I
read Nic's defense here, but I did not see that he refuted the argument I made on his estimate of CS on
Stoat: http://scienceblogs.com/
stoat/2012/12/20/people-if-you-want-to-argue-with-stoats-first-
read-enough-to-be-a-weasel-parrots-neednt-apply/#comment-24749 — It seems to me that Lewis» calculations are reasonable, but they lowball temperature change, ignore ocean heat absorption below 2000 m, and high - ball radiative forcing.