But those who favor the language of privatization say that «school choice» masks reality -
they say vouchers and charters redirect the flow of taxpayer dollars from public schools, which most Americans support, into unaccountable private hands.
Not exact matches
«We think of the educational choice movement as involving many parts:
vouchers and tax credits, certainly, but also virtual schools, magnet schools, homeschooling,
and charter schools,» she
said in a 2013 interview.
«If you are going to be a Democrat
and you believe in bread -
and - butter Democratic issues like funding public schools, you should do that
and not keep — you've got to fund the schools better
and not keep siphoning off money for
vouchers and charters,» Nixon
said.
Talk of
vouchers and charter schools is not only going to destroy education for our children, it will cost jobs, Flynn
said.
But MPS board member Larry Miller blasted MMAC's legislative agenda,
saying it removes new reforms that make
voucher and charter schools more accountable to parents
and taxpayers.
Fischel goes so far as to
say this distinction in residential restrictions between
charters and vouchers is «critical» to the greater success of
charters.
This dire sequence started, he
says, with A Nation at Risk, the 1983 Reagan administration report that launched America on «experiments» such as «open classrooms, national goals, merit pay,
vouchers,
charter schools, smaller classes, alternative certification for teachers, student portfolios,
and online learning, to name just a handful.»
[They
say] it's a hopelessly bloated bureaucracy...
and charter schools,
vouchers, or at least radically reconstituted public schools are the answer.
The real culprit of the school systems» troubles, Weingarten
says, has been state governments» support for expanding
charter schools,
voucher plans
and other school choice policies, which she argues has eaten into the budget for traditional public schools.
So there has never been popular expression
saying we want to get rid of our public schools
and replace them with privately managed
charters or
vouchers that you can take to any place.
• Best approach for improving education: 77 percent
said the focus should be on ensuring that every child has access to a good public school in his or her community; just 20 percent
said there should be more public
charter schools
and vouchers.
But «when you talk about
charters and vouchers, it's disruptive, so people have stronger feelings about them,» he
says.
But by 1993, he
said charters are no different from
vouchers, because they both open the door to corporations coming in
and running public schools.
What does the evidence
say about a free market approach to school reform that relies on school
vouchers and unregulated forms of
charter schooling?
Much has been
said about
charter schools in Michigan
and Detroit, about accountability for
voucher programs,
and even the views of DeVos's family members!
«We've got to demand the same standards» for
voucher schools, he
said, «as we do [for] our public
and our
charter schools.»
In an interview with StateImpact Florida «s John O'Connor, Bennett
says almost all of Indiana's initiatives — A-F grading for schools, teacher evaluations, performance based pay, expansive
voucher programs
and expanded
charter school options — mirror what Florida has been doing for several years now.
«What's important when you're embracing a new approach to education, like
charters and vouchers, is to think about how those impact all the children, not just those who get the
vouchers or get into the
charters,» Russakoff
said.
Citing a long list of recent laws that many argue will hurt public education, Ravitch anticipated a brain drain for the state thanks to bad policies,
said that
charters and vouchers do not save kids from failing public schools but instead pave the way for resegregation,
and bemoaned the loss of teacher tenure.
He
says requiring public,
charter and private schools that receive
voucher money to teach to the same standards will diminish school choice in Indiana.
Walker has
said he supports subjecting all schools that receive taxpayer money to the same level of scrutiny
and has supported legislation aimed at doing that in the past legislative session, including giving report cards to all public,
charter and private
voucher schools.
This campaign, it
says, is really «a proxy for a broader assault on public education itself»
and is coming at a time when public schools have been weakened by funding cuts, «vitriolic political attacks on teachers
and their unions,
and state programs to privatize schools through
vouchers,
charter schools
and other «school choice» measures.»
John Witte, a UW - Madison professor emeritus who was the principal researcher on a long - term study of Milwaukee's
voucher school program,
said studies in Milwaukee «found that competition from
charter, magnet
and voucher schools has had beneficial effects on the public schools.»
Supporters of
vouchers and charter schools, however, pointed to the study's limitations,
saying it gave only a snapshot of performance, not a sense of how students progress over time.
As for the research on competitive effects of school choice policies in general —
vouchers, tax - credit scholarships,
and charters all together — the jury is still out,
said David Arsen, a professor of education policy
and K - 12 educational administration at Michigan State University.
Martin
said the growth of publicly funded private
charter schools
and private school
vouchers is also an important issue because those programs divert critical tax money away from public schools, thereby increasing the challenges public schools face in meeting the growing needs of their diverse student bodies.
Pinsky
said that rather than try to influence those policies through the confirmation process, lawmakers could intervene legislatively if they saw a new superintendent adopt policies on
vouchers,
charter schools
and other matters that he described as out of the mainstream.
Critics
say this lopsided exposure fueled Ms. DeVos's staunch support of privately run, publicly funded
charter schools
and voucher programs that allow families to take tax dollars from the public education system to private schools.
Our research indicates that continued growth in
charter,
voucher and tax - credit scholarship programs across the country could propel innovation to new heights, bringing about broader positive change
and particularly impacting traditionally disadvantaged students,» Wolf
and Egalite
said.
Milwaukee NAACP President Fred Royal
says the state will create a fourth school district joining MPS, independent
charter schools
and private
voucher schools.
That is why I agree with Elinor Ostrom, this year's Nobel Economics winner, who
says policy makers should reconsider the past reforms
and recommend «
charter schools,
voucher systems,
and other reforms to create more responsive schools.»
And teachers are firing back saying, you know, these corporate reformers, as they call them, are undermining public education by pushing charter schools vouchers and trying to roll back teacher tenu
And teachers are firing back
saying, you know, these corporate reformers, as they call them, are undermining public education by pushing
charter schools
vouchers and trying to roll back teacher tenu
and trying to roll back teacher tenure.
, who opposes
vouchers and supports
charters,
said the system «is in terrible shape,
and it has been for a very long time.
He also finds it particularly interesting that Common Core foes
say they want high - quality education for all children, yet fail to consider that their opposition to the standards hurts poor
and minority kids as well as middle class white
and Asian children in suburbia, both of which have few options — including
vouchers and charter schools — to which they can avail in order to get high - quality education.
Farrow
said he has always been «open to looking at sanctions if they are equal across all three sectors,» meaning in areas of public, private
voucher and charter schools.
Olsen also
said funding for open enrollment
and charter and private
voucher schools could be examined.
Pence
said those words at a press conference with outgoing Gov. Mitch Daniels, who was instrumental in enacting many of the education policies — a private school
voucher program, a teacher evaluation mandate, new
charter school rules,
and others — Bennett supported.
In 1998, Gov. Dayton
said, «While I support
charter schools
and open enrollment, I am opposed to
vouchers.»
Humphries
said in an interview that Evers was too focused on objecting to the expansion of private
voucher and independent
charter schools
and not focused enough on raising student achievement
and closing the gap in academic achievement between white
and black students.
Farrow
said the Senate bill will likely change before its tentatively scheduled Jan. 27 hearing
and dropping the key provision of creating one board to oversee public
and charter schools
and another to oversee private
voucher schools could happen if public response to the proposal indicates it's not a popular idea.
«While
voucher programs, tax credit scholarships,
charter schools
and the like have done wonders in improving education, states with such programs in place should not stop there,» Rayanne Matlock, operations manager at Americans for Tax Reform,
said.
Grant Callen, president of Empower Mississippi, a nonprofit dedicated to «school choice» options, including
vouchers and charter schools,
says an experience like Kast's illustrates a range of failures on the part of public schools.
Wisconsin Education Association Council president Betsy Kippers, a Racine teacher,
said the «fingerprints of the
voucher and privately run
charter lobbyists are all over this.»
For school choice to work, Butcher
said, policymakers should give families
vouchers to attend private schools,
and allow more
charter schools to open.
State superintendent candidate Lowell Holtz, a former superintendent of Whitnall
and Beloit school districts,
said he is «adamantly opposed» to immediately converting «failing schools» into
charter or private
voucher schools or closing them.
And while her supporters say she has deep knowledge when it comes to vouchers, charter schools, and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing about other areas of education policy, including special educati
And while her supporters
say she has deep knowledge when it comes to
vouchers,
charter schools,
and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing about other areas of education policy, including special educati
and other forms of choice, she appeared confused during her confirmation hearing about other areas of education policy, including special education.
Andy Smarick of the Maryland State Board of Education
said he was not sure where GOP presidential nominee Donald Trump stands on
charter schools, standardized testing, school choice,
vouchers, teacher evaluations,
and the rollout of the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA).
«It's a direct attack on public education,»
said Diane Ravitch, a historian
and former Bush administration official who has become one of the most voluble critics of
vouchers and charter schools
and a proponent of the term privatization.
For now the Asociación de Maestros de Puerto Rico will continue mobilizing against the
charter and voucher proposals,
and Díaz
said they are also going to start more vocally championing for public schools that provide robust wraparound social services.
Scott Richard, executive director of the Louisiana School Boards Association,
said school choice,
charter schools,
vouchers, new standards, public school letter grades
and other steps were all touted as answers.