The net effect of this complex ruling is to validate genepatents as a legal concept but reject claims made by Myriad for diagnostically using the genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 to identify mutations that carry a high risk for breast and ovarian cancer.
He flatly rejected the position of the Obama Administration, whose Justice Department had filed a brief siding with those who argue for a sweeping rejection of genepatents.
The court also rejected an argument that Bowman was not liable because the beans themselves — and not the farmer — replicated Monsanto's patentedgenes.