While rail may be considered
safer than a pipeline, I don't find that argument compelling when considered in the context of the math of climate change.
Not exact matches
They argued transporting crude by
pipeline would be
safer than alternatives like rail, and charged Obama with hypocrisy for complaining about the lack of investment in U.S. infrastructure while obstructing an $ 8 billion project.
One spill is too many but
pipelines are much
safer than rail for transporting oil By Kenneth P. Green, Elmira Aliakbari and Ashley Stedman The Fraser Institute State regulators in... Read more»
The nation's aging oil
pipelines are roughly 70 times
safer than trucks when it comes to transporting fuel.
In one piece, Orr writes that, «
pipelines are much
safer than many other human activities, including «
safe sex»».
One would think that passage of Keystone XL would also meet with the Sierra Club's approval, as well, for several reasons: Wealthier countries and populaces generally protect their enviroonment better
than poorer ones; Sierra Club executives and members inevitable all use petroleum products (unless they are living «off the grid»); and
pipelines are a proven
safe method of transporting oil.
In fact, the State Department noted that other options of getting oil from Canada to the Gulf Coast are generally worse for the environment, a point that was revisited by TransCanada's CEO Russ Girling who pointed to statistics showing that
pipelines are a
safer way to transport oil
than rail, barge, or truck.
They also say
pipelines are a
safer method of transporting oil
than trains, pointing to recent cases of oil train derailments.
Older
pipelines, which have undergone decades of wear and corrosion, can be more prone to leaks, and thus less
safe,
than new
pipelines — especially
pipelines carrying corrosive dilbit at higher temperatures.
One of the arguments used by supporters of the Keystone XL
pipeline is that
pipelines are
safer than transporting the oil via the rail roads, as is currently being done.
He totally opposed running a
pipeline to Kitimat, B.C., from Alberta, despite the fact
pipelines are
safer than rail cars (duh again!)