At the individual school level, with a few exceptions such as the large HCZ, there are less data on
school test score effects and attainment effects.
Not exact matches
Fariña recently told Capital she believes some charter
schools can have a positive
effect on the public system, while knocking others (without naming specific
schools) for touting high
test scores, but not accepting special education or English Language Learner students.
On April 9, the DOE announced that a new promotion policy that takes into account teachers» and principals» recommendations rather than students»
test scores would take
effect this
school year.
«Although some types of
school moves can have positive
effects, most are associated with a range of negative outcomes, including lower
test scores, grade retention, low self - esteem, trouble fitting into
schools, dropping out and event adult substance abuse.»
A Wisconsin law requiring public reporting of
test scores from voucher
schools went into
effect during the last year of the study, 2010, giving researchers a rare look at private -
school test scores both before and after the accountability mandate.
We use common statistical procedures to estimate the
effect on math and reading
test scores of each additional year of actual attendance at a charter
school.
Although there were some small - scale random - assignment experiments of the
effects of desegregation on
test scores, most of what we know today concerns the relationship between a
school outcome such as achievement on the one hand, and racial composition on the other.
Consistent with other research on
school effects, we find that the
school a student attends can explain a substantial share of the overall variation in
test scores: that single factor explains 34 percent of the variation in math
scores and 24 percent of the variation for reading.
We address this limitation by focusing on the
effect of
school spending on such long - run outcomes as educational attainment and earnings rather than on
test scores.
But all previous evaluations of the
effects of private
schools or of
school voucher programs reported
test -
score results for both reading and math, or a composite measure of the two, even if the researchers thought that one or the other was a better measure of
school performance.
Such «selection
effects» could in theory account for the apparent
school impacts on
test scores, or even the apparent absence of impacts on fluid cognitive skills.
October 13, 2016 — No - excuses charter
schools raise
test scores but also questions: is the popular educational approach a fad with short - term
effects, or an innovative solution with long - term student benefits?
This
effect is similar in size to those found in evaluations of primary -
school inputs» impacts on postsecondary outcomes, such as being assigned to a teacher who is particularly effective in raising student
test scores.
Koretz's research focuses on educational assessment and policy, particularly high - stakes
testing and its
effect on
schools, as well as the validity of the
score gains.
We find the program did not reduce
test scores; likely, it increased them, with positive
effects most pronounced in
schools that serve a more disadvantaged student population.
If that were the case, then I might find that
schools with later start times have higher
test scores, even if start times themselves had no causal
effect.
Nonetheless, they still reveal significantly positive
effects of attending private
schools on African - American
test scores.
M. Danish Shakeel, Kaitlin Anderson, and I just released a meta - analysis of 19 «gold standard» experimental evaluations of the
test -
score effects of private
school choice programs around the world.
Our meta - analysis avoided all three factors that have muddied the waters on the
test -
score effects of private
school choice.
Thus we use a method that in
effect compares the
test -
score gains of individual students in charter
schools with the
test -
score gains made by the same students when they were in traditional public
schools.
Schneider and his colleagues believe that consumer choice in
schooling can have positive
effects on education quality, and they support their belief with
test score data from New York City.
Specifically, I examine whether the
effects on age - 11
test scores can be detected when the students are
tested again at age 14, three years after the students have left the primary
school.
Black children exhibited the familiar
effect of an initial boost in
test scores that faded away, leading the researchers to attribute the lack of sustained gains to the abysmal public
schools in disadvantaged black neighborhoods.
The results indicate that the
effect of receiving a fail rating is to raise standardized
test scores in a
school by 0.12 standard deviations in math and by 0.07 to 0.09 standard deviations in English.
My colleagues and I just released a meta - analysis of 19 «gold standard» experimental evaluations of the
test -
score effects of private
school choice programs around the world.
Still, its detractors argue that the law has had unfortunate side
effects: too much time spent teaching to narrow
tests,
schools focused on boosting the
scores of students who are just below the proficiency threshold, and some states lowering their standards to reduce the number of
schools missing their achievement targets.
Thomas Dee looks beyond
test scores to examine the
effects of accountability on high -
school graduation rates and students» employment prospects.
Furthermore, students in
schools where external exams or standardized
tests heavily influence the curriculum
scored 4 points higher in math, though there appears to be no
effect in science.
And to turn back to
school choice for a moment, Imberman finds that charters in an unnamed urban district had no
effect on student
tests scores — but had large positive
effects on discipline and attendance.
In order to determine the
effect of scholarship - induced private
school competition on public
school performance, we examine whether students in
schools that face a greater threat of losing students to private
schools as a result of the introduction of tax - credit funded scholarships improve their
test scores more than do students in
schools that face a less - pronounced threat.
To measure the
effect on children's
test scores of switching to a private
school, we estimate a statistical model that takes into account whether a child attended a public or a private
school, as well as baseline reading and math
test scores.
Using a sophisticated methodology to look for value - added
effects (gauged by
scores on state
tests and SAT and AP exams) in six prominent «exam
schools» in Boston and New York City, they didn't find much to applaud:
Despite the vast majority of randomized control trials (RCTs) of private
school choice showing significant, positive
test score effects for at least some subgroups of students, some of those gains have been modest and other
effects have been null for at least some subgroups.
It's true that students from those
schools who did enroll in post-secondary
schooling were more likely to go to a 4 than 2 year college, but it is unclear if this is a desirable outcome given that it may be a mismatch for their needs and this more nuanced
effect is not commensurate with the giant
test score gains.
The outcome of the lottery, a random event, was used to create what statisticians refer to as an instrumental variable, which obtains unbiased estimates of the
effects of attending private
school on students»
test scores.
Charter
schools benefit students in neighboring district
schools Positive
effects found on
test scores, grade completion, and more, increasing with proximity
For example, the Gates Foundation's small
school reforms were widely panned as a flop in early reviews relying on student
test scores, but a number of later rigorous studies showed (sometimes substantial) positive
effects on outcomes such as graduation and college enrollment.
In addition to our main experiment
testing the ECO-C Intervention's
effects on our target group of high - achieving, low - income students, we also used the same approach to study its
effects on students who meet the same
test -
score criteria but who have estimated family income above the bottom one - third or attended a feeder high
school.
Work we conducted separately in 2007 and 2008 provides much stronger evidence of
effects on
test scores from year - to - year changes in the length of the
school year due to bad weather.
Using an experimental design, the study found no clear
effects of using a voucher to enroll in a private
school on students»
test scores four years later.
Data from the tracking
schools allow us to estimate the
effect of being taught with a higher - achieving vs. lower - achieving peer group by comparing students with baseline
test scores in the middle of the distribution.
This pattern of
test -
score effects — showing positive results in urban areas with many low - income students, but neutral or even negative
effects elsewhere — also appears in a national study of oversubscribed charter middle
schools funded by the U.S. Department of Education.
Because we observe
schools over several time periods, we can subject the program to an even stricter
test by controlling for all characteristics of
schools that remain constant over time (by «differencing out» the
effect of attending a particular
school on exam
scores).
These
effects are all larger than what would have been predicted based on the same students»
test -
score gains, leading the researchers to conclude that «high achieving charter
schools alter more than cognitive ability.»
Finally, the only study to have estimated the
effect of charter
school attendance on students» job prospects, although based on nonexperimental methods, finds that attending a Florida charter
school increased students» earnings as adults despite having no impact on their standardized
test scores.
That is, we can say with 95 percent confidence that the
effect of a 10 - percentage - point increase in the private
school share is between 3.9 and 14.2 percent of a standard deviation in
test scores.
Performance metrics tied directly to student
test -
score growth are appealing because although
schools and teachers differ dramatically in their
effects on student achievement, researchers have had great difficulty linking these performance differences to characteristics that are easily observed and measured.
This meta - analysis of social and emotional learning interventions (including 213
school - based SEL programs and 270,000 students from rural, suburban and urban areas) showed that social and emotional learning interventions had the following
effects on students ages 5 - 18: decreased emotional distress such as anxiety and depression, improved social and emotional skills (e.g., self - awareness, self - management, etc.), improved attitudes about self, others, and
school (including higher academic motivation, stronger bonding with
school and teachers, and more positive attitudes about
school), improvement in prosocial
school and classroom behavior (e.g., following classroom rules), decreased classroom misbehavior and aggression, and improved academic performance (e.g. standardized achievement
test scores).
We also lack evidence of how public
schools and private
schools differ in their instructional and teaching strategies that would explain negative
effects on
test scores.
Understanding the
effect of private
school choice on real - world success beyond
test scores requires data on outcomes like college enrollment and graduation, and thanks to three recent Urban Institute studies, we know more about this than we did a year ago.