I do see problems with judging teachers
solely on test score gains in reading and math, but we've got to start somewhere.
Due to this general disconnect between achievement and attainment effects of choice programs and, in a few cases in our sample, individual choice schools, we caution commentators and regulators to be more humble and circumspect in judging school choice programs and schools of choice based
solely on their test score effects.
The casual ease with which I hear schools and teachers labeled as «good» or «bad» based
solely on test scores is disconcerting, because it actually matters quite a lotwhy scores move.
As we continue to study choice - based policies in K — 12 education, one challenge we must confront is the push - pull created by high - stakes accountability measures designed to assess schools, students, and educators, based
solely on test scores — an area where choice proponents and opponents often find common ground.
While there are many critics of the subjective approach, it has an important role in order to balancing out the «teach to the test» and other negative consequences of relying
solely on test scores.
California uses both an elaborate report card (with 50 criteria) and a school ranking (on a scale of 1 to 10) based
solely on test scores.
Educators have also questioned policies in which a decision to hold a student back is based
solely on test scores.
For more than a decade, we used the Academic Performance Index (API), which was based
solely on test scores and established 800 as proficient on a scale of 200 to 1000.
In some cases, schools that typically would not fare so well based
solely on test scores leapfrogged over schools with more elevated reputations.
The ASD selects schools, measured
solely on test scores, and then turns them over to charter school operators to manage.
Because they are judged almost
solely on test scores, some schools have neglected mental health and counseling.
Much of the anxiety surrounding math comes directly from classrooms that don't actively advocate for a growth mindset — a way of thinking that emphasizes effort and understanding concepts instead of focusing
solely on test scores and right answers.
This data is based
solely on test scores, as was the old state accountability system, the Academic Performance Index (API).
«I don't believe merit pay based
solely on test scores is appropriate,» said Marc Liebman, superintendent of the Berryessa Union School District in San Jose, Calif. «The research I did [for] my doctorate... indicated that using test scores as a hammer doesn't work.
This bill further provides that an educator is not: (1) Required to spend the educator's personal money to appropriately equip a classroom; (2) Evaluated by professionals, under the teacher evaluation advisory committee, without the same subject matter expertise as the educator; (3) Evaluated based on the performance of students whom the educator has never taught; or (4) Relocated to a different school based
solely on test scores from state mandated assessments.
Not exact matches
The law includes an indefinite prohibition
on test scores being used «
solely or primarily» in decisions about student promotion and placement, and strikes the grades from students» permanent records.
Thus no system should rely
solely on the snapshot of a single year's
test scores in making decisions about incentives or consequences.
This vacuum stems not only from the difficulty of the endeavor but also from a persistent national clash between an obsession to train students
solely for high
scores on multiple - choice
tests and an angry disenchantment with measuring progress of public schools, educators, or education schools.
In my reading, I see this phrase «achievement gap» as referring
solely to results
on test scores.
Outside of school, policy makers and the media are no longer heard judging programs, schools, school districts, or states
solely on the basis of
test scores.
Sometimes called «exam schools,» because
test scores are typically part of their selection process and a handful of them rely
solely on such
scores, they tailor their curricula and teaching to high - performing, high - potential kids who want a high school experience that emphasizes college - prep, or college - level, academics.
Plans that rely
solely on student
test scores have the most opponents, including many parents, who scorn «teaching to the
test,» in which students are drilled to increase their
test scores rather than taught to understand the underlying material and learning skills to last a lifetime.
Proponents, insisting that tying teacher salaries to measurable standards will improve schools, have instituted a wide variety of incentive plans across the country: Some evaluate teachers based
solely on standardized
test scores, some
on teacher skill development; some offer more pay to teachers working in at - risk schools or with at - risk children, or for teaching certain subjects.
The authors infer
solely from cost data that states with currently higher
test scores on exams such as the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) should not need significant new resources.
While some states still judge schools
solely based
on standardized
test scores, these polls reveal that most parents and guardians do not.
As a result of our findings of no consistent statistical association between the achievement and attainment effects in school choice studies we urged commentators and policymakers «to be more humble» in judging school choice programs or schools of choice based
solely or primarily
on initial
test score effects.
Schools, and those of us working in them, are deemed «failing» based
solely on a single
test's
scores, with no consideration of the growth in our students»
scores.
Nerad's letter said the designation is based partly
on student achievement, student growth, closing achievement gaps and
on - track graduation and post-secondary readiness, but DPI spokesman John Johnson clarified that the designation is
solely based
on state
test scores and 2011 graduation rates.
As educators, we realize that the quality of a child's education can not be measured
solely by
scores on standardized reading and math
tests, which by their nature do not assess students» conceptual thinking, their ability to do research and to evaluate and defend ideas, their skill at written and oral expression, or their success in collaborative or teamwork settings.
* UPDATED A contingent of LA parents, armed with a petition of about 420 signatures, will ask the state Board of Education this week to adopt a summative rating to evaluate schools in addition to a number of proposed measures that move beyond ranking schools
solely based
on test scores.
Their avowed goals include less
testing, an end to high - stakes uses of
tests (that is, making decisions about students, educators, or schools
solely or primarily
on test scores), and implementation of other, educationally sound assessment practices.
No important academic decision about a student, a teacher, an administrator, a school or a district should be made
solely on one type of evidence, such as standardized
test scores.
Such risk factors, however, complicate the interpretation of large - scale standardized
test scores and their related value - added estimates, as VAMs rely
solely on large - scale standardized
test scores to yield their growth estimates.
Second, for Group A teachers whose
scores formerly relied
solely on the PARCC
test for 50 % of their
score, no EOC exams were ever given.
Our outcomes are not
solely based
on student
test scores — but
on graduation rates, college acceptances, and meaningful jobs.
Instead of relying
on intelligence and achievement
test scores solely for identification, multiple criteria would be used, including more non-traditional measures such as observing students interacting with a variety of learning opportunities (Passow & Frasier, 1996) it is a belief of many in the field of gifted education that new conceptions of giftedness and a new paradigm for identifying and selecting students will help minority and disadvantaged students become more represented in gifted programs (VanTassel - Baska, Patton, & Prillaman, 1991; Ford, 1996).
Cuomo proposed legislation Thursday that would change how
test scores are used in evaluations to prevent teachers deemed «ineffective» or «developing» from facing termination or a denial of tenure based
solely on student
test scores.
A contingent of LA parents, armed with a petition of about 420 signatures, will ask the state Board of Education this week to adopt a summative rating to evaluate schools in addition to a number of proposed measures that move beyond ranking schools
solely based
on test scores.
b) High marks
on the other components of the evaluation — her principal's appraisal and her lesson plan — were outweighed by the «value - added measure» based
solely on student
test scores.
The irony is that if we want our kids to be truly successful (happy, healthy, fulfilled, and prepared for life outside of school), we need to challenge the narrow conception of success as
solely related to grades,
test scores, and educational credentials, and we must focus
on these other critical components.
ESSA replaces the controversial No Child Left Behind education law, which evaluated schools
solely on proficiency (i.e.
test scores) and went into effect in 2002.
Narrowing the Curriculum: No Child Left Behind, which judged schools
solely on their students» math and reading
test scores, prompted schools across the nation to abandon science, social studies, art, music, physical education and other subjects in pursuit of high
scores in the
tested subjects.
Just as we would be reluctant to celebrate a school
solely on the basis of its
test scores, we would not acclaim schools strictly because they offer equitable learning opportunities, a positive learning environment, or excel at one of the eight other criteria we've identified as key to closing opportunity gaps.
Education plays an enormous role in lifting people out of poverty, but to hold educators
solely accountable for the impact poverty has
on current students — and to do so using
test scores — defeats the goal.
StudentsFirst brags, «Unlike other education report cards, ours doesn't look at
test scores or teacher performance, but focuses
solely on whether state laws are giving schools the tools to do the best job for our kids.»
Opposition against teacher evaluation based
solely on student
test scores is strong.
The new system Fariña outlined begins in 2017 and newly mandates that educators may not be rated ineffective
solely on the basis of
test scores.
Teachers at five elementary schools received bonuses based
solely on how much their students»
scores improved
on the Stanford Achievement
Test during one school year.
He was the first to flunk huge numbers of students every year based
solely on their end - of - year Iowa
test scores.
I feel it is unfair for the education department to pass down direction for teacher / principal evaluation that is based,
solely or in part,
on student
test score performance.