Alyssa Lyra Pitstick's trenchant analysis of Hans Urs von Balthasar represents an effort to recover a functional
standard of orthodoxy for Catholic theology.
We need a functional
standard of orthodoxy: one supple enough to do justice to the sorts of nuances Griffiths introduces, but one real enough to help us understand when theological speculation, novelty, and critique undermine rather than enrich the faith of the Church.
This doesn't mean that within church - based schools rigid
standards of orthodoxy must be enforced on all.
The shift in theology from mainline to Evangelical does not constitute a movement into heresy, even by Douthat's
standards of orthodoxy.
Parameters demarcate lines of inclusion and exclusion,
standards of orthodoxy and heterodoxy, and, in due course, religion constitutes the basis of collective identity and social reality.
Not exact matches
This meant that resolutions
of synodical conventions, while no doubt offering useful direction and guidance, could not be binding and could not be used as a
standard for assessing
orthodoxy.
But the defence
of faith and lifestyle which is Russian
Orthodoxy tolerates other faiths except «where an alien faith and alien
standards of life have been imposed on our people by force or by proselytism» (p. 4).
Andrew Ferguson informs and amuses at The Weekly
Standard about that other
orthodoxy in, «The Heretic: Who is Thomas Nagel and why are so many
of his fellow academics condemning him?»
With today's environmentalist
standard - bearers hailing from Hollywood and the political left, it is tempting to see the environmental movement as a Trojan Horse for liberalism, pantheism, and all manner
of threats to
orthodoxy.
As Chesterton understood, «
orthodoxy» is the exact reverse
of what people suppose it to be, an assertion
of «established» ideas and
standards: the «chief merit»
of orthodoxy, said Chesterton, is «that it is the natural fountain
of revolution and reform».
On the other hand there is very little in Fascist ideology to escape condemnation at the hands
of religious
orthodoxy, had the church desired to apply rigorous
standards.
Pricey administrators also like to promote the
orthodoxy of accountability and
standards, getting the public to think that the problem is the teachers, meanwhile they cut out specials and enrichment.
This time, it has delved into the primordial and come up with Graham Young, last seen scoring a double Godwin with pike, making both Nazi and Communist analogies in a single post.Young pushes the now -
standard Oz «help, I'm being oppressed line», naming me and Clive Hamilton as the enforcers
of orthodoxy.