Many in conservative circles see her primary role as using the bully pulpit to advance school choice policies, but government - backed
school vouchers for private schools, which is something she's vigorously supported for decades, have really taken a beating recently.
Republicans and conservatives now control every level of government, the state's spending on taxpayer - funded
school vouchers for private schools has increased and the state's teachers union no longer plays an influential role in funding and supporting Democrats.
In a recent New York Times op - ed, I argued that the case for Betsy DeVos's Secretary of Education appointment rests on a very weak track record — in particular, the evidence does not support her free market approach to school reform that relies, first and foremost, on
school vouchers for private schools, as well as unregulated forms of charter schooling.
Not exact matches
Any call
for massive cuts to education by the same people who push
for «
vouchers» so they can send their kids to
private Catholic
schools and such, are the Christian Right seeking to gut secular education because they hate it.
Crumbling urban
schools yet those white liberals shot down the
voucher progran giving black parents a chance to send their child to a
private school for a better education.
On issues like tuition
vouchers for families to send their children to
private and parochial
schools, Orthodox Jews have effectively allied themselves with Catholic and Evangelical Christian conservatives and have gained the support of senators like Joseph Lieberman (D - Conn.)
Private schools, charter
schools,
voucher programs and other
school choice options have been championed by reform - minded conservatives such as Jeb Bush
for years now, partly because of their success
for countless children of color living in poor communities with even poorer - performing public
schools.
In 1951 the nation's scholarship program was opened up to qualifying students who wanted to attend
private secondary
schools; the government also began providing
for children attending all elementary
schools a minimal supplementary aid in a form similar to the tuition
voucher plans presently under discussion in several American states.
An ESA is like a
school voucher because it offers eligible families state - funded access to
private school tuition, but unlike a
school voucher, the ESA deposits money into an account that families can use
for other expenses besides
school tuition —
for transportation or education - related technology,
for example.
Though he has been light on details, Trump is pushing an agenda that includes more charter
schools and a
voucher system
for students who want to attend
private schools.
DeVos» strong support
for taxpayer - funded
vouchers for private and parochial
schools has intensified trepidation about her nomination in New York.
(Advocates
for the bill, chiefly the Catholic Church, argued that there was no point of passing it in the Senate when it wouldn't succeed in the Democratic - led Assembly, where union - allied lawmakers argue the tax credit is a
voucher that drains funds from public
schools in favor of
privates.)
More than 700,000 students in more than 1,200 New York City
schools — including large high
schools in all five boroughs — would face higher class sizes, have fewer teachers and lose after -
school academic and enrichment programs if President - elect Trump makes good on a campaign promise to pull billions of federal dollars away from public
schools to pay
for private vouchers, a UFT analysis has found.
Mr. Cuomo has also voiced support
for a bill, backed by the Catholic Church and advocates of
vouchers, that would offer tax credits to individuals and corporations who donate money to public
schools, or to scholarship programs that help poor and middle - class students attend
private schools.
Recounting Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney's recent speech on educational policy, he noted that it focused on providing
vouchers for children nationwide to attend whatever type of
school they choose, whether public or
private.
Now, according to a poll just released by Associated Press and the National Opinion Research Center,
vouchers that use taxpayer funds
for low - income students to attend
private schools gathered support from 43 % of the public, with only 31 % opposed.
The size and significance of
voucher effects
for African - Americans appear unchanged after controlling
for the class sizes in the public and
private schools students attended.
They give a higher evaluation to
private schools than to public ones in their local community, but opposition to market - oriented
school - reform proposals such as performance pay
for teachers and
school vouchers seems to be on the rise.
As her critics suspected, Skandera adopted a Florida - style approach to New Mexico, pushing forward most major elements of the Bush approach, with the exception of
vouchers and tax credits
for private schools.
Education savings accounts operate like the «partial
voucher» that Friedman envisioned more than a decade ago, allowing families to seek out the best educational opportunities
for their students — whether those be in a
private or parochial
school or a mix of non-traditional education options.
Americans» support
for using public funds to pay
for students to attend
private schools apparently was growing even before the U.S. Supreme Court's June decision upholding the Cleveland
voucher plan, findings from this year's Phi Delta Kappa / Gallup poll on public attitudes about education suggest.
The prediction comes from both proponents and opponents of the tuition -
voucher measure, which, by providing parents with $ 900
for each student enrolled in a
private or out - of - district public
school, would be the most extensive choice program yet adopted by any state.
Few topics stir up as much debate in the education sphere as steering public money in the form of
vouchers to pay
for students to attend
private school.
When comparable samples and measuring sticks are used, the improvement in test scores
for black students from attending a small class based on the Tennessee STAR experiment is about 50 percent larger than the gain from switching to a
private school based on the
voucher experiments in New York City, Washington, D.C., and Dayton, Ohio.
In Milwaukee,
for example, according to Paul Peterson, while charters have «accelerated» the decline of
private schools,
vouchers seem to have «stabilized» them.
Another problem is that the effect sizes Goldhaber took from the Washington, D.C.,
voucher experiment were adjusted to account
for imperfect compliance - the fact that not everyone offered a
voucher attended
private school, and some of those who weren't offered a
voucher nevertheless attended
private school.
Half our sample was instead asked a question about
vouchers that did not mention wider choice
for families but referred to the use of «government funds»
for private -
school tuition.
DeVos is certainly known
for her support of various forms of
school choice, including
vouchers, but there are both practical and political obstacles to promoting
private school choice from DC.
I then assume that each
school district receives that amount
for each poor student enrolled in 2014 - 15: that is, I assume that no students take their
vouchers to
private schools.
With an RCT design, a group of students who all qualify
for a
voucher program and whose parents are equally motivated to exercise
private school choice, participate in a lottery.
The most extreme claim in the essay, among many, is that «the effect of
vouchers on student achievement is larger than the following in -
school factors: exposure to violent crime at
school...» Yep, you read that correctly: selecting a
private school for your child is as damaging to them as witnessing
school violence.
The authors devote the concluding chapter to claims that their findings undermine the case
for private school vouchers.
The positive impacts on reading achievement observed
for voucher users therefore reflect the incremental effect of adding
private school choice through the OSP to the existing
schooling options
for low - income D.C. families.
Back in 2004, Spencer Hsu told the story of how the first federal
voucher program was launched, when George W. Bush signed legislation providing grants worth as much as $ 7,500 each to children from dozens of public
schools in the District of Columbia
for their use at
private or religious
schools in a five - year experiment.
But all previous evaluations of the effects of
private schools or of
school voucher programs reported test - score results
for both reading and math, or a composite measure of the two, even if the researchers thought that one or the other was a better measure of
school performance.
Trump's conception, now reinforced by the DeVos appointment, promotes choice, broadly construed, to authorize charter
schools,
vouchers and opportunity scholarships including public,
private,
for profit, and maybe even religious
schools.
«Position A: Government should give parents more educational choices by providing taxpayer - funded
vouchers to help pay
for private or religious
schools.
In contrast to
vouchers (which are used
for private school tuition), ESAs are accounts that families can use
for a variety of education expenses — including tuition, online classes, tutoring, educational therapy services — or to contribute to a 529 college savings plan.
And by the end of the legislative session, he got just about everything he wanted in a
school reform plan: expansion of charter
schools,
private school vouchers, and college scholarships
for students who graduate high
school early.
In fact, when Congress passed a
private school voucher program
for Washington, D.C., alongside new funding
for the district and charter sectors, the overall reform plan was called the «three - sector approach.»
This would include funding
for a pilot
private -
school voucher program, new money
for charter
schools, and additional money
for Title I that would be directed to follow students to the public
school of their choice.
Lawyers
for each side sparred over the role of religion in many of the
private schools that receive
vouchers under Florida's Opportunity Scholarships program.
Indeed, whereas the differences in enrollment trends between
voucher and non-
voucher private schools provide some suggestive evidence
for the Overregulation Theory, Harris provides no evidence to support the Nonaligned Test Theory.
The federal tax credit proposal is one of several ideas under review by the White House to fulfill Donald Trump's campaign promise to promote the expansion of charter
schools and
vouchers that would allow families of low income to use public money
for private school tuition, sources tell POLITICO.
The new version of the «at public expense» question asked, «Would you vote
for or against a system giving parents government - funded
school vouchers to pay
for tuition at a
private school?»
The second PDK item became the following: «Would you vote
for or against a system giving parents the option of using government - funded
school vouchers to pay
for tuition at the public,
private, or religious
school of their choice?»
Survey Question # 6: Which one of these two plans would you prefer — improving and strengthening the existing public
schools or providing
vouchers for parents to use in selecting and paying
for private and / or church - related
schools?
Justices on the seven - member court also questioned whether public money
for K - 12
schools should be used in
private schools at all, whether other forms of state aid to religious institutions would be at risk if the
vouchers are struck down, and whether...
The second of them asks, «Which one of these two plans would you prefer — improving and strengthening the existing public
schools, or providing
vouchers for parents to use in selecting and paying
for private and / or church - related
schools?»
August 1, 2017 — The 2017 Education Next annual survey of American public opinion on education shows public support
for charter
schools has dropped, even as opposition to
school vouchers and tax credits
for private -
school scholarships has declined.