Lately, our organization has been engaged in a spirited debate with former Texas Workforce Commission Chairman Tom Pauken, who has been conducting a vigorous campaign against what he perceives as an onerous high
stakes assessment system in public education and in the service of the promotion of a less rigorous vocational pathway to high school graduation.
In addition, abundant research has been conducted to examine the impact that movements toward standardization, accountability, and high -
stakes assessment systems have had on teachers» practices, beliefs, attitudes, and overall effectiveness (e.g., Hamilton & Stecher, 2004; National Board on Educational Testing and Public Policy, 2003; Parke, Lane, & Stone, 2006).
But the bad news is that our paltry support of innovative curriculum development and our reluctance to really change our high -
stakes assessment systems means that students and teachers will continue to focus on low - level kinds of learning.
Not exact matches
Commenting on the statement by the Secretary of State for Education setting out proposals to reform the
system of primary
assessment, Chris Keates, General Secretary of the NASUWT - The Teachers» Union, said: «It is important to recognise, and as the NASUWT has stated consistently, that many of the concerns expressed about statutory primary
assessment are the direct result of their use in the current high
stakes school accountability regime.
Critics of high -
stakes assessments will object that without an exhaustive set of controls, the
assessment system will end up penalizing some teachers and schools for circumstances beyond their control.
Editor's Note: Since this video was filmed in 2001, the Urban Academy has become a member of the New York Performance
Assessment Consortium, a coalition of public schools in New York State that uses a
system of performance - based
assessment in lieu of high -
stakes exit exams.
Concerned that high -
stakes testing was narrowing student
assessment down to a few scores, teachers and administrators in one Illinois district developed a
system to assess a range of skills — including critical thinking and social - emotional skills — they wanted students to master by the time they left school.
And only if the
assessment system holds all teachers responsible for results can the
system improve (as opposed to high -
stakes testing in four of the twelve years of schooling).
Beyond Standardized Testing: District Focuses on Assessing the Whole Child Concerned that high -
stakes testing was narrowing student
assessment down to a few scores, educators in one Illinois district developed a
system to assess a wide range of skills — including thinking skills and social skills — they wanted students to master.
Specific strategies include early warning
systems, special needs testing early intervention, intensified learning, and performance
assessments instead of high -
stakes standardized testing.
In a Wired blog, «Inside the Educational Data Revolution,» David Stewart, CEO of Tembo, laments how in the largest US school
systems, «millions of dollars are being spent on interim
assessment systems, intended to track student performance throughout the year and adapt teaching strategies in advance of the high -
stakes year - end tests.
In addition, since these
assessments are self - report surveys, there is also the issue of response bias — meaning a student's tendency to give answers that they believe are socially acceptable or to consistently answer «yes» or «no» regardless of the question asked.48 Since self - report measures tend to be weak in reliability and validity, state and local policymakers should refrain from including measures of learning mindsets and skills in high -
stakes accountability
systems.
Recognizing the challenges associated with use of student growth and
assessment data in the high
stakes evaluation of teachers and administrators, MASSP in collaboration with MASA has designed a one day institute April 25, 2018 for central office and K - 12 building administrators, teacher leaders, and others responsible for managing student data to come together as a team to revisit current practice, identify areas of strength and challenge within their
system, and make plans to further address growth requirements for the future.
For the past year in almost every available venue, opponents of high
stakes standardized
assessments of public school student achievement have been droning on about the perceived oppression of the Texas public school accountability
system, which has been rated by national education organizations as having produced the best high school graduation standard in the country when fully implemented.
Visit the consortium's site (www.performanceassessment.org) to learn about these schools» self - styled
assessment systems and to get pointers for advocating for alternatives to high -
stakes tests in your own state or district.
I am talking about the convergence of the Common Core State Standards (CCSS), high -
stakes assessments, and our new teacher and principal evaluation
system, referred to as annual professional performance reviews (APPR).
WHEREAS, the new evaluation
system based on NYS Education Law 3012c disproportionately weights the use of high
stakes test scores over qualitative
assessments as «Measures of Student Learning (MOSL)» in determining teacher performance, leading to a proliferation of Common Core - aligned tests with devastating consequences for teaching and learning conditions in our schools, and
To facilitate such examination, this brief reviews credible research exploring: the feasibility of combining formative
assessment (a basis for professional growth) and summative
assessment (a basis for high -
stakes decisions like dismissal); the various tools that might be used to gather evidence of teacher effectiveness; and the various stakeholders who might play a role in a teacher
assessment system.
In addition, Dr. Koenig has served as the lead software project manager for several technology - focused efforts for high -
stakes K - 12
assessment systems, including the Smarter Balanced
Assessment Consortium and ELPA21, whose solutions featured the development of RESTful web APIs for vendor
assessment delivery
system compliance, prototype development of
assessment delivery frameworks, and database design and development.
Those of us who are involved with PreK - 12 education reform have been dealing with a major firestorm of pushback to the Texas public school accountability
system and its high
stakes standardized
assessments that were adopted in 2009.
We need a new
assessment system that is not based on yearly, high -
stakes tests that capture one moment in time.
Virginia Virginia has taken strides to reduce high -
stakes testing and shift toward a
system of
assessments, including performance - based
assessments, aimed at informing instruction.
First, a low
stakes system of formative
assessments, both qualitative and quantitative, could apply to all children and would conform to accommodations for children with special needs.
In Pencils Down we take the high -
stakes tests to task, deconstruct the damage they cause to our education
system, highlight their inaccuracy as tools of measurement, and offer visionary forms of
assessment that are more authentic, democratic, fair, and accurate.
If results from the new K - 12
assessment systems are to be used for comparable high -
stakes decisions regarding individuals, such as the awarding of high school diplomas, similarly high thresholds for psychometric quality must be met (p. 17).
The
system also requires micro-engines to
stake an amount of nectar tokens on its
assessment of the digital products it's scanning.
It's also true that nobody believes social and emotional learning measurement should be employed for over-the-top, high
stakes and punitive
assessment systems that we saw academic achievement testing used for in the extremes of the No Child Left Behind era.