A group of business and civic leaders is urging the Los Angeles school district and teachers union to quickly develop a new evaluation system that incorporates
student test score data and gives families more access to information about instructors.
This includes the new teacher evaluation pilot program that is part of the revised version of Gov. Dan Malloy's school reform package contained in what is now Public Law 116, which will only involve eight - to - 10 districts; the fact that NEA and AFT affiliates are still opposed to this plan and are also battling reformers over another evaluation framework that uses
student test score data that the unions had supported just several months earlier also raises questions as to whether Connecticut can actually earn the flexibility from federal accountability that has been gained through the waiver.
Those reforms include «college - and career - ready standards,» targeted intervention in low - performing schools and new teacher and principal evaluations — that include
student test score data.
* Revamp teacher evaluations to include several new categories, including the addition of several years worth of
student test score data analyzed to show whether a teacher is effective.
Also Thursday, the Los Angeles Board of Education formally directed its superintendent, for the first time, to include
student test score data as part of teachers» evaluations.
Moreover, in many states, up to half of each evaluation score is based on value - added analysis, a complex statistical method that seeks to determine each teacher's contribution to student growth using
student test score data.
Abstract Researchers have devoted substantial attention to the use of
student test score data to measure teacher performance.
Provide the state with information about the academic program at the participating school and
student test score data
Within the last year, three influential organizations — reflecting researchers, practitioners, and philanthropic sectors — have called for a moratorium on the current use of
student test score data for educator evaluations, including the use of value - added models (VAMs).
As part of each teacher's regular evaluation, some districts already look at
student test score data that demonstrate how much students advanced while working with that teacher (value - added data).
But Superintendent Jennifer Cheatham said Monday she is not recommending sharing
student test score data at this point.
Louisiana has used
student test score data since 2006 to determine which teacher training programs are most effective.
At issue is a 2006 law that bars the state from using
student test score data for measuring teacher performance.
The new system will rate teachers by looking at
student test score data, as well as the scores teachers receive from observations conducted by administrators.
Spagna argues that
student test score data is the key to helping teacher programs — and the state — figure out whether they are succeeding.
The effort to analyze the performance of its university schools of education in recruiting and training teachers — using value - added analysis of
student test score data — is one of the most - pathbreaking in the nation.
Even for teachers with relevant
student test score data available for evaluations, it is critical to use multiple measures to capture the myriad of important things teachers are expected to do.
Provide the department of public instruction with information about the academic program at the participating school and
student test score data
But even so, data representing how students experienced your class, your staff, or your school feels really different than
student test score data.
Because they have spent little on developing robust data systems that can monitor student achievement and teacher performance means (and thanks to state laws that had banned the use of
student test score data in teacher evaluations), districts haven't been able to help those aspiring teachers by pairing them with good - to - great instructors who can show them the ropes.
Not exact matches
Farrell notes that colleges and universities tout the successes of their incoming
students —
test scores, academic achievement, acceptance rates, and the like — but rarely spend the same amount of energy sharing
data about job placement and success rates of graduates.
Duckworth was a co-author on a paper published last year that compared self - reporting on grit, self - control and conscientiousness with actual
test scores and behavior
data of
students at 32 Boston schools.
Using longitudinally linked,
student - level
data collected from two urban school districts, New York City and Washington, DC, Mathematica estimated the impacts of five EL middle schools on
students» reading and math
test scores.
In addition to
test scores, PISA collects
data on
student learning styles.
As part of New York's Race To The Top federal grant, the state is working with
data integration companies to build a database of
student information, including demographics,
test scores and behavior records.
7:15 pm: Juan asks DioGuardi: The NYC Department of Education is poised to release to the public in the coming weeks Teacher
Data Reports, which are based on
student scores on state
tests.
The yearly releasing and parsing of
students test scores took place Monday with Mayor Michael Bloomberg finding lots of good news among the reams of
data.
«The
data points shouldn't be
test scores but parent engagement, the amount of [
student] suspensions, and the improvements made at struggling schools.»
«After developing our scale,
data from follow - up
testing confirmed that
students» engagement
scores were positively correlated with indicators of performance, such as good grades and independent learning outside of school motivated by interest.
Doctoral
student Helen Malone has been researching time and learning and says that because this is so new, «there's no rigorous
data yet, but what they are finding is that kids are making significant gains on standardized
test scores.»
We use
test -
score data from the years 2000 — 01 to 2005 — 06 from the 36 charter schools that enroll
students in grades 3 through 12.
Using
student - level
data from two states, Harvard Professor Martin West and I found that 40 to 60 percent of schools serving mostly low - income or underrepresented minority
students would fall into the bottom 15 percent of schools statewide based on their average
test scores, but only 15 to 25 percent of these same schools would be classified as low performing based on their
test -
score growth.
A second study, recently published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) by Gary Chamberlain, using the same
data as Chetty and his colleagues, provides fodder both for skeptics and supporters of the use of value - added: while confirming Chetty's finding that the teachers who have impacts on contemporaneous measures of
student learning also have impacts on earnings and college going, Chamberlain also found that
test -
scores are a very imperfect proxy for those impacts.
States can foster innovation and develop approaches to gathering and publishing
data beyond
test scores, such as
student, staff, and parent surveys, career and college readiness benchmarks, and post-secondary outcomes.
Though we do not have
data on every aspect of teachers» working conditions, we do know certain characteristics of their
students that many believe affect the teaching conditions at a school: the percentage of low - income
students at the school (as estimated by the percentage eligible for a subsidized lunch), the shares of
students who are African - American or Hispanic, average
student test scores, and class sizes.
For instance,
data may show that the
students who pass through one teacher's class consistently
score lower on state achievement
tests than the
students in another teacher's class.
The companies should be required to then forward these instructional
data, along with
test scores, subscores on specific components of the
test, and
student demographic information, to the state in a standardized format.
They agree that the 4 - year - old law has brought unprecedented attention to those
students by requiring schools to isolate
test -
score data for English - learners.
It cites 2011 TIMSS (Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study)
data showing no significant difference in the
scores of Australian boys and girls in Year 4 and Year 8, and notes that male and female
students perform equally in international comparative
testing in Singapore — a top five country in PISA (Programme for International
Student Assessment) mathematics.
Chenoweth: They all studied their
test score data very closely in order to figure out which
students needed extra help and to see patterns in achievement.
Among the districts in the
data, one standard deviation in percent free / reduced lunch is 21 percentage points and one standard deviation in average
test scores is 0.35
student - level standard deviations.
«Nearly all states are building high - tech
student data systems to collect, categorize and crunch the endless gigabytes of attendance logs,
test scores and other information collected in public schools,» reported the New York Times in a front - page story last May, confirming the scope of the trend.
Students entered the G&T program in 6th grade, and their progress was measured when they were 7th graders, using
data drawn from their Stanford Achievement
Test scores and attendance rates.
In response to the criticism that teacher impacts on
student test scores are inconsistent over time, the authors show that «although VA measures fluctuate across years, they are sufficiently stable» that selecting teachers even based on a few years of
data would have substantial impacts on
student outcomes, such as earnings.
Test - retest reliability over short periods of time is the preeminent psychometric question for report card items because the
data are not useful if
scores that teachers generate for individual
students on individual items are unstable during a period of time in which it is unlikely that the
student has changed.
«We have
data that shows that if teachers
scored high on their evaluations,
students showed improvement on state
tests.»
If elementary
students are not affected by later start times, as my
data suggest (albeit not definitively), it may be possible to increase
test scores for middle school
students at no cost by having elementary schools start first.
Study coauthor Matthew Gaertner, who produced calculations for this article that were not part of the published study, said displaced
student test scores dropped 12 percent in reading, 9 percent in math, and 19 percent in writing compared with what they would have
scored had the school not closed (using modeling developed from historic
test data).
The
data needed to best answer these questions are the
student - level
test -
score and demographic information collected by the New York State Department of Education.
Two recent experimental evaluations of the Louisiana Scholarship Program found negative effects of the program on
student test scores but one study was limited to just a single year of outcome
data and the second one (which I am leading) has only analyzed two years of outcome
data so far.