Risks of raw diets can include nutritional excesses and / or deficiencies, gastrointestinal perforation or obstruction from bones and food safety issues including salmonella infection.
The risks of raw diets have been acknowledged in numerous studies published in veterinary journals.
Not exact matches
Experts are warning dog and cat owners to be aware
of the
risks associated with feeding their pets
raw meat - based
diets (RMBDs), instead
of the more conventional dry or canned pet foods.
You also need to take into account the
risks of eating
raw fish when considering including it in your
diet.
Because
of the
risk of bacterial infection from
raw eggs, we don't recommend regular inclusion
of them in the
diet, anyway.
Experts say: «There's no doubt that plant - based
diets have been linked with a lower
risk of obesity and other chronic diseases, but because the
raw - foods
diet is so restrictive, its followers are at
risk for deficiencies
of vitamin B12 and omega - 3 fatty acids if they don't take supplements,» says Andrea N. Giancoli, M.P.H., R.D., a spokesperson for the American Dietetic Association in Los Angeles.
A 2005 study in Archives
of Internal Medicine reported that
raw - foods -
diet followers had significantly lower body - mass indices (a measure
of body fat) than people consuming a typical American
diet; they also had lower bone densities, a
risk factor for osteoporosis.
For instance, If I take the recommended dosage
of FCOL and 2
raw pastured organic egg yolks daily, would this offer the right balance
of 3's to 6's in my daily
diet to avoid any potential
risks?
To find out how the veggie might affect colon cancer
risk, the researchers fed three groups
of pigs one
of three
diets for 13 weeks: a high - calorie
diet, a high - calorie
diet supplemented with
raw or baked purple potatoes, and a standard control
diet.
Risks Of Feeding Puppies Kibbles Feeding puppies kibbles or a
raw food
diet.
To me, feeding
raw bones (excluding fish) is an acceptable
risk compared to the certainty
of gum disease, tartar and tooth loss from an unnatural / improper
diet.
Homemade
diets and commercial BARF
diets are often demonstrable unbalanced and have severe nutritional deficiencies or excesses.16 - 18 Dogs have been shown to acquire and shed parasitic organisms and potentially lethal infectious diseases associated with
raw meat, including pathogenic strains
of E. coli and Salmonella.25 - 27 Many other pathogens have been identified in
raw diets or
raw meat ingredients, and these represent a
risk not only to the dogs fed these
diets but to their owners, particularly children and people with compromised immune systems.29 - 30 The bones often included in such
diets can cause fractured teeth and gastrointestinal diseases, including obstructed or perforated intestines, and the FDA recently warned pet owners against feeding bones to their canine companions.
So with a dodgy theory behind it, no sound evidence
of benefits, and clear
risks, there is no justification for recommending
raw meat based
diets for dogs.
The
risk of Salmonella shedding by dogs fed Salmonella - contaminated commercial
raw food
diets.
Certainly,
raw meat and bones are often used as enrichment items or bait for husbandry purposes, but always with an awareness
of the
risks they pose, and never as the primary
diet.
Joffe, D., Schlesinger, D. Preliminary assessment
of the
risk of Salmonella infection in dogs fed
raw chicken
diets.
While dog owners are somewhat split over the health benefits and
risks of feeding a
raw food
diet, most veterinarians agree that
raw feeding has more
risks than benefits.
Avoid
raw food
diets for FIV - positive cats to reduce the
risk of food - borne illness.
On top
of the low
risk, you have facts: the Merck Veterinary Manual notes that 21 to 41 percent
of raw chicken for HUMANS is contaminated with Salmonella, and 36 percent
of healthy dogs and 70 percent
of healthy cats, regardless
of their
diet, have salmonella bacteria in their digestive system anyway.
Raw diets are popular but most experts believe the risks of bacterial and viral contamination in feeding your pet raw meat overrides the value of a homemade di
Raw diets are popular but most experts believe the
risks of bacterial and viral contamination in feeding your pet
raw meat overrides the value of a homemade di
raw meat overrides the value
of a homemade
diet.
«FDA does not believe
raw meat foods for animals are consistent with the goal
of protecting the public from significant health
risks, particularly when such products are brought into the home and / or used to feed domestic pets; however, we understand that some people prefer to feed these types
of diets to their pets.»
So, while the benefit
of raw diet is unproven, the
risks to health are inherent and well documented.
Raw and home - cooked
diets are unlikely to meet your dog's needs, and you run the
risk of making your family ill, warns Cruz.
The AVMA recommends that veterinarians inform pet owners
of potential
risks and educate them on how to best mitigate the
risk of pathogen exposure in both handling the food and in managing pets consuming undercooked or
raw animal - source protein
diets.»
For one thing, some veterinarians and animal nutritionists question the safety
of feeding pets
raw meat and bones — there is also the
risk for food - borne illness and contamination to affect the people preparing the
raw food
diet.
Advocates
of the BARF
diet (a.k.a. Biologically Appropriate
Raw Food diet or Bones And Raw Food diet) suggest that by feeding raw meat, the gastric pH is lowered enough to kill any potential pathogenic bacteria on the food; this is also oftentimes false, thus putting these pets at ri
Raw Food
diet or Bones And
Raw Food diet) suggest that by feeding raw meat, the gastric pH is lowered enough to kill any potential pathogenic bacteria on the food; this is also oftentimes false, thus putting these pets at ri
Raw Food
diet) suggest that by feeding
raw meat, the gastric pH is lowered enough to kill any potential pathogenic bacteria on the food; this is also oftentimes false, thus putting these pets at ri
raw meat, the gastric pH is lowered enough to kill any potential pathogenic bacteria on the food; this is also oftentimes false, thus putting these pets at
risk.
Neither commercial nor
raw diet manufacturers were contacted during development
of this policy because it was based on public health
risk, and not on nutritional comparisons, health benefits, or economic factors.
They should be fed nutritionally complete and balanced
diets, and uncooked food, such as
raw meat and eggs, and unpasteurized dairy products should be avoided to minimize the
risk of food - borne bacterial and parasitic infections.
In a
raw diet ground bone poses less
risk to your dog as it won't cause any perforations
of your dog's gastrointestinal system.
PICO questionIn adult dogs, does feeding a
raw food
diet alter urine composition compared to a kibble
diet?Clinical bottom lineThe evidence provided by the single study identified is weak and the outcomes can neither support nor challenge the hypothesis that a
raw food
diet increases the
risk of urinary calculi compared to a kibble
diet.
As much as
raw diets can appear beneficial, with many dog owners reporting improved health and longevity, the American College
of Veterinary Nutrition warns there are always
risks for nutritional imbalances.
While advocates
of raw food
diets say unprocessed foods are a natural and healthy option for feeding pets, others say the health
risks involved should not be overlooked.
The
risk of disease to cats due to not feeding a
raw meat
diet is far greater.
Raw food
diets tend to preserve more
of the natural nutrient content
of the ingredients but it puts your dog at a greater
risk for food - borne illness.
My personal feeling is that there are more
risks of bacterial and viral contamination in feeding a
raw diet than there are conceivable health benefits (ref).
While it is possible to provide a nutritionally complete
raw food
diet, there is significant
risk of bacterial contamination with uncooked foods and this poses
risk of food - borne disease to your pet as well as the food preparer and anyone who may come in contact with the
raw food or equipment / surfaces used for preparation.
Our family needs the convenience
of a kibble, and as a healthcare professional a will not feed
raw diet in my home d / t
risk of infection.
The
risk of illnesses such as Salmonella or E-Coli associated with
raw meat do exist, and we are at more
risk than our dogs when feeding a
raw diet.
These
risks are more
of a concern with home - prepared
raw diets but are also associated with commercially available
raw diets as well.
Freeman, Lisa M., et al. «Current Knowledge about the
Risks and Benefits
of Raw Meat - Based
Diets for Dogs and Cats.»
Experts are warning dog and cat owners to be aware
of the
risks associated with feeding their pets
raw meat - based
diets (RMBDs), instead
of the more conventional dry or canned pet foods.
Raw food
diets are controversial, as they put dogs at
risk of contracting illness from bacteria, choking on bones or suffering internal injuries from bone splinters.
Choosing to feed a
raw diet, however can carry significant health
risks to both pets and people, and if the
diet is not formulated properly,
raw food and homemade
diets can cause serious nutritional deficiencies and predispose pets to a variety
of chronic illnesses.
Finally, in July 2012, the FDA wrapped up a conclusive study that found a high
risk of salmonella and listeria bacterias in
raw dog food
diets.
Also, please be aware that there are no scientific studies showing any health benefits
of raw meat
diets, and these
diets pose a significant
risk of bacterial contamination.
Raw Diets and the
Risk of Exposure to Pathogens: Fair warning, this section may be a little tough to stomach (wink):
Raw diets are not suggested for these pets because with the increased
risk of aspirating regurgitated stomach contents, bacteria in the unprocessed food can be a
risk.
The AVMA was encouraged by the Delta Society and the Council on Public Health and Regulatory Veterinary Medicine to make a policy statement concerning the public health
risk of feeding pets
raw food
diets adapted from the Delta Society's own position on the matter that forbids members to feed
raw food to their dogs.
There are
risks and concerns associated with the feeding
of raw diets.
One
of these is the
risk of nutritional imbalances, which is a reality for both home - prepared and commercial
raw meat
diets.