Even if we ignore the fact that most portfolio managers, regulators, and other policy makers rely on the level of test scores (rather than gains) to gauge quality, math and
reading achievement results are not particularly reliable indicators of whether teachers, schools, and programs are improving later - life outcomes for students.
The fact that math and
reading achievement results are overly narrow and easily distorted makes them particularly poor indicators of quality and weak predictors of later - life outcomes.
A screening measure needs to focus on specific skills that are highly correlated with broader measures of
reading achievement resulting in a highly accurate sorting of students.
Not exact matches
BUFFALO, N.Y. (WBEN)-- When looking at the
results of Wednesday's re-organization meeting for the Buffalo School Board, the public will
read Dr. Barbara Seals Nevergold retained her position as President of the Board while Sharon Belton - Cottman was voted Vice President of Executive Affairs and Theresa Harris - Tigg was voted the Vice President of Student
Achievement.
Nonetheless, NCLB offered some positive changes that the new ESSA maintains, including academic standards, annual assessments of
reading and math
achievement, and report cards on schools that students, parents and the public can use to gauge
results.
Sources might include
reading and math
achievement test scores, IQ scores, benchmark and state test
results, and grade level progress in the curriculum.
Reading's
results show a wide and worsening gap between the
achievement of these pupils and their more advantaged peers, both locally and nationally.
In the 2013 NAEP
results, Florida's low - income 4th graders were tops in the nation for
reading achievement.
Study
results indicate that English - language learners (ELLs) in bilingual / ESL programs perform better in
reading and math
achievement compared to ELLs in English mainstream programs.
Our
results indicate that, on average, New York City's charter schools raise their 3rd through 8th graders» math
achievement by 0.09 of a standard score and
reading achievement by 0.04 of a standard score, compared with what would have happened had they remained in traditional public schools (see Figure 3).
Results from the latest cycle of the PIRLS assessment (that's the Progress in International
Reading Literacy Study) show the literacy
achievement of Year 4 students in Australia has improved.
From a scientific standpoint, three conclusions are valid about the
achievement results in
reading from the year 3 impact evaluation of the OSP:
Highlights of this year's NAPLAN
results include: • There is evidence of movement of students from lower to higher bands of
achievement across year levels and most domains over the last 10 years • Year 3
reading results continue to show sustained improvement • ACT, Victoria and NSW continue to have high mean
achievement across all domains • There are increases in mean
achievement in the Northern Territory in primary years
reading and numeracy since 2008 • WA and Queensland have the largest growth in mean
achievement across most domains since 2008 • Percentage of students meeting the national minimum standard remains high — over 90 per cent nationally and in most states and territories, across all domains and year levels
The PIRLS 2016
results and questionnaire also revealed that higher levels of enjoyment of
reading are associated with higher levels of
achievement, so long as students have books in the home.
• «All of which» means «some of which,» as the multi-year Louisiana study cited (of which I am co-author) reports no significant
achievement impacts of the program after three years and the Indiana study cited reports that the initial negative
results of that program turn positive in
reading by year four.
K - 12
Achievement (2016) The K - 12 Achievement Index scores states based on 18 distinct achievement measures related to reading and math performance, high school graduation rates, and the results of Advanced Place
Achievement (2016) The K - 12
Achievement Index scores states based on 18 distinct achievement measures related to reading and math performance, high school graduation rates, and the results of Advanced Place
Achievement Index scores states based on 18 distinct
achievement measures related to reading and math performance, high school graduation rates, and the results of Advanced Place
achievement measures related to
reading and math performance, high school graduation rates, and the
results of Advanced Placement exams.
If you are not persuaded by the evidence I reviewed yesterday on the disconnect between
achievement results and other outcomes, I suggest you read an excellent book written by Nobel Prize winning economist James Heckman and his students called The Myth of Achieve
achievement results and other outcomes, I suggest you
read an excellent book written by Nobel Prize winning economist James Heckman and his students called The Myth of
AchievementAchievement Tests.
In implementing
READS, districts must adopt a set of data use strategies that inform decision - making and help to improve student
achievement, such as examining spring to fall
achievement gains or losses and using the
results of student surveys and
achievement tests to select books that are well matched to students»
reading skills and interests.
In addition, a series of studies by David Grissmer and colleagues found that early math and
reading achievement tests are not even very good predictors of later test
results relative to other types of skills and more general knowledge.
On the basis of these survey
results, we created three measures: (1) the principal's overall assessment of the teacher's effectiveness, which is a single item from the survey; (2) the teacher's ability to improve student academic performance, which is a simple average of the organization, classroom management,
reading achievement, and math
achievement survey items; and (3) the teacher's ability to increase student satisfaction, which is a simple average of the role model and student satisfaction survey items.
State and national efforts to raise student
achievement are continuing to yield far greater progress in mathematics than in
reading, judged by the
results of the 2003 National Assessment of Educational Progress.
Recalling that black students have the lowest scores on both the
reading and math tests, one can see that these
results can be interpreted as the effects of peer
achievement.
Thomas Cook, writing in 1984, concludes that meta - analyses of
results from all the studies, taken together, support the view that the effects on the mathematics and
reading achievement in elementary school are quite small or even zero.
«The Effects of a Voluntary Summer
Reading Intervention on
Reading Achievement:
Results from a Randomized Field Trial.»
The only tests that got a modicum of respect were the Metropolitan
Achievement Tests, which were given in
reading and math at every grade level except kindergarten, with school - by - school
results published in the Boston newspapers.
In my
reading, I see this phrase «
achievement gap» as referring solely to
results on test scores.
What's disappointing is that 4th - grade
reading results have held steady since 2007 — after a big bump up (across all
achievement levels) from 2005 - 2007.
Results indicated that those students in the small class made greater gains in
reading achievement compared to those in the larger class.»
In contrast to the
results for math
achievement, we do not find any evidence that being evaluated increases the impact that teachers have on their students»
reading achievement.
They demonstrate that attending an oversubscribed charter middle or high school has a clear positive effect on students» math and
reading achievement, but also find that this «on - average»
result obscures dramatic variation.
Of course it has immense value in these areas, but it is just as relevant to improving attainment and
achievement in
reading, writing and mathematics, improving SATs and GCSE
results and helping children of all abilities and learning styles to achieve to their full potential.
Analysts have cited a legion of reasons for the state's slide in
achievement: the steady leaching of resources from the schools that was the inevitable
result of the infamous 1970s property - tax revolt led by Howard Jarvis; a long period of economic woes caused by layoffs in the defense industry; curriculum experiments with «whole language»
reading instruction and «new math» that were at best a distraction and at worst quite damaging; a school finance lawsuit that led to a dramatic increase in the state's authority over school budgets and operations; and a massive influx of new students and non-English-speaking immigrants that almost surely depressed test scores.
If you look at student
achievement data, say in New York state,
results on the typical New York state test correlate to socioeconomic status in
reading, one and a half to two times as much as they do in math.
So, if you've got good procedures for monitoring, for example, students»
results — whether it be
reading or mathematics or indicators of student wellbeing — then you know what your past
achievements have been.
Summary of
Results Predicting Later
Achievement With Earlier Math and
Reading Readiness and Socioemotional and Motor Skills
The
results indicated that children on average identified peers with stronger
reading skills and the positive association between peer
reading skills and children's own
reading achievement was strongest for children with lower initial levels of
reading skills.
The
results, however, also revealed wide disparities in
achievement among student groups, with 65 percent of English language learners, 46 percent...
read more
In 2005, Illinois Standard
Achievement Test
results for grades 3 through 8 showed a proficiency level of 76 percent in
reading and 81 percent in math.
We estimate racial / ethnic
achievement gaps in several hundred metropolitan areas and several thousand school districts in the United States using the
results of roughly 200 million standardized math and
reading tests administered to public school students from 2009 - 2013.
Together, these
results suggest that the accountability policy in Chicago led to a substantial increase in math and
reading achievement.
In the case study, Lavely describes the leadership responsibilities she has accepted and her team's
results: A set of classrooms fully proficient in both math and
reading — including students in special education and English language learners — and 70 percent of those students ranking in the top two
achievement categories on the 2011 — 12 state math exam, up from 52 percent the previous year.
Recent
results on our Nation's Report Card (the National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP), for example, tell us that during the NCLB era, student
achievement in
reading and math improved for African American, Hispanic, and white students alike, and
achievement gaps among these groups narrowed.
At the two year mark, they found no significant
achievement effects for students who were offered vouchers, but their third - year
results found voucher recipients making outsized
reading gains.
Last year, MDRC released
results of a randomized evaluation of a volunteer - based tutoring program,
Reading Partners, that increased reading achievement by 0.1 of a standard deviation for an out - of - pocket cost to the schools of only $ 320 per s
Reading Partners, that increased
reading achievement by 0.1 of a standard deviation for an out - of - pocket cost to the schools of only $ 320 per s
reading achievement by 0.1 of a standard deviation for an out - of - pocket cost to the schools of only $ 320 per student.
Reforms aimed at improving
reading achievement seem to have propelled Russia, Hong Kong, and Singapore from middle to top rankings on an international assessment of literacy skills, even as U.S. performance stood still, according to
results released last week.
While Virginia students again ranked among the nation's highest achievers, the 2009 NAEP
results for the commonwealth show that overall
achievement among Virginia fourth graders is similar to
achievement in 2002, while the overall average
reading score for eighth graders has declined.
The
results showed that not only were
reading and math
achievement highly corrected in fourth grade, but that there was a tendency for students with higher initial
reading scores to have higher mathematics growth rates over time.
The study also determined that the study
results can not be dismissed with claims that the students in the program performed worse because they were adjusting to a new school: «There was no statistically significant association between changing schools and student
achievement in
reading and mathematics.»
These
results support findings from earlier research that time spent in independent
reading in school does make a difference in students»
reading achievement (Anderson et al., 1988; Elley & Mangubhi, 1983; Taylor, Frye, & Maruyama, 1990).
Amid the intense debates about how much progress the nation has made in raising student
achievement and whether federal investments in education have produced
results, one important trend tends to be overlooked — namely, the notable gains made by African American and Latino students in
reading and math
achievement since 1971.