Overall, charter high schools, like charter elementary and middle schools serve different populations of
students than their public school counterparts (See here).
Not exact matches
All this despite the fact that private
schooling doesn't actually yield better outcomes for
students, according to a recent Statistics Canada report (instead, the apparent academic success of private
school student is due to their socioeconomic backgrounds).9 A UBC study also found that
students from
public schools scored higher in first - year university classes
than their private
school counterparts.10
This does not mean that
students are not inspired to learn just as much if not more
than their
public school counterparts do.
Belluck has used his own Twitter handle in recent days to dog the State Education Department over the results of third - through eighth - grade English and math test scores that showed charter
school students performing slightly better
than their
public school counterparts.
For example, a 2010 report by UCLA's Civil Rights Project found that black charter
school students were twice as likely to attend
schools that enrolled fewer
than 10 percent non-minority
students as their
counterparts in traditional
public schools.
Our new findings demonstrate that, while segregation for blacks among all
public schools has been increasing for nearly two decades, black
students in charter
schools are far more likely
than their traditional
public school counterparts to be educated in intensely segregated settings.
In Chicago,
students who attended a charter high
school were 7 percentage points more likely to earn a regular high
school diploma
than their
counterparts with similar characteristics who attended a traditional
public high
school.
To quote from a famous interview given by James Coleman, cited in this book, «Catholic high
schools educate
students better
than public schools do...
students drop out four times more often
than their Catholic
school counterparts.»
Bluntly put, do
students in charter
schools learn more
than their
counterparts in traditional
public schools?
Public school students have more classroom access to the information highway
than their private
school counterparts, a federal report released last week says.
Based on the findings presented here, the typical
student in Michigan charter
schools gains more learning in a year
than his [traditional
public school (TPS)-RSB-
counterparts, amounting to about two months of additional gains in reading and math.
In general, charter
schools that serve low - income and minority
students in urban areas are doing a better job
than their traditional
public -
school counterparts in raising
student achievement, whereas that is not true of charter
schools in suburban areas.
Thus,
public school students might have been encouraged to try harder on these tests
than their voucher
counterparts.
In the 2009 - 10 academic year, for instance,
students received approximately 1,360 hours more instructional time
than their
counterparts in Chicago's
public schools, with
school schedules resembling those of
students in Seoul, Shanghai, or Tokyo.
Similarly, in Louisiana, research after the first and second years of the program found voucher
students performed worse
than their
public school counterparts, but after three years, performance was roughly similar across both groups.
Using data from the Florida Tax Credit (FTC) Scholarship program, we find that low - income Florida
students who attended private
schools using an FTC scholarship enrolled in and graduated from Florida colleges at a higher rate
than their
public school counterparts.
In 2006, the National Center for Education Statistics found that
public school students do as well as or better
than their private
school and charter
school counterparts.
Specifically, the data book reports that two
public charter
schools in Eastern Idaho serve a significantly lower number of Hispanic
students than their district
counterparts (24 % in
public charter vs. 51 % in the Jerome Joint SD, for example).
In fact,
public charters are doing better
than their district
school counterparts at getting these at - risk
students to graduate, as can be seen in data from the 2008 high
school cohort (
students graduating four years later and released in 2013).
In 2014, New York City's budget office released a report making the claim that attrition among charter
schools of special education
students was higher
than their district
public school counterparts.
In Arizona, second only to California in the number of charter
schools statewide,
students were 7 percent more likely to be proficient in reading and math, and in Illinois charter
students were found to be 21 percent more proficient in math and 16 percent more proficient in reading
than their
public -
school counterparts.
In a new study released today by a team of researchers led by Josh Cowen at the University of Kentucky, we learn that voucher
students in Milwaukee are more likely to graduate high
school and go to a four year college
than their
counterparts in the Milwaukee
Public Schools.
Five years ago, one group of researchers found that charter
school students across Chicago and the whole state of Florida scored slightly worse on math tests
than their
public high
school counterparts.
The study of charter
schools in 15 states and the District of Columbia found that, nationally, only 17 % of charter
schools do better academically
than their traditional
counterparts, and more
than a third «deliver learning results that are significantly worse
than their
student [s] would have realized had they remained in traditional
public schools.»
In order to meet this parental demand for choice and the
public's desire for more high quality
public educational options for families, three key things must be addressed in California: the funding inequity which results in charter
school students being funded at lower levels
than their traditional
public school counterparts, the lack of equitable facilities for charter
school students, and restrictive and hostile authorizing environments such as LAUSD Board Member Steve Zimmer's recent resolution limiting parent choice.
But the most extensive survey of
student performance at charter
schools, from Stanford University's Center for Research on Education Outcomes, found that, of the 2,403 charter
schools tracked from 2006 to 2008, only 17 percent had better math test results
than the
public schools in their area, while 37 percent had results that were «significantly below» those of the
public schools and 46 percent had results that were «statistically indistinguishable» from their
public -
school counterparts.
Students in publicly funded and independently managed online charters across the country made far less progress
than their
counterparts in traditional
public schools.
Studies are showing, for example, that black
students in charter
schools are more likely
than their
counterparts in traditional
public schools to be educated in an intensely segregated setting.
Cami Anderson, former superintendent of Newark
public schools, talked about the way that current discipline policies negatively impact
students of color, referencing research that shows that adults view black girls as less innocent
than their white
counterparts as early as kindergarten.
On eighth - grade reading and math tests, charter -
school students performed worse
than their
public -
school counterparts by enormous margins — 2 to 3 standard deviations.
CREDO found that, on average,
students in New Jersey charter
schools are making greater gains in both reading and math
than their
counterparts in traditional
public schools.
It's a debate that includes disputes over whether charter
schools — untied to neighborhood boundaries — should be leveraged to help integrate
public schools racially and socioeconomically, whether poor
students benefit more from diverse classrooms, and whether charters are indeed less integrated
than their district
school counterparts.
A review by Florida TaxWatch found that the per - pupil figure in Florida
public schools was $ 10,308 last year; scholarship
students receive less
than 60 percent of the amount for their
public -
school counterparts.
The case alleges the way the state funds charter
schools is unconstitutional because less money is allocated per
student than to their traditional
public school counterparts.
The charter
students in Detroit gain over three months per year more
than their
counterparts at traditional
public schools.»
The charter
school student body is always going to be easier to manage
than its
public school counterpart, because charter
schools do not have a legal responsibility to accommodate any and all children who step across the threshold.
The report by Alan B. Krueger, a professor of economics and
public policy, analyzed data presented last year by Harvard University Professor of Government Paul E. Peterson that found black
students in the voucher
schools scoring 5.5 points higher on standardized tests
than their
counterparts in
public schools.
Eight of 11 empirical studies show that choice programs increase
students» tolerance for the rights of others and the likelihood to vote, volunteer, or give more to charity
than their
public school counterparts.
At KIPP, teachers make about $ 10,000 a year more
than their regular
public school counterparts, but they put in longer days, Saturday classes and summer
school - all extra time and extra resources to lift
students who begin KIPP below grade level.
The report found poor oversight when it came to ensuring accurate
student attendance, dramatically lower test scores
than their traditional
public school counterparts and difficulty accessing technology.
Most charters, at least here in Pennsylvania, receive considerably fewer dollars per
student than their traditional
public school counterparts.
Poor oversight when it comes to ensuring accurate
student attendance, dramatically lower test scores
than their traditional
public school counterparts and difficulty accessing technology were only some of problems the report found with CAVA and were echoed by Golovich, who was not involved in the compilation of the study.
In a 2014 meta - analysis, Pahlke and her colleagues reviewed the studies and found when examining
schools with the same type of
students and same level of resources — rather
than «comparing [those at] the
public co-ed
school to [their
counterparts at] the fancy private
school that's single - sex down the road» — there isn't any difference in how the
students perform academically.
In fact, in Milwaukee,
students receiving vouchers performed worse
than their
counterparts in the city's
public schools.
More
than 80 percent of
public charter
school students in Connecticut scored higher in both Math and English Language Arts
than their district
school counterparts on the 2016 - 17 SBAC, and 70 percent of charter
school students identify as low - income.
In virtually all instances, the charter
students did worse
than their
counterparts in regular
public schools.
In many cases,
students using vouchers to attend private
schools and religious academies are doing worse
than their
counterparts in
public schools.
LGBT
students in
public schools are more often victims of harassment based on their gender and sexual identities and are also less likely to have access to LGBT resources
than their
counterparts in private
schools (religious or otherwise).
Providing competitive wage career development opportunities is especially important considering the fact that half of all
public school students are now living at or below the poverty line and in light of recent studies which suggest
students receiving paid internships receive more job offers and higher salaries
than their unpaid
counterparts.