We know that austerity, incessant testing regimes to rate and rank
schools and state takeovers of schools and districts are intentional strategies to undermine public support for public schools, to facilitate the transfer of tax dollars to privatized schools, and to disenfranchise parents, educators and communities.
Not exact matches
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio on Wednesday called for a permanent extension of mayoral control for city
schools and criticized Gov. Andrew Cuomo's approach toward standardized testing
and push to make it easier for the
state to
takeover struggling
schools.
Governor Cuomo released a
state budget plan that closes a $ 2 billion dollar gap, recommends a phased in
state takeover of county health care costs,
and offers an ultimatum to
schools to accept a teacher evaluation program or lose access to increased
school funding.
Governor Cuomo released a
state budget plan that closes a $ 2 billion dollar gap, recommends a phased in
state takeover of county health care costs,
and offers an ultimatum to
schools to accept a teacher evaluation program or lose increased
school funding.
Further, her call for a
state takeover of far more of the cost of public
schools may yet resonate with New Yorkers as they begin to feel the impact of cuts in staff
and services to
schools and local governments, experts said.
The money can be used, they say, to enact needed education reforms — ones that differ from those proposed by Cuomo, which includes
state takeovers of chronically failing
schools and an expansion of charter
schools.
Just when some
schools thought they had cleared the threat of a
takeover, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said the
state could withhold funding for struggling
schools if he
and the legislature can not agree on which ones should be taken away from the local
school district.
J.H.S. 162 in the Bronx — the only public
school threatened with a
state takeover since the establishment of the receivership program — is caught in a power struggle between the governor
and the
state Education Department.
But, threatening public
schools like Schuyler with
state takeover when the
state has NOT provided the necessary funding
and support does everyone a disservice.
As part of this, Hempstead High
School is identified as «persistently struggling»
and Alverta B. Gray Schultz Middle
School as «struggling,» with each given requirements
and deadlines to meet federal
and state standards — or face potential
takeover by an outside manager.
The money can be used, they say, to enact needed education reforms — different reforms than Cuomo has proposed, which include
state takeovers of chronically failing
schools and an expansion of charter
schools.
«The
state's budget includes a $ 248 million increase in
school aid, $ 212 million more for the
state takeover of Medicaid,
and $ 60 million in additional tax revenue — calling this significant increase a cut is disingenuous
and the city should check its math.»
Cuomo's Five - Year Financial Plan keeps revenue sharing with local governments flat at a time when scores of local governments
and school districts are headed for insolvency
and a
takeover by
state Control Boards.
The education changes also provide a means for
state takeover of what Cuomo calls «failing
schools»
and many lawmakers refer to as «struggling
schools.»
Last July, the
state's new education commissioner, MaryEllen Elia, named 62 «struggling»
and «persistently struggling» New York City
schools that would face a
takeover if they did not improve.
He called on the
state to increase funding for the Metropolitan Transportation Authority
and criticized Cuomo's
school -
takeover policy, but without calling out the governor by name.
Michigan, for instance, passed laws permitting
state takeovers of failing
schools and tying teacher evaluations to students» test scores.
They need real governance change in the form of
state takeover, outsourcing of their
schools (perhaps to a «recovery» district),
and maybe even closing the district.
Maryland would have been the first
state in the country to take over
schools for NCLB restructuring, but Grasmick's efforts met with intense political opposition from Baltimore's mayor
and other political leaders,
and the
state legislature passed a bill blocking the
takeover.
Grassroots advocacy, public opinion, proposed legislation, the looming
state takeover of the Philadelphia
schools,
and a 2 - year - old court decision are fueling new momentum on an issue that
state legislators have been reluctant to shoulder, activists say.
States including California, Colorado, Georgia, Michigan,
and Nebraska have ruled out
state takeovers for
schools in restructuring, because either
state law does not permit it or the
state department of education lacks the capacity to manage a significant number of
schools.
West Virginia has relinquished the reins of a struggling
school system, leaving behind a rare
state -
takeover success story: a
state - hired superintendent in charge of a system with higher test scores
and better management
and buoyed by local acceptance.
Instead of
takeovers, closures,
and other dire options mentioned in press coverage of the law, most
states and school districts have chosen less aggressive interventions.
Yet because NCLB has made accountability tests the tail that wags the dog of the whole education system — threatening remediation
and state takeover for
schools that fall short — what's not tested often isn't taught.
A study published in 2005 by the Education Commission of the
States (ECS) on
state takeovers of
schools and districts noted that the
takeovers «have yet to produce dramatic consistent increases in student performance,»
and that the impact on learning «falls short of expectations.»
But
takeovers elevate the
state above local boards, independent charter authorizing works around local boards,
and RSD - like entities take
schools away from local boards.
So if the storm brought
state takeover and dramatic expansion of charter
schools to New Orleans, did it also bring vouchers?
In contrast, research suggests that the
state takeover and improvement efforts targeting Massachusetts» Lawrence Public
Schools generated limited signs of resistance.
in Pennsylvania that have created Achievement
School District laws, as well as NJ, MA,
and IN where there are direct
state takeovers.
While the
state - run Recovery
School District created in 2003 has its share of critics, credible external evaluation suggest that test scores
and graduation rates have indeed improved under the districtwide
takeover by charter
schools.
Mayor Richard M. Daley has made the key appointments in his
state - mandated
takeover of the Chicago public
schools — 13 people assigned to plug the system's $ 150 million deficit
and improve education for its 410,000 students.
Skim headlines from the press coverage of
school districts undergoing
state takeover and turnaround
and you will find significant signs of public frustration.
«Disruption» may be in vogue in business
schools, but disrupting — rather than fixing — struggling
schools has come to mean mass firings,
school closures,
and district or
state takeovers.
Nonetheless, even though the
state did not fully exploit the opportunity for comprehensive change, the
schools and the system itself unquestionably are better today than at the time of the
takeover.
A key early test will come from Wisconsin, where Milwaukee's mayor
and the
state's governor have said the prospect of a federal aid windfall should provide a major incentive for approval of legislation allowing a mayoral
takeover of the city's public
schools.
She said the
state would still provide the scores to parents
and students, but
schools that received F's, for example, would potentially be at no higher risk for a
state takeover,
and teachers» salaries would not be affected by low pass rates.
«This is about using the opportunity of the Muncie
Schools» funding crisis to float a test balloon for
school takeover in Indiana
and in the United
States,» says Boltz.
One hundred eighty - seven
schools have
school governance councils in place, the first condition required for families in the Nutmeg
State to use the Parent Trigger
and launch
school takeovers.
That number is small compared to the Atlanta
and Philadelphia scandals, yet with more
state policies — like teacher evaluations, merit pay,
and takeovers of
schools with poor ISTEP + scores — riding on students» scores on
state tests,
state officials, education experts,
and parents told StateImpact Indiana they see these pressures to get results as incentives for teachers who can't hack it to bend the rules on
state tests.
We will stand for fair funding for our students
and against
state takeovers of our public
schools.
While test scores rose in cities like Boston, Chicago
and New York after mayors took control of the
schools,
state takeovers have been less successful.
Public education advocates will have many opportunities in the coming months to fight for greater funding for our children's
schools and against
state takeovers that hand our democratically controlled
school boards over to private third party operators.
Wisconsin Public
Schools have seen a billion dollars cut since 2011, as well as a 2015 public
takeover of MPS that was snuck into the last
state budget
and met fierce resistance
and eventually was defeated.
We know this legislative cycle the privatizers will come back even harder
and we continue to build a movement against any
state takeovers of our public
schools.
The
state's largest
school district remains a Hilltop client as it deals with a crisis in funding
and a possible
takeover by the
state.
The battle between traditional
schools and charters has been particularly sharp in the Houston ISD, the
state's largest district, which is threatened with a
state takeover unless it turns over 10 underperforming
schools to a charter operator.
With many
state elected officials continuing to call for the
takeover of Milwaukee Public
Schools, the coalition is using the actions —
and social media — to build a list of engaged parents
and educators for future action
and quick mobilization.
A recent poll by Tulane University found that two - thirds of the respondents supported the
state takeover of New Orleans»
schools,
and nearly 80 percent thought that parents should be able to send their children to any
school in the city.
ATLANTA On Thursday, the Annenberg Institute for
School Reform
and the Southern Education Foundation released a new report criticizing the proposed
state takeover district in Georgia
and urging the
state to instead turn to evidence - based reform strategies such as sustainable community
schools.
Opponents of the new rule say the move could set the table for additional
state takeovers or interventions in underperforming
schools,
and fear the new system is too complex.