Indeed, the global study of Dr. Lutz and colleagues suggests that greatly enhanced carbon sequestration should not be expected no matter the location or duration of proposed large -
scale ocean fertilization experiments.
In one on - line discussion, Oklahoma State University botanist William Henley wrote that «large -
scale ocean fertilization is a classic example of the traditionally favored «end of the pipe» approach to environmental problems, as opposed to eliminating the source of the problem.»
Given all of the risks and limitations, why has the idea of industrial
scale ocean fertilization not been summarily dismissed?
This paper considers the practicalities, opportunities and threats associated with one of the earliest proposed carbon - removal techniques: large -
scale ocean fertilization, achieved by adding iron or other nutrients to surface waters.
Not exact matches
Can
ocean fertilization really help combat climate change on any significant
scale?
Fe
fertilization on a large
scale could result in depletion of other resources in the
ocean and alter the ecosystem.
Ocean fertilization works by manipulating natural ecosystems on a grand
scale, so rather than protecting these ecosystems we are disturbing them in yet another way.
Together with commercial operators they plan to go ahead with large -
scale and more permanent
ocean fertilization experiments and note that potential negative environmental consequences must be balanced against the harm
This allows us to
scale the two records by their respective interglacial levels, combine them to better resolve the Southern
Ocean, and use the combined record as our proxy for glacial / interglacial iron
fertilization forcing.
Based on a century of
ocean plankton science and the 10 international experiments on iron
fertilization over the last 15 years we are confident that the
scale, methods and technologies of the work we are planning will have positive impacts on all fronts, improving water quality, buffering surface water acidity, recharging the marine food chain, and safely sequestering enormous amounts of CO2 to help slow climate change.