Sentences with phrase «range of reasonable outcomes»

As long as the decision - maker took the Charter right into account and arrived at a decision within the range of reasonable outcomes, the decision should be upheld.

[91]... It is only where the current circumstances represent a significant departure from the range of reasonable outcomes anticipated by the parties, in a manner that puts them at odds with the objectives of the Act, that the court may be persuaded to give the agreement little weight.

While I agree that the Presiding Officer's decision was correct in law and within a range of reasonable outcomes, this case raises concern that the Court's broad application of the self - incrimination immunity exception to one class may have adverse effects on the public.

However, while the Court disagreed that the appropriate standard of review was correctness, it proceeded by assuming otherwise and found the Presiding Officer's decision both correct in law and within the range of reasonable outcomes (at para 45).

[26] The obligation of the administrative delegate is to apply the Dreidger template so as to determine whether the statutory provision is open to two or more reasonable interpretations (Dunsmuir's range of reasonable outcomes).

With respect to the reasonableness of interpretative rulings, Dunsmuir requires they fall within a «range of reasonable outcomes.»

It makes sense for judges to be flexible when ordering costs in decisions in which the range of reasonable outcomes could have resulted in the plaintiff being awarded damages in excess of $ 25,000 and the plaintiff has followed the most cost - effective and efficient route in pursuing his or her claim for damages.

Accordingly, in cases involving fundamental constitutional values or important individual interests, the range of reasonable outcomes will be narrower.

It seems to me that the only way to move the law forward within the existing framework without starting again from scratch is to apply reasonableness review across the board, with the important caveat (borne out, I would say, by the decisions on the merits in Kanthasamy and Saguenay) that the range of reasonable outcomes will be narrower in cases featuring an appeal clause.

In this case, the husband contracted to pay spousal support for a ten - year period, and his retirement — and the wife's continued need for support — were not significant departures from the range of reasonable outcomes the parties anticipated at the time the final order and separation agreement were made.