However, any such effect, if it existed, would have had to have continued into the year after the experiment was over, when the credit gap between the statistics and
remedial algebra students widened.
Not exact matches
A new study finds that allowing
students to take a college - level statistics class instead of
remedial algebra has long - term benefits, starting with higher
student pass rates.
Envision runs four charters in Northern California, including one that piloted Khan Academy with a small program for
remedial -
algebra students last summer.
And researchers at CUNY find that if college
students assessed as needing
remedial algebra are instead placed directly into credit - bearing statistics and provided extra support, they are more likely to succeed in their first college - level quantitative course and complete more college credits overall.
College
students assessed as needing
remedial algebra more likely to succeed by instead taking credit - bearing statistics with additional support
In a new article for Education Next, Alexandra Logue and Mari Watanabe - Rose of City University of New York and Daniel Douglas of Rutgers University present evidence showing that if
students assessed as needing
remedial elementary
algebra are instead placed directly into a college - level statistics course with additional support, they are more likely to pass their initial college - level quantitative course and, after three semesters, more likely to have completed college - level credits than are
students placed in
remedial algebra courses.
By the end of Spring 2015, three semesters after the experiment's end, just 37 percent of
remedial elementary
algebra students had passed a college - level quantitative class, which is required for graduation, compared to 60 percent of
students placed directly into statistics.
In the fall of 2013, the researchers randomly assigned 907 freshman
students assessed as needing math remediation into one of three groups: traditional
remedial elementary
algebra; the same
algebra course with an additional two - hour weekly workshop; or a college - level statistics class with an additional two - hour weekly workshop.
Regardless of their race or ethnicity,
students with a wide range of incoming placement test scores did better in statistics with weekly workshops than their counterparts in noncredit
remedial elementary
algebra, with or without weekly workshops.
After four semesters in college, 60 percent had, compared to 37 percent of
students placed in the
remedial elementary
algebra class and 33 percent of
students who took
remedial elementary
algebra with workshops (Figure 3).
Incoming
students assessed as needing remediation were randomly assigned to one of three course types: traditional
remedial elementary
algebra; the same
algebra course with an additional two - hour weekly workshop; or a college - level statistics class with an additional two - hour weekly workshop.
More than one - third of
students placed in
remedial elementary
algebra — with or without workshops — still had not passed that class by the end of their second year of college.
Pass rates for
remedial elementary
algebra without workshops were similar during the study period and during the year before: 39 percent of study participants passed, compared to 37 percent of
students in fall 2012.
The participants in our experiment are broadly representative of all
students assessed as needing
remedial elementary
algebra.
Some entering
students who ordinarily would have been assigned to a
remedial elementary -
algebra class were placed instead in a college - level statistics course and provided with extra academic support.
For those
students to complete statistics within two semesters, they would have to pass
remedial algebra in the fall, return to college in the spring, and then pass statistics.
The pass rate in statistics for
students who have taken
remedial algebra is 68 percent.
We compared our participants with
students who did not consent to participate in the experiment but who had been assessed as needing remediation and who enrolled in other sections of
remedial elementary
algebra during the same semester as the experiment.
One year later, statistics
students were slightly more likely to persist in college: 66 percent were still enrolled in fall 2014 versus 62 percent of
students in
remedial elementary
algebra without workshops, though this difference was not statistically significant.
Students reported higher levels of engagement with the college - level statistics class, establishing more self - initiated study groups than students in the remedial algebra
Students reported higher levels of engagement with the college - level statistics class, establishing more self - initiated study groups than
students in the remedial algebra
students in the
remedial algebra classes.
The positive effect of taking statistics (relative to
remedial elementary
algebra without workshops) was similar across
students with a wide range of placement test scores (Figure 2).
Starting with
students entering high school in the fall of 1997, CPS eliminated lower - level and
remedial courses so that all first - time freshmen would enroll in
algebra in 9th grade, geometry in 10th grade, and
algebra II or trigonometry in 11th grade.
Pass rates are very low for community college
students placed in
remedial math, typically a review of elementary
algebra.