Sentences with phrase «seriously flawed paper»

A number of review editors resigned as a reaction against the publication of what they regarded as a seriously flawed paper.

The Soon and Baliunas paper was so bad that half of the Climate Research journal editorial staff resigned in protest because the seriously flawed paper should never have passed peer review.

Not exact matches

This graphic depicts the carbon intensity of shipping wine from various global wine regions to key U.S. cities and bases its data on a seriously flawed, two - year - old working paper that is filled with untested assumptions, has not been peer reviewed, and does not accurately reflect the complexities of greenhouse gas emissions in the wine sector.

The criticism of our paper was seriously flawed.

This viewpoint appears to have been driven into the IPCC by a strong desire for lower natural variability from the climate modelling community and was largely done off the back of the seriously flawed MBH paper.

Our «Physics of the Earth's atmosphere» papers show that CO2 does not cause global warming, and that the current climate models are seriously flawed (summary here).

As it is, this adds to the list of Nature - brand journal climate science papers that I regard as seriously flawed.

While this doesn't by itself demonstrate that the paper is seriously flawed, many of us identified serious flaws in the audio version of the presentation he gave.