By using the term «gaming» to describe the practice of schools trying to improve their metrics, we are missing the real problem, which is the high -
stakes accountability culture itself, says Brian Lightman
Not exact matches
After contributing an essay to the blueprint, Lightman said: «For too long the way children are assessed has been dominated by the demands placed on schools by performance tables and a
culture of high -
stakes accountability.
Union City, Kirp argues, is successful because it fosters a
culture of continuous improvement of existing staff and schools, utilizes bilingual instruction, and guarantees high quality pre-school — eschewing high
stakes accountability, Teach for America teachers, and school choice.
Since then, a review of the evolution of our assessment
culture reveals the almost complete dominance of a blind faith that high -
stakes accountability testing — local, state, national, international and interplanetary — is the way to improve schools.
As is true elsewhere, New York City's education leadership is struggling to calibrate the right balance between pressuring schools to change in response to high -
stakes accountability and supporting them to change by promoting networks, coaching, and collaboration to build a trust - based, professional
culture.
For example, the law eliminated an
accountability system that punished schools which failed to increase the percentages of students proficient in math and reading each year — a policy largely blamed for creating the high -
stakes culture of over-testing.
These can be a great tool for sparking conversations about ways teachers and students can improve their classroom
culture and instructional supports — although we do not recommend that such assessments be used for high -
stakes accountability.