Not exact matches
I presume it was, as the timing makes sense, and you are thanked for your
comments in the acknowledgments
along with two others (presumably also
reviewers).
A helpful
reviewer from Irvine, CA
comments that she needs a stroller she can use to walk her dogs
along with her baby and the Revolution is great.
The Gold Star rating was determined by considering each program's total score
along with the number of recommendations submitted for the program and the tenor of
reviewers»
comments about it.
I believe that WG1 review
comments (
with names of
reviewers), and the author responses, will be published when the full copy - edited report comes out in January,
along with the First and Second Order Drafts of the chapters — this will enable people to see what the
comments referred to, and how the authors addresses those
comments.
If the skeptics are actually being shut out of journals, then they could provide evidence of such by producing the papers that they submitted and were then rejected,
along with the
reviewers»
comments.
The editor can then weigh that point of view
along with the
comments of the other
reviewers.