Governor Nathan Deal floated the idea of
a state turnaround district in his first term; following his 2014 re-election, he made it a cornerstone of his education agenda.
Nelson Smith, former CEO of the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, and Brandon L. Wright of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute write about three approaches that are already in use: charter expansion,
state turnaround districts, and state - led, district - based solutions.
Not exact matches
It's a remarkable
turnaround for a politician who once sold his car two weeks before a primary to raise badly - needed campaign cash, barely won a Democratic
district leader race and was told by an opponent that the
state attorney general — now Gov. Andrew Cuomo — should investigate him for corruption.
Interim Buffalo School Superintendent Don Ogilvie says the school
district has a Friday deadline to submit a round of proposed
turnaround plans for four failing city schools to prevent closure by the New York
State Education Department.
Waiver: Comprehensive flexibility that the U.S. Department of Education has granted to more than 40
states and the
District of Columbia from key requirements of the No Child Left Behind Act (the current version of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act) in exchange for embracing certain Obama administration education - redesign priorities on teachers, testing, standards, and school
turnarounds.
Delaware lawmakers have approved a bailout, teachers have gotten pink slips, and
turnaround consultants have been hired — all for a budget crisis that former leaders of the
state's largest school
district say doesn't exist.
When the Education Achievement Authority (EAA), the
state of Michigan's school
turnaround district, launched in the fall of 2012 with 15 schools, hopes for rebirth in Detroit were high in many quarters.
Whether countervailing forces — federal pressure, political pressure from organized parent groups, or conscientious officials committed to the law's goals — are strong enough to force
states and
districts to implement meaningful
turnaround efforts remains to be seen, but the evidence so far is not encouraging.
Finally, we should continue to provide incentives for and encouragement to charters and educational management organizations to join the
state and
districts in the kind of novel forms of school
turnaround work and governance now being pioneered in Lawrence.
Detroit parents still have very few high - quality options, despite a number of different reform interventions, including putting a
state - appointed emergency manager in charge of the
district, pulling the lowest - performing schools into a statewide
turnaround district, and allowing a significant number of charter schools to operate.
To enable more widespread, successful
turnarounds in education,
state and
district leaders need to focus on two critical policy changes.
By his third - year residency in Memphis at the Tennessee Achievement School
District — the state's turnaround district aimed at bringing the bottom performing 5 percent of schools into the top performing 25 percent within five years — he found his initial interests that brought him to
District — the
state's
turnaround district aimed at bringing the bottom performing 5 percent of schools into the top performing 25 percent within five years — he found his initial interests that brought him to
district aimed at bringing the bottom performing 5 percent of schools into the top performing 25 percent within five years — he found his initial interests that brought him to Ed.L.D.
From higher standards and 21st - century assessments, to educator effectiveness and the
turnaround of failing schools, Race to the Top's program elements were anchored firmly in the good work of
states and
districts.
Frederick Hess and Thomas Gift have argued for developing school restructuring leaders; Bryan Hassel and Emily Ayscue Hassel have recommended that
states and
districts «fuel the pipeline» of untraditional
turnaround specialists.
Much of the gap can be filled, however, by allowing
states to allocate more of their federal dollars to supporting
turnaround efforts in low - performing
districts.
Then, nearly a decade ago, he became commissioner in Massachusetts, where he embraced the Common Core, revamped teacher evaluation, and championed
turnaround strategies for some of the
state's most - challenged
districts.
«Most studies of
district turnarounds are places like New Orleans, where the
district or the schools were in this really extreme
state, but this is the first recent example of a
turnaround just coming out of policy,» says Deming.
Skim headlines from the press coverage of school
districts undergoing
state takeover and
turnaround and you will find significant signs of public frustration.
Academic Gains, Double the # of Schools: Opportunity Culture 2017 — 18 — March 8, 2018 Opportunity Culture Spring 2018 Newsletter: Tools & Info You Need Now — March 1, 2018 Brookings - AIR Study Finds Large Academic Gains in Opportunity Culture — January 11, 2018 Days in the Life: The Work of a Successful Multi-Classroom Leader — November 30, 2017 Opportunity Culture Newsletter: Tools & Info You Need Now — November 16, 2017 Opportunity Culture Tools for Back to School — Instructional Leadership & Excellence — August 31, 2017 Opportunity Culture + Summit Learning: North Little Rock Pilots Arkansas Plan — July 11, 2017 Advanced Teaching Roles: Guideposts for Excellence at Scale — June 13, 2017 How to Lead & Achieve Instructional Excellence — June 6, 201 Vance County Becomes 18th Site in National Opportunity Culture Initiative — February 2, 2017 How 2 Pioneering Blended - Learning Teachers Extended Their Reach — January 24, 2017 Betting on a Brighter Charter School Future for Nevada Students — January 18, 2017 Edgecombe County, NC, Joining Opportunity Culture Initiative to Focus on Great Teaching — January 11, 2017 Start 2017 with Free Tools to Lead Teaching Teams, Turnaround Schools — January 5, 2017 Higher Growth, Teacher Pay and Support: Opportunity Culture Results 2016 — 17 — December 20, 2016 Phoenix - area
Districts to Use Opportunity Culture to Extend Great Teachers» Reach — October 5, 2016 Doubled Odds of Higher Growth: N.C. Opportunity Culture Schools Beat
State Rates — September 14, 2016 Fresh Ideas for ESSA Excellence: Four Opportunities for
State Leaders — July 29, 2016 High - need, San Antonio - area
District Joins Opportunity Culture — July 19, 2016 Universal, Paid Residencies for Teacher & Principal Hopefuls — Within School Budgets — June 21, 2016 How to Lead Empowered Teacher - Leaders: Tools for Principals — June 9, 2016 What 4 Pioneering Teacher - Leaders Did to Lead Teaching Teams — June 2, 2016 Speaking Up: a Year's Worth of Opportunity Culture Voices — May 26, 2016 Increase the Success of School Restarts with New Guide — May 17, 2016 Georgia Schools Join Movement to Extend Great Teachers» Reach — May 13, 2016 Measuring Turnaround Success: New Report Explores Options — May 5, 2016 Every School Can Have a Great Principal: A Fresh Vision For How — April 21, 2016 Learning from Tennessee: Growing High - Quality Charter Schools — April 15, 2016 School
Turnarounds: How Successful Principals Use Teacher Leadership — March 17, 2016 Where Is Teaching Really Different?
Lawrence provides a rare case of a leadership approach that resulted in notably impressive academic gains for students without generating the kind of negative response that typically accompanies
state takeover and
district turnaround efforts.
The creation of
turnaround districts by
states, indeed even the serious contemplation of such a move, suggests a real restlessness with the ability of traditional K — 12 governance to act on persistent school failure.
After the release of our December study — which found that just one percent of
district and charter school
turnarounds were successful, as defined as reaching at least the 50th percentile in
state proficiency in reading and math — Bryan wondered whether charter start - ups in similar neighborhoods would fare any better against such rigorous criteria.
While not spreading like wildfire, the idea of
turnaround districts has caught the imagination of leaders in a growing list of
states.
Other
states have created what amount to
turnaround districts in name only.
The brief history of
turnaround districts also raises new questions about who represents «the
state» itself.
This summer, a Virginia circuit court judge ruled that statewide
turnaround districts were unconstitutional in that
state.
We need to STRENGTHEN School Governance Council Language (public act 10 - 111) We also have to continually hammer / promote the message of a «TEAMWORK» collaborated effort between the local
district boards of education,
turnaround committees and the SGC (school governance councils) in the reconstitution of our low - performing schools once they have been «accepted» into the
state Commissioners Network.
After two years, the federal program providing billions of dollars to help
states and
districts close or remake some of their worst - performing schools remains an ambitious work in progress, with roughly 1,200
turnaround efforts under way but still no verdict on its effectiveness.
If
district leaders and their union counterparts either disagree on how to overhaul a particular school or submit a proposal for
turnaround that the
state education secretary deems as too weak, the secretary can override it.
Those frustrations were visible at a recent
State Board of Education meeting, as turnaround operators offered blunt assessments of the current state of affairs in IPS schools, while district officials unsuccessfully argued state officials» funding formula for the takeovers is inequit
State Board of Education meeting, as
turnaround operators offered blunt assessments of the current
state of affairs in IPS schools, while district officials unsuccessfully argued state officials» funding formula for the takeovers is inequit
state of affairs in IPS schools, while
district officials unsuccessfully argued
state officials» funding formula for the takeovers is inequit
state officials» funding formula for the takeovers is inequitable.
The
state would develop a
turnaround plan for these schools and then either give them back to the
district to run as prescribed or hire an outside contractor, such as a charter school operator.
readers and superintendents in Connecticut's thirty Alliance
Districts know, on March 28, 2013, Stefan Pryor, Malloy's Commissioner of Education, signed a contract with Mass Insight, a relatively new Massachusetts company, to «develop the
state's
turnaround strategy and improve the most struggling schools.»
This descriptive, mixed methods study uses survey data from
turnaround leaders in all 50
states and in - depth interviews with eight intentionally selected
state leaders to launch a discussion about how
states support
district turnaround efforts.
Authorizing charter schools to turn around some of the
state's lowest - performing schools through the statewide
turnaround Achievement School
District.
In addition to initiating
turnarounds in these schools, the Commissioner's Network is designed to serve as a vehicle for innovative initiatives, a platform for sharing effective practices, and a model for other schools and
districts throughout the
state.
Thomas Wei, an IES research scientist, instead pointed me to these profiles of potentially promising
turnaround practices in specific schools,
districts and
states.
In 2012 and 2013, IES asked 49
states and the
District of Columbia about their capacity to support failing schools receiving federal
turnaround money.
Furthermore, the most recent
state test scores showed that Denver performed better than most
districts in the
state, showing commendable improvements in
turnaround schools located in Far Northeast and Northwest Denver, even though the
district is still far from its own goal of 3.5 percent improvement in growth across all subjects.
New efforts labeled «recovery school
districts,» «achievement school
districts,» «
turnaround schools,» and the like are making their way into places that include Tennessee, Louisiana, and Arkansas, to name a few — efforts that allow
states to take over failing schools and relegate their management to private charter school operators that would be free to fire teachers and start from scratch.
The series includes a guide to help
district and
state leaders choose the best restructuring option for each school, updated in a 2nd edition released in 2009, and white papers identifying what we know from research about when the first four restructuring options under NCLB work: reopening as a charter school, contracting with external providers,
turnarounds with new leaders and staff, and
state takeovers.
Lee J. Rutledge, Senior Associate, National School Reform, provides technical assistance at
district and
state levels related to CTAC's teacher effectiveness and school
turnaround work.
Public Impact has surveyed the cross-sector experience and both led and studied education - sector successes to generate resources that help educators,
districts, and
states implement successful
turnarounds.
District as it grows its efforts to
turnaround the lowest performing schools in the
state.
With lawmakers duking it out over whether or not to eliminate a large number of teacher aides in elementary classrooms, it's hard to imagine that the
state and local school
districts will be able to keep school
turnaround efforts going into the future.
IPS superintendent Eugene White also says the
district will cooperate with the school
turnaround companies who will operate the four Indianapolis schools the
state will take over next year.
Carrie Hillyard, who leads the
turnaround team Evansville Vanderburgh School Corporation leaders created to assist five struggling
district schools, speaks to
State Board of Education members at a public hearing on the future of Glenwood Leadership Academy.
Public Impact produced some of the earliest work guiding
states and
districts choosing among school
turnaround strategies and has been the field leader in providing research, guidance and implementation support for
turnarounds within schools, charter restarts and innovation zones.
States and
districts can not do this alone; that is why nonprofit providers like Talent Development Secondary can provide the much needed capacity and expertise in the ESSA environment in school
turnaround, early warning systems and chronic absenteeism.
State and
District leaders can help more
turnaround - attempt schools succeed by selecting the right principals, training them, helping them transition to school models supported by teacher - leadership, tracking leading indicators of performance, and coaching principals to make needed changes fast.
«Extraordinary authority
districts» —
turnaround districts in which
states gain legal authority to take over and operate chronically underperforming schools and / or
districts — can fundamentally transform school structures and practices.