After reviewing the law on
reversing findings of fact by a trial judge, Justice Epstein wrote, «The trial judge's conclusion that Ms. Weddell had no reason to doubt the Scherbaks» representations was «clearly wrong».
In other words, if the appellate judges believe the lower court got the law wrong, they will reverse its decision; but they will only
reverse a finding of fact if the lower court made an especially egregious or obvious mistake.
Not exact matches
In
fact, keep reading to
find out how each
of these people
reversed their leaky gut and now enjoy a life
of health they previously only wished for.
What makes his
findings even more disappointing is that it's
reverse sexism: The majority
of those criticizing the looks
of the women on air are, in
fact, women.
This is perhaps most noticeable when
reversing out
of a parking space: several times I pushed the throttle to back up and
found it so unresponsive that I looked down at the shift lever to make sure I had remembered to engage
reverse gear — which I had, in
fact, done.
In
fact, a practitioner
of value investing tries to
find a situation which is
reverse of an auction.
The Virginia Court
of Appeals first restated the rule that it will not
reverse the divorce court's discretion in fashioning an equitable distribution award unless it appears from the record that the divorce court abused its discretion, failed to consider or misapplied the factors in the equitable distribution statute, Virginia Code Section 20 - 107.3 (E), or made essential
fact findings unsupported by the evidence.
Appellate Decision: As no new
facts came to light after the initial contempt
finding had been made, the principle
of finality must be respected and Rule 60.11 did not permit the motion judge to revisit or
reverse her initial
finding of contempt.
One is to make copious
findings of fact (especially on credibility) that are hard to
reverse on appeal and alternative
findings.
In a 3 - 2 decision the Supreme Court
reversed the family court
finding that Garcia's «subjective fear for her safety does not warrant issuance
of the order
of protection, particularly given the
facts that it was more than one month between the incident and the final hearing, Saski had moved out
of the house, and the parties had had absolutely no contact in the interim.»
On this interlocutory review, the Georgia Court
of Appeals
found that the Recreational Property Act did, in
fact, immunize SMMA from liability, and it
reversed.
Had another judge sentenced Sedore to 84 months without
finding those additional
facts, the court
of appeals would likely
reverse this hypothetical sentence as unreasonable.
(3) If a jury
find of fact is against the evidence, courts have frequently
reversed juries (eg see New York HLD, v. 30, n. 4), however, they are not supposed to do so, unless the verdict is a gross miscarriage
of justice.
These authorities are not to be taken as meaning that the
findings of fact made at trial are immutable, but rather that they are not to be
reversed unless it can be established that the learned trial judge made some palpable and overriding error which affected his assessment
of the
facts.
In Benson v. Northwest Airlines, Inc., the Eighth Circuit
reversed summary judgment as it
found the plaintiff (1) made a prima facie case that he was able to perform the essential functions
of his position, and (2) created a genuine issue
of fact as to whether the airline had an existing vacant position which he could have filled.
While the court agreed that it is possible the Purchaser could claim that the Seller was estopped from claiming title defects which would have prevented the closing when it had misrepresented the status
of the title in the purchase agreement, the court ruled that the bankruptcy court had failed to make sufficient
findings of fact in support
of this ruling and so
reversed the equitable estoppel ruling, sending the case back to the trial court for further proceedings.
Agawam Realty v. Haggerty (223 A.D. 2d 518)- summary judgment for broker's commission
reversed; material issues
of fact exist as to whether broker procured a buyer who was ready, willing and able to purchase; seller accepts second offer after initial buyer failed to sign contract and tender deposit within 8 days
of receipt
of contract which was based on terms
of offer made by buyer in Purchase Memorandum; issue
of fact as to whether buyer was willing to purchase as measured by whether buyer was provided reasonable time to sign contract and tender deposit; dissent
finds broker earned commission prior to seller's determination buyer was unwilling to purchase.