A model that compares teachers to the average teacher across all schools produces estimates of teacher effectiveness that are combinations of teacher and
school effects on student achievement.
Not exact matches
Likewise, homeschooling seems to mitigate the negative
effects of low levels of parents» education
on student achievement — a finding that's especially intriguing since these parents are the educators — as well as the negative
effects of family socioeconomic variables and race displayed in public
schools.
Coleman Report had concluded that «
schools are remarkably similar in the
effect they have
on the
achievement of their pupils when the socio - economic background of the
students is taken into account.»
Depending
on how many
students at a given
school live in poverty, strong parental networks have a favorable or inhibiting
effect on the academic
achievements of their children.
Since the No Child Left Behind Act went into
effect in 2002, more data than ever have been made available
on schools, the quality of their teachers, and their
student achievement.
By contrast, just four states base a majority of
schools» summative ratings
on «growth for all
students,» though this is the best way to evaluate a
school's
effect on student achievement.
These studies show, consistently, that parental
schools of choice not controlled by public
school districts 1) are usually prohibited by law from screening out
students based
on admission exams, 2) use ability tracking less frequently than traditional public
schools even when, legally, they can, and 3) may use ability tracking, but when they do, it is less likely to have a negative
effect on the
achievement of low - track
students.
Matt Chingos of Brookings and Guido Schwerdt of the University of Konstanz are out today with a new Program
on Education Policy and Governance working paper that provides, to my knowledge, the first credible evidence
on the
effects of online courses
on student achievement in K - 12
schools.
Growing Minds: The
Effect of a
School Gardening Program
on the Science
Achievement of Elementary
Students (PDF).
The power of culture - and its
effect on student achievement - is evident in adolescents» lesser concentration
on academic endeavors as they focus more
on television, video games, and excessive employment during the
school year.
Our present approach also assumes that each year of charter
schooling has the same
effect on student achievement.
The basic strategy we use to evaluate the
effect of charter
schools on student achievement is to compare
students who are awarded a seat in a charter
school through a lottery with
students who enter the lottery but are not awarded a seat.
We also estimated a separate
effect on achievement for each of the 32 charter
schools with
students in grades 3 through 8.
And the topics covered in those pages extend far beyond bread - and - butter questions of salary and benefits; there are dozens of clauses covering a district's ability to evaluate, transfer, terminate, and manage the workload of teachers, all having potentially serious
effects on the management of
schools and
student achievement.
However, this is exactly the facile logic invoked by Hanushek regarding the
effect of
school spending
on student achievement.
The most extreme claim in the essay, among many, is that «the
effect of vouchers
on student achievement is larger than the following in -
school factors: exposure to violent crime at
school...» Yep, you read that correctly: selecting a private
school for your child is as damaging to them as witnessing
school violence.
We also drew
on an additional year of data, from the 2012 13
school year, in assessing IMPACT's
effects on student achievement in tested grades and subjects.
In high - poverty
schools, we estimate that the overall
effect of all teacher turnover
on student achievement is 0.08 of a standard deviation in math and 0.05 of a standard deviation in reading.
In his 2014 academic paper — The
achievement effects of tardy classmates: Evidence in urban elementary
schools — Michael Gottfried explores the impact of tardy
students» behaviour
on their peers.
Despite these differences, the bulk of the available, high - quality evidence
on school voucher programs suggests that they do yield positive
achievement effects for participating
students.
Arguably, the most important development in K — 12 education over the past decade has been the emergence of a growing number of urban
schools that have been convincingly shown to have dramatic positive
effects on the
achievement of disadvantaged
students.
To determine the
effect of teacher turnover
on student achievement under IMPACT, we examine the year - to - year changes in
school - grade combinations with and without teacher turnover.
In related work conducted in Massachusetts, Harvard economist Josh Goodman finds no
effects of
school closures
on student achievement but large negative
effects of weather - induced absences
on moderately snowy days when
schools remained open.
Consistent with the Wisconsin evidence, parallel studies in Colorado and Maryland found that weather - related differences in the number of days
students had spent in
school when they were tested had noticeable
effects on their
achievement.
Goodman finds that
school closings have no
effect on student achievement overall in either math or English language arts.
The major substantive chapters of the book place Swedish expenditure and
achievement in comparative perspective (in both, Sweden rates high); show that the decline in education inputs during the 1990s worsened the teacher -
student ratio and teacher quality; review the international research
on the
effects of
school choice; and test for the
effects of
school choice in Sweden
on achievement.
Because teachers were considering intangible factors, even when race, gender, family income, and academic
achievement are the same, there was no way to isolate the
effect of being held back, much less to make reasonable conclusions about the
effects of retention
on a
student's academic
achievement or the probability of his dropping out of high
school.
On the third page of the study, the authors write: «Negative voucher
effects are not explained by the quality of public fallback options for LSP applicants:
achievement levels at public
schools attended by
students lotteried out of the program are below the Louisiana average and comparable to scores in low - performing districts like New Orleans.»
Much evidence suggests that
school decisions about curricula (e.g., textbooks, instructional software, and the corresponding pedagogy) can have comparatively large
effects on student achievement.
A Little Rock, Arkansas, performance - pay program lasted only three years and was not renewed by the local
school board, despite evidence of positive
effects on student achievement in math, reading, and language.
[viii] And a longer
school day and year is a distinguishing feature of those charter
schools that have the strongest positive
effects on student achievement.
The impact that the changing demographic composition of
schools could have
on the
achievement of black
students is not clear, especially given the difficulty of isolating the
effects of desegregation.
To provide more rigorous evidence
on the
effect of middle
schools on student achievement, we turned to a richly detailed administrative dataset from New York City that allowed us to follow
students from grade 3 through grade 8.
But, unfortunately, evidence from both the United States and other countries shows that more
school resources and smaller classes do not have much of an
effect on how much a
student learns in
school, as measured by tests of
achievement.
More specifically, if the average quality of teachers in a
school is already high, being assigned to one of the better teachers will have only a limited
effect on student achievement.
These patterns suggest that the positive
effects of charter
school attendance
on educational attainment are not due solely to measured differences in the
achievement of
students in charter and traditional public high
schools.
A RCT of charter
schools in New York City by a Stanford researcher found an even larger
effect: «
On average, a
student who attended a charter
school for all of grades kindergarten through eight would close about 86 percent of the «Scarsdale - Harlem
achievement gap» in math and 66 percent of the
achievement gap in English.»
Even when attrition and replacement throughout the middle
school years are taken into account, the limited range of potential peer
effects at KIPP
schools does not explain the large cumulative impacts
on student achievement identified by prior studies.
Perhaps the largest long - term impact of the Coleman Report has been its
effect on elite opinion about the contribution
schools make to
student achievement.
Charter
schools have the potential to have broader
effects on student achievement if traditional public
schools respond to the threat of losing
students to charter
schools by improving the quality of their own education programs.
Still, if North Carolina's traditional public
schools improved in response to their presence, the apparently negative
effects of charter
schools on the
achievement of
students who attend them could be offset by more positive statewide
effects.
More importantly, they say, the
effects persisted when children were aged 11, but add `... the estimated
effects of
school starting age
on other mental health constructs, which have weaker links to subsequent
student achievement, are smaller and less persistent.»
However, charter
schools in North Carolina exhibit negative
effects on student achievement even after controlling for
student turnover rates.
The studies were conducted as a partnership with the
School Choice Demonstration Project at the University of Arkansas and look at the impact of the vouchers
on student achievement and non-cognitive skills,
on racial segregation, and
on students attending nearby public
schools (competitive
effects).
Research
on the
effect of existing private
school voucher programs has not shown significant
achievements for
students in those programs, the report asserts.
Still, its detractors argue that the law has had unfortunate side
effects: too much time spent teaching to narrow tests,
schools focused
on boosting the scores of
students who are just below the proficiency threshold, and some states lowering their standards to reduce the number of
schools missing their
achievement targets.
After controlling for
student and peer attributes and for selection bias, we still find a substantial positive and statistically significant
effect of attending a network
school on student achievement.
But over the range of spending commonly observed among
school systems in the United States, the
effect on student achievement is often swamped by how wisely the money is spent, by bureaucratic and contract rigidities, and by a host of important policies and decisions that have nothing at all to do with money.
While some critics have charged that changing to a four - day
school week may have negative
effects on student achievement, researchers at Colorado State University have completed a study indicating that the switch to a four - day schedule has «no
effect»
on achievement as measured by the Iowa Test of Basic Skills.
Competition from Sweden's private
school choice program has a positive
effect on student achievement in both public and private
schools.