He almost occupied
the role of a defensive midfielder in Gasperini's side.
However, as the 13 assists created by Steven Gerrard puts a limelight on an attacking
role of a defensive midfielder, Liverpool fans might be looking towards their new signing to show at least glimpses of the same mantra in his 1st season and the two - footed German has plenty to offer in this respect.
Not exact matches
With the emergence
of Francis Coquelin as Arsenal's first - choice
defensive midfielder and with the likes
of Aaron Ramsey, Jack Wilshere and even Santi Cazorla, who has grown accustomed to playing a deeper
role, fighting for a place alongside the young Frenchman, the Gunners captain will certainly find it difficult to get into the first - team.
The
midfield is a diamond arrangement with Ozil at the north
of the diamond, Carzola and Xhaka on the sharing the deep lying
role in the west and the east
of the diamond and Coquelin on the south
of the diamond as
defensive midfield.
But his age is making me to panic
of his manning the Gunners
defensive holding
midfield role against the speedy Barca's pouncers in Feb Ucl clash at the Ems in Feb next year.
Despite Antonio Valencia's tremendous start to the season, Mourinho has little full - back options to choose from and so signing 23 - year - old Fabinho — who can also play in a
defensive midfield role — would undoubtedly bolster this area and thus the strength
of the overall squad.
You cant escape he fact that Podolski was played rarely and when he was he was played out
of position much the same way that Wenger has assembled a squad
of players most
of which are a talented bunch, but, Wenger has failed to build a team who fit n with each other, we have a
midfield that overtly populated with players who al excel in the same
role BUT have no solid
defensive midfield talent and no options in defence when players have crap periods or are long term injury problems.
Meanwhile, should he arrive from Leicester, N'Golo Kante would become the natural
defensive midfielder that would do the key
role, allowing Cesc Fabregas to provide some help on both sides
of the pitch.
It literally takes pretty much all the strengths away from our world - class triangle
of Mesut, Santi and Ozil to place a struggling for form Campbell in a more attacking
role when the part
of his
role he's been doing best is providing extra
defensive cover, while making us weaker in
midfield when our strongest
midfielder has been injured!!
Another impressive
defensive midfielder, Daley Blind can also fill in as a left - back, so may not have too much to worry about with Gundogan's arrival, even if his best
role has perhaps been in front
of the back four.
Defensive midfield Arteta, flamini, coqulan To get a top def mid we would have needed to get rid
of flamini n coqulan who would be ideal for the emergency left back
role vermaelen played.
I think he can play everywhere in the
midfield — certainly not in a
defensive role — but all the other positions are not out
of reach for him.»
Xhaka has his qualities, but playing the
defensive midfielder role like Kante does, is not one
of them.
At the moment I would not need to take a gooner vote to find out which player would make their starting 11 in that
defensive midfield role out
of him, Arteta and Flamini.
I maintain Ramsey s more
of a curse than a blessing... no10
role is nt jes fr him.He shud stick more to keeping d
midfield together n his
defensive input... Walcott still nt convincing enough... jes need som1 exciting up front for once... not jes speed
of even hold up play... itz gotten us this far, need sth diff yet again... And som1 pls tap Ox, the game s started!
The Wingers will provide support to the three - man
midfield of Elneny or Xhaka (I would go with Elneny right now) in the
defensive midfield role; Ramsey in the Vieira
role — Yes, our Vieira, if well motivated, is Ramsey — and Ozil in the attacking
midfield role.
We're covered in terms
of numbers in the
defensive midfield role, though I'd like to see the quality improve.
Roberto has shone for Barcelona in a number
of midfield and
defensive roles, and Don Balon reported that he was considering his future at the club.
442 diamond - like formation might work if we had the base
of the diamond as a dedicated
defensive midfielder role with Coquelin (or new addition, or even perhaps Elneny), playmaker at the top
of the diamond, the side operating like wingers (or falling back for more
defensive cover as required) and two strikers.
Talking
of people being critical
of AR I was interested listening to Keown last night on MOTD2 where he almost seemed reluctant to praise FC but was very keen to highlight AR's
role (and SC's) in the improved Arsenal
defensive set - up in
midfield.
This is an incredibly difficult question to answer for a variety
of reasons, most importantly because over the years our once vaunted «beautiful» style
of play has become a shadow
of it's former self, only to be replaced by a less than stellar «plug and play» mentality where players play out
of position and adjustments / substitutions are rarely forthcoming before the 75th minute... if you look at our current players, very few would make sense in the traditional Wengerian system... at present, we don't have the personnel to move the ball quickly from deep - lying position, efficient one touch
midfielders that can make the necessary through balls or the disciplined and pacey forwards to stretch defences into wide positions, without the aid
of the backs coming up into the final 3rd, so that we can attack the
defensive lanes in the same clinical fashion we did years ago... on this current squad, we have only 1 central defender on staf, Mustafi, who seems to have any prowess in the offensive zone or who can even pass two zones through so that we can advance play quickly out
of our own end (I have seen some inklings that suggest Holding might have some offensive qualities but too early to tell)... unfortunately Mustafi has a tendency to get himself in trouble when he gets overly aggressive on the ball... from our backs out wide, we've seen pace from the likes
of Bellerin and Gibbs and the spirited albeit offensively stunted play
of Monreal, but none
of these players possess the skill - set required in the offensive zone for the new Wenger scheme which requires deft touches, timely runs to the baseline and consistent crossing, especially when Giroud was playing and his ratio
of scored goals per clear chances was relatively low (better last year though)... obviously I like Bellerin's future prospects, as you can't teach pace, but I do worry that he regressed last season, which was obvious to Wenger because there was no way he would have used Ox as the right side wing - back so often knowing that Barcelona could come calling in the off - season, if he thought otherwise... as for our
midfielders, not a single one, minus the more confident Xhaka I watched played for the Swiss national team a couple years ago, who truly makes sense under the traditional Wenger model... Ramsey holds onto the ball too long, gives the ball away cheaply far too often and abandons his
defensive responsibilities on a regular basis (doesn't score enough recently to justify): that being said, I've always thought he does possess a little something special, unfortunately he thinks so too... Xhaka is a little too slow to ever boss the
midfield and he tends to telegraph his one true strength, his long ball play: although I must admit he did get a bit better during some points in the latter part
of last season... it always made me wonder why whenever he played with Coq Wenger always seemed to play Francis in a more advanced
role on the pitch... as for Coq, he is way too reckless at the wrong times and has exhibited little offensive prowess yet finds himself in and around the box far too often... let's face it Wenger was ready to throw him in the trash heap when injuries forced him to use Francis and then he had the nerve to act like this was all part
of a bigger Wenger constructed plan... he like Ramsey, Xhaka and Elneny don't offer the skills necessary to satisfy the quick transitory nature
of our old offensive scheme or the stout
defensive mindset needed to protect the
defensive zone so that our offensive players can remain aggressive in the final third... on the front end, we have Ozil, a player
of immense skill but stunted by his physical demeanor that tends to offend, the fact that he's been played out
of position far too many times since arriving and that the players in front
of him, minus Sanchez, make little to no sense considering what he has to offer (especially Giroud); just think about the quick counter-attack offence in Real or the space and protection he receives in the German National team's
midfield, where teams couldn't afford to focus too heavily on one individual... this player was a passing «specialist» long before he arrived in North London, so only an arrogant or ignorant individual would try to reinvent the wheel and / or not surround such a talent with the necessary components... in regards to Ox, Walcott and Welbeck, although they all possess serious talents I see them in large part as headless chickens who are on the injury table too much, lack the necessary first - touch and / or lack the finishing flair to warrant their inclusion in a regular starting eleven; I would say that,
of the 3, Ox showed the most upside once we went to a back 3, but even he became a bit too consumed by his pending contract talks before the season ended and that concerned me a bit... if I had to choose one
of those 3 players to stay on it would be Ox due to his potential as a plausible alternative to Bellerin in that wing - back position should we continue to use that formation... in Sanchez, we get one
of the most committed skill players we've seen on this squad for some years but that could all change soon, if it hasn't already
of course... strangely enough, even he doesn't make sense given the constructs
of the original Wenger offensive model because he holds onto the ball too long and he will give the ball up a little too often in the offensive zone... a fact that is largely forgotten due to his infectious energy and the fact that the numbers he has achieved seem to justify the means... finally, and in many ways most crucially, Giroud, there is nothing about this team or the offensive system that Wenger has traditionally employed that would even suggest such a player would make sense as a starter... too slow, too inefficient and way too easily dispossessed... once again, I think he has some special skills and, at times, has showed some world - class qualities but he's lack
of mobility is an albatross around the necks
of our offence... so when you ask who would be our best starting 11, I don't have a clue because
of the 5 or 6 players that truly deserve a place in this side, 1 just arrived, 3 aren't under contract beyond 2018 and the other was just sold to Juve... man, this is theraputic because following this team is like an addiction to heroin without the benefits
That leaves the box - to - box
role and the
defensive midfielder, unless our manager elects to play a sort
of double pivot to protect the weakened defence.
Fabinho has largely played central
midfield in a
defensive role for Monaco this season, though he has also shown himself capable
of playing in defence in the past.
Jose Mourinho has been using Pogba less in recent games, suggesting perhaps that there's a lack
of trust in the player after his struggles to adapt to a more
defensive midfield role for the Red Devils.
To put the burden
of that pivotal
defensive midfield role on coquelin alone seems to be a faulty plan to me.
Eric Dier, 22, who joined Spurs from Sporting Lisbon in the summer
of 2014 has excelled since being deployed as a
defensive -
midfielder and is thriving in his new
role alongside Moussa Dembele.
3) Chambers, is the very first variation, he plays just ahead
of the Centre back pair in the first amphibian
role of Half Centre back — Half
Defensive Midfield.
Although it is not yet clear where the versatile Daley Blind will play, he looks well suited to the
defensive midfield role for United, and a similar style
of player to Chelsea's Nemanja Matic, though it is the Serbian who is surely the better player based on his superb performances since re-joining the Blues in January.
Also, we know that Wenger has not really agreed with our need for a tough tackling
defensive midfielder, as proved by his use
of Mikel Arteta in the
role.
The fact is that Arsenal are blessed with an amazing array
of attacking
midfielders, and especially have Cazorla (Wenger's Player -
of - last - season) and Alexis Sanchez who are more than capable
of making the No 10
role their own next season, while we are desperate for a more
defensive - minded
midfielder to share the burden with Francis Coquelin.
Wenger has no concept
of defensive coaching — none whatsoever and frequently plays attacking players out
of position, even giving attacking
midfielders the
midfield anchor
role as in the case
of Arteta.
If Iwobi can work on his
defensive game, putting tackles in and having the right stamina, He should be ahead
of Ramsey in that central
midfield role.
It seems as though the debate about Arsenal and the
defensive midfield role will go on as long as water is wet, or at least as long as Arsene Wenger is the manager
of the Gunners.
He will be faster, more penetrative, some goals in there and will shield the four back players not out
of brute force but intelligence... He will not be a
defensive midfielder, but a deep positioned play maker... A Xavi
of Barcelona and the 4.1.4.1 AW attempted and found Arteta too isolated could now work with a hard working Ramsey... imagine a 25 year old Arteta converted to his present
role... definately he would be more effective than what we have today.
Arsenal are in great need
of a
defensive midfielder, a position that has been a problem for them all season and Ginter, originally a centre back, has slotted into the
role with a natural ease.
Khedira won the Champions League in May and then played a prominent
role in Germany's World Cup triumph over the summer and is therefore clearly a quality performer and perhaps the ideal man to balance out the heaps
of midfield creativity at Arsenal with some much needed
defensive nous.
Our
midfield no longer picks itself, but I expect Wenger to opt for the most
defensive approach
of fielding Francis Coquelin alongside new signing Granit Xhaka from the start
of the match, and possibly even playing Mohamed Elneny in a box - to - box
role to stop our opponents from trying to over-run us on the break.
Ozil needs to be played more centrally if we hope to benefit from his creativity with the ball and Welbeck's first touch is far too sloppy to be played along side Lacazette... we need to find a formation which allows more service to those making runs from the middle
of the pitch... Lacazette can not play so much with his back to goal or we're simply playing the same unsuccessful offensive scheme we played with Giroud, who is much better in that type
of role... I can only hope we keep Sanchez and purchase a true
defensive midfielder then switch to a 4 -4-1-1, which allows us to have Ozil play more centrally with Sead and Sanchez on the left side and Ox and Bellerin on the right, which would stretch defences so much that we could overwhelm most opponents with both runs in behind and overlapping runs out wide
I think that's his best position has he has the technical skills for it, but every creative / attacking
midfielder believes that is their best position because
of the freedom the
role allows and the reduced
defensive duties due to the
role being that essentially
of a 2nd striker in a 442 or 4411, leaving the bulk
of defending to 2 CMs.
During his time at Southampton, Chambers typically played the
role of a right back for his side but has primarily focused on a centre back or
defensive midfield role at the Gunners.
A highly promising young
midfielder who also operates well in a number
of defensive roles, Emre Can has proven a very astute buy by the Merseysiders.
Godoy plays much more as a number six
defensive midfielder with Panama, but the more free - roaming
role he has in San Jose also allows him to direct the action on both sides
of the ball.
Mourinho has the guts to play David Luiz a CB as a
defensive midfielder but Wenger has no vision
of playing Vermaleen a team Captain in that
role.
Depending on the situation, both have played more as a pair
of number sixes — true
defensive midfielders — and at other times they have switched
roles to take on the number eight attacking
midfielder position.
Despite graduating from the Centre
of Excellence as a central
midfielder, the 19 - year - old has adapted to
defensive roles at centre back and full back this season.
Coquelin was a revelation in
midfield for Arsenal during the second half
of last season, claiming the
defensive -
midfield role.
Trent Alexander - Arnold and Andy Robertson are developing into key men at full - back, and in front
of them on Tuesday, Wijnaldum proved an able deputy for the suspended captain Jordan Henderson in the
defensive midfield role.
Key to his exclusion is the variety
of options available to the coach, especially players who can play in more than one
role like Shehu Abdullahi and Wilfred Ndidi unlike Esiti who is only best as a
defensive midfielder.
In front
of him, Jordan Henderson has featured less frequently in the league since Christmas due to injury and rotation, and less playing time for the club captain in the
defensive -
midfield role has correlated with the uptick in
defensive performance.
It is looking like a repeat
of the three year search for a right back that only ended with the signing
of Pablo Zabaleta — who ironically may now be asked to cover in a
defensive midfield role.