Sentences with phrase «sorts of administrative decision»

But this specified expertise can not be imputed to all sorts of administrative decision - makers, and so the precedential value of Pezim and Southam is limited.

Not exact matches

While punting issues to the membership may be appropriate where the decision involves matters of policy (say, in establishing a rule on how many hours of CPD time lawyers are required to obtain or in approving new rules of professional conduct or bylaws) rather than administrative decisins involving a weighing of Charter values, in these sort of circumstances, it's hard to see how the decision in BC or NB can survive judicial scrutiny (even if one doesn't believe that the earlier SCC decisionin TWU doesn't govern).

From the perspective of any administrative decision - maker, isn't the import of this sort of decision that it is better to provide coherent reasons to survive substantive judicial review?

In particular, it is very doubtful that the right of access to superior courts constiutionalized in Trial Lawyers extends to provincial court and to administrative tribunals (which is to say, to the sort of decision - maker at issue in Unison!)

I think prof. Daly is right to remind us about the links that exist between the two sorts of judicial review — that of legislation and that of administrative decisions — and to invite us to think about whether our approach to them makes sense when we consider them together, and not only in isolation.