Laurene Saunders, a member of the Champlain Valley Educational Services Board of Cooperative Educational Services,
said measured of achievement needs to be tempered.
Not exact matches
Regents Chancellor Betty Rosa
says the board wants to make certain the tests continue to provide a valid
measure of student
achievement.
President Mulgrew
said: «By objective
measures like the racial
achievement gap or the college readiness rate, and by public disenchantment with the governance
of the schools, it is clear that mayoral control in its current form has not worked.
«Two days
of testing is a natural next step, as long as the assessments continue to cover the material needed to truly
measure every student's strengths and challenges, and the changes are implemented carefully and with the input
of educators and communities,» High
Achievement New York, which advocates for higher standards,
said in a statement.
General secretary, Philip Parkin,
said: «Whether as a performance
measure or an actual certificate
of achievement, it has no point.»
This is a «substantial
achievement» noted NAO head Sir John Bourn, who
says Britain is ahead
of other countries in
measuring and understanding benefit fraud as a result.
«If we're
saying that the only thing that's a valid
measure of student
achievement is a test score, versus all the other work they do, it's going to be a sad day for the students
of New York state,» Mulgrew
said.
«Over the past decade we've been able to identify a growing number
of educational interventions that have managed to have notable impacts on students» academic
achievement as
measured by standardized tests,» West
says.
«Without publishing, [it is as if] you haven't done anything, because scientific articles are the most important
measure of scientific
achievement,»
says Ana Marušić, editor - in - chief
of the Croatian Medical Journal and president - elect
of the Council
of Science Editors.
Assessment is,
of course, a vital part
of education, but the stakes attached to these tests are way out
of balance when such a limited and imperfect
measure of achievement counts for more than all the assessments
of all the students» teachers,»
says Orfield.
In tackling this task, Feinberg
says, they «backed into» the five essential tenets
of the KIPP model: High Expectations (for academic
achievement and conduct); Choice and Commitment (KIPP students, parents, and teachers all sign a learning pledge, promising to devote the time and effort needed to succeed); More Time (extended school day, week, and year); Power to Lead (school leaders have significant autonomy, including control over their budget, personnel, and culture); and Focus on Results (scores on standardized tests and other objective
measures are coupled with a focus on character development).
Schools Minister Nick Gibb
said his statement to the House
of Commons that: «We (DfE) want new GCSEs to set expectations which match those
of the best education systems in the world, with rigorous assessment that provides a reliable
measure of students»
achievement.
Teachers» unions are strongly against these plans for a variety
of reasons, including that they
say it's nearly impossible to accurately
measure an individual teacher's contribution to a student's success, since a child's
achievement is cumulative over a period
of years and the result
of the efforts
of many people.
RAND, a non-profit analysis group,
said expanding
measures of school performance beyond mathematics and English language arts will give educators better information when evaluating the academic
achievements of schools.
Gov. Phil Bredesen
of Tennessee earlier this month called on his legislature to hold a special session in January to consider a package
of education
measures, including a requirement that student -
achievement data be used in teacher evaluations, and a proposal he
said would strengthen provisions allowing the state to intervene in chronically low - performing schools.
Since it may take a couple
of years for states and districts to follow the department's urging and set up systems that will allow them to
measure teacher effectiveness based on growth in student
achievement, she
said, states should be required to show that they are making good on the language about equitable distribution
of teachers that's already in the No Child Left Behind Act.
To
say that better
measures of achievement are «too expensive... and way too complicated for voters to understand and trust» is no reason to institute an accountability system that will never work.
It's hard to
say — student
achievement tests are everywhere, but finding good
measures of cultural change is difficult.
The Stanford study provides the first comparable
measures of ethnic
achievement gaps in every U.S. school district, Reardon
said.
«I have a pen in my pocket at all times to sign a tentative agreement with UTLA that would comply with the Stull Act and use
measures of student
achievement as a factor in evaluating teachers,»
said Deasy.
NAHT general secretary Russell Hobby
said: «Anyone who thinks that external tests are somehow an «objective»
measure of pupils»
achievement should be rapidly disabused
of the notion by this year's second exam fiasco.
The
measure, which won approval in the Republican - led House
of Representatives late Wednesday, would ease federally imposed
achievement goals that critics
say relied too much on standardized tests and were unrealistic for struggling public school systems such as Baltimore's.
The United Way
of Dane County, which has made closing Madison's
achievement gap a top priority, also plans to
measure the effectiveness
of its Schools
of Hope tutoring program over time using MAP results,
said Kathy Hubbard, director
of community impact.
With $ 360 million in additional Race to the Top money, it is backing work by states to design new testing systems that it
says will
measure student growth — rather than capture a snapshot
of achievement — supply real - time feedback to teachers to guide instruction, and include performance - based items to gauge more types
of learning.
Opponents
say comparing schools in this way is too crude a
measure of a school's quality,
achievements and character.
But to focus on student
achievement, schools have to explain how expenditures align to their needs analyses — a component
of strategic planning — and how effectiveness
of the funded activities will be
measured, Price
said.
Pro-voucher groups aren't trying to fight accountability, but are working to make sure that an equitable process is developed to
measure the success
of school choice programs in improving academic
achievement,
says Jim Bender, executive director
of School Choice Wisconsin.
Combatants on both sides
of that fight could claim a
measure of validation from the new research: Advocates
of school choice who argue that it isn't fair to judge voucher programs based on test results from a student's first year in private school, given that it takes children time to adjust to a new environment, and critics who
say vouchers drain funds from public schools without improving student
achievement.
Muir
says that although the school did administer a standardized
achievement test, that program did not: 1) provide a sufficient
measure of proficiency against state requirements; 2) enable progress monitoring; or 3) include math - skills benchmarking.
When asked what should determine teacher pay, 86 percent
said a teacher's education and training should be either the most important or an important factor, followed by 77 percent who
said their students»
achievement and progress on a range
of measures including standardized tests, classroom observations and parent feedback; 77 percent
said whether the teacher is at a low - performing school where students need the most help; 64 percent who
said students»
achievement and progress on standardized tests; and 57 percent who
said seniority in the number
of years
of classroom teaching experience.
He
said the way schools are
measured at the moment is «too narrow» with too much emphasis on the «narrow
achievements»
of individual schools.
«Providing a summative
measure does not have to conflict with the multiple indicator approach that California has adopted and can build on it, to ensure that parents have a clear entry point to interact with the richer performance data and the state can clearly identify those LEAs and schools with wide
achievement gaps and in need
of extra attention,» the letter
says.
Measures of student
achievement and post-secondary readiness included on the cards are good for reinforcing high standards, he
says.
«We did support un-timed tests as providing a truer
measure of a student's level
of achievement,» Lowry
said.
Dan Rossmiller, government affairs director for the Wisconsin Association
of School Boards,
said districts are concerned the one - size - fits - all system for
measuring schools doesn't make sense for certain schools, such as K - 2 schools where students are too young to take the WKCE, schools with high student turnover or schools that don't have
achievement gaps to close.
Snow
said she'd like to see more meaningful
measures of how schools are closing the
achievement gap for English learners, such as how quickly a student is able to move out
of English - learner status, or finding a way to
measure content knowledge without their language limitation being a factor in the score.
These data
say nothing about speeded math practice — the
measure of math
achievement used by Ramirez et al was untimed.
The eight Republican members who attended the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee hearing chastised King,
saying he'd failed to follow numerous provisions, including mandates to reduce the size
of the Department
of Education, allow states to set rules for
measuring performance and avoid complex reporting requirements for academic
achievement.
Based on the first two complete years
of data, that includes sophisticated growth
measures of achievement, Social Emotional Learning, school climate, and chronic absenteeism, she
said, «there is good evidence that we can use the
measures for school improvement, but it's not conclusive.»
State Superintendent Tom Torlakson
said the NAEP scores can serve as one
of several tools parents can use to
measure achievement across states.
«With the onset
of testing to
measure student
achievement, many times at the expense
of other disciplines, it is amazing what students can achieve when given half a chance,» Eisenhuth
says.
He
says his time as a superintendent
of Beloit schools, which have a high percentage
of low - income students and students
of color, will help address the state's longstanding, persistent
achievement gap between black and white students — which is the worst in the country by some
measures.
Those trade - offs are worth accepting,
said U.S. Secretary
of Education Arne Duncan, in order to achieve the goal
of measuring student
achievement aligned with common national academic standards, which most states have adopted this summer.
There is a growing base
of evidence outside California that multiple
measure evaluation systems can drive student
achievement,»
said board president Ted Mitchell.
While the task force results may be eye - opening to the general public, they come as no surprise to local educators, who
say they have known for years that the topics covered by New Jersey's High School Proficiency Assessment (HSPA), the standardized test used in grades 11 and 12 to
measure achievement and required for graduation, is not a
measure of college readiness.
And, Fletcher
said, the program's key
measure of student
achievement — known as Academic Growth Over Time — is based on state standardized tests that will be phased out in the next few years as California moves toward a new national curriculum and assessments.
Using Alternative Student Growth
Measures for Evaluating Teacher Performance: What the Literature
Says is a resource from the Institute
of Education Sciences and the Regional Education laboratory that looks at approaches to alternative methods
of evaluating student
achievement in order to
measure teacher performance.
Regents Chancellor Betty Rosa
says the board wants to make certain the tests continue to provide a valid
measure of student
achievement.
Evers also
said part
of his work to provide schools with guidance on how to reduce gaps in
achievement will come through a council convened
of educators, education - related lobbyists and lawmakers that Evers heads to figure out how Wisconsin will carry out the
measures of the new federal education law Every Student Succeeds Act.
Motor Trend began its annual award in 1949 as «a recognition
of engineering excellence,»
says its current editor, C. Van Tune.Most awards recognize past
achievement, but Motor Trend tries to
measure future potential.