AIDWYC suggests that an independent review body «would remove all political considerations from the review of applications submitted to it» and eliminate «the incompatible roles of the Minister as Chief Prosecutor and as the person to
review wrongful convictions.»
An independent state commission would
review wrongful convictions and determine who's to blame.
The group in 2009 formed a committee composed of district attorneys to oversee best practices and
review wrongful convictions while also recommending procedures to strengthen truth seeking functions.
Not exact matches
Zeff was serving as a senior advisor to the AG and was on track to direct a new bureau to
review potential
wrongful convictions that Schneiderman announced in April.
After
reviewing 30 cases of potential
wrongful imprisonment for murder from the tenure of his controversial predecessor Charles Hynes, Brooklyn District Attorney Kenneth Thompson's office has begun to investigate the former prosecutor's non-homicide felony
convictions, too.
Thompson created an internal unit to
review and exonerate
wrongful convictions, a clear rebuke to Hynes» leadership.
He also pushed his
Conviction Review Unit to examine old cases to overturn
wrongful convictions.
He put Eric Gonzalez in charge of setting up the unit, which to date has overturned 22
wrongful convictions, with another 100 cases under
review.
One of the ABA Center for Innovation's projects is the Distributed Forensic Expert Network Delegating
Review (DFENDER) a joint project with the software developer Relativity, where e-discovery software and a network of forensic and legal experts are used to identify
wrongful conviction trends.
For example,
conviction review units have been set up by prosecutors throughout the U.S. for the sole purpose of making certain that
wrongful convictions are identified and corrected.
Regardless of the approach adopted, there are compelling reasons to believe that an independent
review body that is knowledgeable in cases of
wrongful convictions, has special administrative powers, and possesses expertise in
reviewing claims is a far more effective way of addressing claims of miscarriages of justice than the current model.
The manner in which causes of
wrongful convictions are studied and what recommendations are presented to eradicate them are largely dependent on the effectiveness of the
review process that investigates
wrongful convictions.
AIDWYC contends that Canadian cases of alleged
wrongful convictions should «not [be] examined from the adversarial perspective of trying to show that the convicted person was rightfully treated by the court system» as occurs at present through the Minister of Justice's current practice under section 696.1147 Rather, AIDWYC argues that an independent
review board like CCRC should «undertake a fresh
review without bias.»
The statutory threshold test for the referral of an application ensures that the Court of Appeal
reviews all possible
wrongful convictions.
The low threshold test is consistent with an intention to seek out allegations of
wrongful conviction, and to ensure that they are
reviewed by the courts where there is a real possibility of success.
Anyone claiming to have experienced a
wrongful conviction may apply to the CCRC for case
review, with or without the aid of a solicitor.
I recommend that, in the future, there should be a completely independent entity established which can effectively, efficiently, and quickly
review cases in which
wrongful conviction is alleged.
Once these judicial avenues have been exhausted, section 696.1 of the Criminal Code of Canada (the «Criminal Code») allows the Minister of Justice to
review alleged
wrongful convictions.
Despite the public awareness of
wrongful conviction cases in Canada and the calls by advocates and organizations for an independent body to investigate such cases, the Minister of Justice has determined that «an independent body for
conviction review [is] not needed in Canada.»
An independent
review process in Canada would play a vital role in restoring public confidence in the criminal justice system that has been shaken by the number of
wrongful convictions.
Wrongful Convictions and the Avenues of Redress: The Post-Conviction
Review Process in Canada (2015) 20 Appeal 5
This committee is responsible for
reviewing Pennsylvania's
wrongful conviction cases and identifying its causes and possible remedies.
April 2014 - Philadelphia DA Creates Unit to
Review Wrongful -
Conviction Claims: The Legal Intelligencer
As reported in the Pittsburgh Times -
Review, the Pennsylvania Commission on
Wrongful Convictions, commissioned by the State Legislature in 2006, is due to release its report «by summer's end.»
Innocence Project of Florida,
Conviction integrity units, district attorneys office, innocent, ken thompson, larry krasner, Louis Scarcella, sentence review units, vanessa gathers, wrongful
Conviction integrity units, district attorneys office, innocent, ken thompson, larry krasner, Louis Scarcella, sentence
review units, vanessa gathers,
wrongful convictionconviction
«Contemporary Perspectives on
Wrongful Conviction: An Introduction to the 2016 Innocence Network Conference, San Antonio, Texas,» Hofstra Law
Review 45, no. 2 (Winter 2016): 365 (co-authored with Aliza B. Kaplan, Valena Beety, and Keith A. Findley).
The
Conviction Integrity Unit reviews claims of innocence or wrongful conviction resulting from prosecutions by the Cook County State's Att
Conviction Integrity Unit
reviews claims of innocence or
wrongful conviction resulting from prosecutions by the Cook County State's Att
conviction resulting from prosecutions by the Cook County State's Attorney's...
The proposed reforms Grewal has decided to pursue include creating a
conviction review unit to examine
wrongful conviction claims and help prevent innocent people Read more here
Database of hundreds of books, law
review articles, movies and documentaries related to
wrongful convictions