So far as applies here, Family Procedure Rules 2010 (FPR 2010) r 4.4 (1), deals with
striking out of a claim (in almost exactly the same terms as Civil Procedure Rules 1998 (CPR 1998) r 3.4 (1)-RRB- as follows:
In Decadent the relevant breach which triggered the operation of CPR r 3.9 was the claimant's failure to comply with an unless order relating to the payment of court fees which provided for
strike out of the claim in the event of default.
Successful
striking out of claim brought against the Second Defendant on the basis of alleged delays in listing a Parole Board hearing.
At first instance, Mr Justice Jay
struck out all of the claims, on the Commissioner's application, pursuant to CPR r 3.4.
Not exact matches
The enthusiastic response
of the audience really
struck me as
out -
of - place in a church that
claims to teach the Gospel
of Jesus.
Wenger will
claim it's a player he has had his eye on and tried to sign previously on many occasions.Abua gets a move away from a club he no longer wishes to play for in addition to a nice financial package and bigger wages.The fans get a top top replacement for Sanchez.Laca gets a
strike partner.The team gets rid
of someone who has reportedly left a nasty smell and atmosphere in the dressing room.The Board get a (temporary) get
out of jail card.We as fans lose Walcott as a bonus.Mika to sign as an added bonus.WOW the garden is full
of roses.Will probably get stuffed by Palace on Saturday.
Reports overnight
claimed that a deal had been
struck at # 10.5 m, but Sky Sports
claims that Newcastle will in fact pay # 12m for the England international, who is
out of favour at White Hart Lane.
The Queens Park Rangers captain
claimed he was «gutted» over his «stupid reaction» against the Tigers, having lashed
out at midfielder Tom Huddlestone and
struck him between the legs, earning himself a ninth red card
of his career.
Last season Firmino scored 7 goals and
claimed 10 assists, whilst the season before he scored 16 with 11 assists, so it's clear he needs to be around the box, instead
of being deployed
out wide, as his performances earlier this season
out wide did not show his goalscoring threats, but once he moved into the middle he showed his attacking ability,
striking the post twice.
Defending his nutty conspiracy theory, Mr McCluskey
claimed: «We found
out just a couple
of years ago that the chair
of my union then, the Transport and General Workers Union, was an MI5 informant at the time that there was a
strike taking place that I personally as a worker was involved in.
The only factor that could stop you is if the suspension
of your court case is due to be lifted or the banks» solicitors apply to have your
claim struck out of court, in which case you will need to decide quite quickly.
And you
struck out this portion you wrote: If the scientists had actually substituted or replaced the tree ring proxy data with instrument data, then McIntyre and Fuller would have a valid
claim of fraudulent behavior by Phil Jones et al..
The issue at the centre
of Wyatt v Vince [2015] UKSC 14 (on appeal from Vince v Wyatt [2013] EWCA Civ 495) was the power
of family courts to
strike out a
claim for matrimonial financial provision.
It was reported earlier this month that the German metalworkers» union had
struck a deal so employees wishing to take time
out to look after children or ailing parents have the option to reduce their working week to 28 hours for a total
of two years and
claim the right to return to full - time employment afterwards.
In the Court
of Appeal the judges had
struck out a wife's
claim for «abuse
of the court's process» (FPR 2010 r 4.4 (1)(a) and (b)-RRB-.
In any event the tribunal retains the power to
strike out claims on the grounds, inter alia, that the case is scandalous or vexatious, or has no reasonable prospect
of success.
BA applied to have the representative element
of Emerald's
claim struck out.
The tribunal
struck out her
claim as it had no reasonable prospect
of success.
The motion judge had also applied an unjustly - high threshold for establishing the wife's unequal division
claim, and had deprived her
of notice that it might be
struck out permanently.
These questions were the subject
of a motion brought by McDonald's Restaurants
of Canada seeking to
strike out a plaintiff's
claim for unlawful invasion
of his privacy on the basis that it disclosed no reasonable cause
of action.
(following FNB v Ann above,
strike out / limitation period for extortionate credit bargain
claim / issue estoppel / abuse
of process)
In B v B [2007] EWHC 789 (Fam), [2007] All ER (D) 144 (Mar) Mrs Justice Baron held that the «developing needs
of [a] child» and the «provision
of future housing for [her] is something that merits proper investigation» by the court; and that accordingly a
claim by the mother should not be
struck out in limine (at the outset
of the case).
This has led to complete rubbish,
strike -
outs and amended or substitute particulars
of claim.
AC0135666 was then decided at first instance, which gave insurers some reassurance that the
striking out of obviously fraudulent
claims was not a mere aspiration.
Fari had no representation at the trial or hearing to
strike out the
claim — much to the annoyance
of the trial judge who made adverse comment.
The defendant applied to have the
claim struck out, and the judge accepted the defendant's contention that youthful playfulness was not a characteristic which satisfied either
of the limbs
of s 2 (2)(b).
If someone genuinely defames someone, and there is a meritorious
claim against them, would the
claim would be
struck out merely because the defamatory speech related to a matter
of public interest and the plaintiff (respondent on the motion) couldn't prove that there was no possible defence, or they couldn't prove the damages they suffered were sufficiently serious?
Mrs Fari's
claim was
struck out entirely when video evidence emerged showing that her allegations
of considerable disability were wholly false.
Moore Stephens applied for the liquidator's
claim to be
struck out on the grounds that Stone & Rolls was guilty
of fraud and was seeking to rely upon and recover a loss caused by its own fraud.
(2015) Advising and acting for a solicitor and LLP member in relation to an appeal to the Employment Appeal Tribunal concerning the
striking out of his PIDA
claim on the basis
of judicial proceedings immunity (the
claim settled shortly before the EAT hearing).
Christopher Smith QC examines the pros and cons
of a defendant applying for a summary determination (summary judgment or
strike out) in a professional liability
claim and, by reference to three recent decisions, suggests some practical lessons that can be learned.
«They paid
out a lump sum for the entire
claim because it wasn't worth it to them to carry the expense
of running the case,»
Strike says.
The Department applied to
strike out the
claim on the grounds that no duty
of care was owed to the plaintiff and was successful in the High Court and in the Court
of Appeal.
Court
strikes out parts
of swap
claim against bank In a recent decision in the Commercial Court, parts
of a # 81m
claim against a bank relating to...
Take for example, the 2012 Ontario Superior Court
of Justice decision, Al - Dandachi v. SNC - Lavalin Inc., in which the defendant brought a motion to
strike out all references in a plaintiff's statement
of claim relating to his human rights
claim for failing to disclose a reasonable cause
of action.
The legal principles for
striking out a
claim were recently discussed in the Saskatchewan case
of Filson v AG Canada 2014 SKQB 164 16.
Karas v Ontario, 2013 ONSC 6053; Bilich v. Toronto Police Services Board, 2013 ONSC 1445 — These cases are decisions from motions to
strike out Statement
of Claim.
• JJW Ltd v IBRC Asset Finance Ltd (2017), in relation to an application by the Defendant to
strike out the Claimant's
claim for c. # 150 million, arising
out of alleged breaches
of an # 82 million loan agreement.
Where a claimant with a valid
claim seeks to dishonestly enhance that
claim or conspires with another so as to enable that person to present an exaggerated or groundless
claim, should the claimant be
struck out and be denied all compensation despite having a valid cause
of action?
The court below had
struck out her
claim as disclosing no cause
of action.
The judge found that the injunctive and declaratory relief sought by the claimant was too wide and
struck out the parts
of the
claims for relief which fell outside the scope
of what was permissible on a collective challenge.
16 York points to the Important Notice found in the 1995 - 1997 Undergraduate Program Calendar as an absolute defence to any
claim arising
out of the
strike.
[43] Given the poor state
of the Amended Statement
of Claim, I
strike it
out in its entirety.
The cause
of action against the father was intentional assault and the
claim was
struck out on limitation grounds.
The Chandhoks argued that this part
of the
claim should be
struck out because caste is not a protected characteristic.
Therefore, we applied to the Court on behalf
of our client for an order that unless the Claimant provided security within 28 days that the
claim be
struck out.
He also ordered that if the
claim was
struck out that the Defendant would be awarded her costs
of the whole proceedings, including an immediate payment on account
of those costs.
For example, in Warraich v. University
of Manitoba, 2003 MBCA 58, the Manitoba Court
of Appeal
struck out a
claim on the basis that the inherent jurisdiction
of the Manitoba Court
of Queen's Bench had been displaced by the University's statutory dispute resolution regime.
In Ernst the Court
of Appeal does not cite any
of these Alberta cases, but rather points to the 2011 Supreme Court
of Canada decision in R v Imperial Tobacco Canada Limited, 2011 SCC 42, where at paras 17 to 26 the Supreme Court sets
out the test to be met for a motion to
strike claims for the failure to disclose a reasonable cause
of action.
The employment tribunal
struck both
of those elements
of the
claim out.