I know of no other field where a phone call from Trenberth results in an editor
resigning over a paper which went through the standard review process.
On the other hand, Wagner
resigned over a paper that has not been refuted or retracted.
«Three Journal Editors
Resign Over Paper by Skeptics,» The Heat is Online, July 29, 2003.
A few months ago, another journal's editor
resigned over a paper that should not have been accepted due to a poor peer review process.
Not exact matches
CNN: Jewish newspaper's editor
resigns over Obama assassination column A Jewish newspaper owner who attracted U.S. Secret Service attention for a column suggesting that Israel consider assassinating an American president has
resigned as the
paper's editor, employees there said Monday.
CNN: Vatican: Pope not
resigning over alleged
papers leak Pope Benedict XVI's spokesman has denied the pontiff will
resign over the arrest of his butler on suspicion of leaking confidential documents, the Vatican press office said Thursday.
Claire Udy who had
resigned from the party in a row
over anti-semitism last week, said she would serve as an independent despite being on the ballot
paper as a Labour candidate.
A NOTW staff member told The Independent that Ms Brooks dodged difficult questions: «She said: «I am not going to
resign because these are unproven allegations,» to which someone replied: «Well, you closed the
paper down
over these unproven allegations.»
In May, Nayfeh
resigned over the scandal at his journal, and SAGE contacted the authors of all 60 affected articles to let them know that the
papers would be retracted.
The editor - in - chief of the journal Remote Sensing has
resigned over the publication of a
paper questioning the reliability of climate models.
One of that biologist's colleagues at Hopkins has already
resigned from the journal's editorial board
over its decision to correct (and not retract) the
paper; last week, another 21 people told the journal they'd do the same.
Over a dozen editorial board members
resigned when a journal refused to retract a
paper.
on
Over a dozen editorial board members
resigned when a journal refused to retract a
paper.
Continue reading
Over a dozen editorial board members
resigned when a journal refused to retract a
paper.
It should be noted that the controversial 2003
paper that Soon co-authored was so bad that half of the editorial board of the journal in which it was published
resigned in protest
over the journal's handling of that
paper.
It is well known that there have been some glitches in the peer review: a
paper by Soon and Baliunas (2003) caused the resignation of several editors from the journal Climate Research (Kinne 2003), and Wagner (Wagner et al. 2011)
resigned from the editorship of Remote Sensing
over the publication of a
paper by Spencer and Braswell (2010).
I have been up to my neck for
over a year in a huge row with Iannis Kominis about the underlying quantum mechanics of spin sensing chemical reactions, and either his
papers or mine (or just possibly both) are complete nonsense: but nobody has
resigned over Koniminis's
paper in Phys Rev B or mine in Chem Phys Lett.
Six of the journal's editors
resigned over the publication of this
paper.
Minority committee chair Jim Jeffers would create it when he read into the record the startling revelation that fully half of the editorial board of Energy and Environment had just
resigned in protest
over the «failed editorial process» which had allowed the publication of such a badly compromised
paper.