deter certain conduct that courts finds egregious or outrageous.
In addition, Archibald ordered them to pay IMAX $ 456,000 for disgorgement of profits and
awarded $ 50,000 in
punitive damages against Tsui.
Jury Trial for compensatory and
punitive damages, ICBC v. Finley and Finley, BC Supreme Court, 2003 unreported —
awards in excess of $ 2.5 million dollars
against each defendant
Jury Trial for compensatory and
punitive damages, ICBC v. Sun and others, BC Supreme Court, 2003 unreported —
awards in excess of $ 640,000
against numerous defendants
In order for a jury to
award punitive damages against a defendant, the plaintiff must properly allege such
damages throughout the case.
Kwinter helped secure the largest jury
award in the province's history for
punitive damages against an insurer in the 2006 case Pereira v. Hamilton Township Farmers» Mutual Fire Insurance Co., with his clients ordered to receive $ 2.5 million.
On Friday, a Jackson County Circuit Court jury
awarded $ 20 million in
punitive damages in a case that alleged retaliation, age and sex discrimination
against an American Family Insurance sales manager.
Awards against nursing homes are comprised for the most part of
punitive damages, and
damages for mental anguish, pain and suffering experienced by the injured person, medical expenses, and the loss of affection and companionship by the surviving spouse or children.
Liptak's article describes an Italian court that refused to enforce an Alabama judgment
against an Italian company because the
award included
punitive damages — a concept offensive to Italian notions of justice.
In reducing the original
punitive damages award, the Court of Appeal balanced the legitimate objective of «punishing» the employer
against a requirement of proportionality based on the specific facts of the case.
The Court of Appeal11 reduced the
punitive damage award to $ 100,000
against Wal - Mart and $ 10,000
against the manager.
Punitive damages are
awarded against a defendant in exceptional cases for «malicious, oppressive and high - handed» misconduct that «offends the court's sense of decency»: Hill v. Church of Scientology of Toronto, [1995] 2 S.C.R. 1130, at para. 196.
The plaintiff alleged in the statement of claim that the Bank displayed the same tactics and approach in his dismissal as in earlier dismissal, which had resulted in court
awards of
punitive damages against the bank.
It's also worth noting that Texas law may have limits on the amount of recovery you may be entitled to in a personal injury claim depending on several factors, including limits established by the Texas Tort Claims Act for actions
against governmental entities,
punitive damage awards and general
damages awards on Medical Malpractice claims, just to name a few.
Obtained a
punitive damage award ($ 350,000) which is still the highest
punitive award against an insurer upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal (Plester vs. Wawanesa)
In some cases, if an insurer's conduct is egregious or heavy handed, a Court could
award punitive or aggravated
damages against the insurer.
There may be a vehicle to
award punitive damages against a perpetrator.
However, in some cases, juries and courts can
award what are called «
punitive damages,» which are designed to punish defendants who have behaved recklessly or intentionally
against the public's interest.
The jury found for the plaintiff and
awarded 20 weeks salary in
damages, the amount specified in her employment contract, $ 200,000 in aggravated
damages against the employer for the manner of dismissal, and $ 1,000,000 in
punitive damages.
The jury, however, will not consider whether to
award punitive damages against Western Express.
Obtained a $ 20 million compensatory
damage award, a six - figure
award of sanctions for discovery abuses
against the Defendants and counsel, and a recommended $ 10 million
award of
punitive damages.
Representation of city in post-judgment motions and appeal of whistle blower case where the jury
awarded Plaintiffs $ 27 million in actual and
punitive damages against three Defendants who allegedly retaliated
against Plaintiffs for exercising their First Amendment rights and whistle blowing.
Provided coverage advice to an international insurance company in a matter where a Missouri jury
awarded $ 355 million in compensatory
damages and $ 35.5 million in
punitive damages against a financial institution for a trust that was intended to fund «pre-need» funeral policies that would cover all future funeral - related needs.
Damaging Justice The case
against awarding punitive damages based on the sway of emotions or messianic zeal.
Awards against nursing homes are comprised for the most part of
punitive damages.
One need only compare that
against the recent case of Boucher v. Wal - Mart Canada Corp., 2014 ONCA 419 (CanLII), summarized by this blog in the post Wal - Mart Rolls Back
Award of
Punitive Damages, which must now be considered the high - water mark for aggravated damages for bad behaviour in empl
Damages, which must now be considered the high - water mark for aggravated
damages for bad behaviour in empl
damages for bad behaviour in employment.
A small claims case
against a slum landlord in which the judge blasted the landord for his conduct and
awarded punitive damages made the front page of the Edmonton Journal.
For example,
punitive damages may be
awarded against a manufacturer of a defective car in order to incent the manufacturer to improve the safety of its cars going forward.
Although the Supreme Court of Canada upheld the
award of
punitive damages against RBC it rejected the trial judge's conclusion that «courts are entitled to expect honest behaviour from the major chartered banks».
The court believed that
punitive damages can not be
awarded against a tortfeasor's estate.
Successful co-counsel with Alfred M. Kwinter at trial where Court found in favour of insureds
against its insurer and repair contractor including an
award of $ 100,000 in
punitive damages (Brandiferri v. Wawanesa and Strone)
Successfully represented Plaintiff in fire loss claim
against insurer where jury
awarded $ 175,000.00 in
punitive damages for bad faith conduct of insurer in denying claim based on an alleged misrepresentation in in the application process (Haji - Fazul v. Lloyd's Underwriters)
D'Amore, of D'Amore Law Group, who represented a woman who was molested by an anesthesiologist while under sedation, has been
awarded $ 950,000 in compensatory and
punitive damages in her case
against a hospital -LSB-...]
The group of North Carolina plaintiffs were each
awarded $ 75k in compensatory
damages, as well as $ 5 million each in
punitive damages,
against a pig farming conglomerate.
Community Rights Counsel Press Release — For more than a decade, Exxon Corporation (now ExxonMobil) has waged a comprehensive campaign
against punitive damages awards, triggered by the decision of a jury in Alaska to impose a $ 5 billion penalty on the company for the misdeeds that led to the Valdez oil spill, the worst in the nation's history.
As my colleague Andy Frey and I reported in an earlier post, an Illinois federal jury in July returned a $ 150 million
punitive verdict
against AbbVie without
awarding the plaintiff any compensatory
damages.
The trial judge's reasons confirm that he appreciated the purposes of
punitive damages, their exceptional nature, the need to be fair to both sides, and the basis for Rabinowitz's contention at trial that any
award of
punitive damages as
against him should be limited to $ 25,000 to $ 50,000.
The jury also
awarded her
damages of $ 1,200,000
against Wal - Mart, made up of $ 200,000 in aggravated
damages for the manner in which she was dismissed, and $ 1,000,000 in
punitive damages.
In deciding that the
award of
punitive damages against Wal - Mart should be reduced, however, Justice Laskin wrote: