This study is critically important at a time when many deeply - flawed and misleading
studies about home birth have been receiving media attention.
I hope you will participate in
my study about home birth.
Not exact matches
The American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists emphasized the results of the Wax
study in its official statement on homebirth, siting that «Women inquiring
about planned
home birth should be informed of its risks and benefits based on recent evidence.
This
study was
about place of
birth, the options being
home, primary, secondary, or tertiary, not hospital
births all joined together.
She is currently involved in a research project
studying ob / gyn physician attitudes and knowledge
about home birth.
However, they sometimes draw different conclusions
about the safety of
home,
birth center or hospital
birth, even when they read the same
studies.
Last week, I read
about a new
study claiming
home births triple the rate of infant deaths due to lack of interventions.
As it has been shown that conducting a randomised controlled trial is not possible, the best evidence
about the safety of
home birth can only come from good quality, routine registrations such as the one we used in our
study.
«There are several significant hurdles which must be overcome if a
study is to make a useful contribution to the debate
about whether perinatal death is more likely if a
home birth is planned or if a hospital
birth is planned, and few (if any) readily available data sources can overcome all of these hurdles.
Caroline Homer, one of the authors of the
study, and Hannah Dahlen, a spokesperson for the Australian College of Midwives, take to the lay press to boast about the results of the study (Study of low risk women reveals good news on the home birth fr
study, and Hannah Dahlen, a spokesperson for the Australian College of Midwives, take to the lay press to boast
about the results of the
study (Study of low risk women reveals good news on the home birth fr
study (
Study of low risk women reveals good news on the home birth fr
Study of low risk women reveals good news on the
home birth front):
That book is full of misinformation, for example he cites the Johnson & Daviss
study saying «any remaing doubts
about the safety of
home birth were conclusively erased» by said
study — which isn't even remotely true (the
home birth data from that
study actually shows that neonatal mortality is 3 TIMES higher at
home):
These
studies were from Australasia, 13 14 Europe, 15 — 18 and the United States.19 Australian planned
home births had a perinatal death rate
about twice as high as these countries (table 5).
We found only one other
study, conducted in the United States, on mortality associated with breech, twin, and post-term
births at
home.9 This
study showed excess mortality in such
home births and voiced concern
about the trend to encourage midwives to engage in high risk practice.
The recently released MANA
study found a 15 % chance of postpartum hemorrhage at
home birth, compared to
about 5 % in the hospital.
In order to draw any conclusion
about the differences between
home and hospital
births from the Canadian
study, the
home birth outcomes should have been compared with hospital outcomes only of women satisfying the same exclusion criteria.
The authors concluded that the findings of this
study provided the first national evaluation of a significant proportion of women choosing publicly funded
home birth in Australia; however, the sample size did not have sufficient power to draw a conclusion
about safety.
Planning to have a baby at
home is
about as safe as having one in a hospital, but unplanned
home births pose a hazard, a
study by federal and state health researchers in Kentucky suggests.
In the
study group,
about 75 % of the women who planned to give
birth at
home were able to, and
about 97 % of those who planned to give
birth in hospital had their babies there.
Therefore, this
study makes a novel and valuable contribution to what was previously known
about the safety of
home birth.
The more
studies and stats I read
about home births, the more excited I am for my
home birth, and the more sure I am that I am making the right choice for me and my babe!
The results of this
study, and those of its companion article
about the development of the MANA Stats registry, confirm the safety and overwhelmingly positive health benefits for low - risk mothers and babies who choose to
birth at
home with a midwife.
In a
study published in
Birth, 201 new mothers were surveyed
about inducing labor at
home.
Ethics dictate that all healthcare providers should respect the autonomy of individuals to make their own informed decisions, and this
study provides further information
about the risks and benefits of planned
home birth so that families can make those decisions with the information available.
I am a former
home birth advocate and one of the reasons I am a * former *
home birth advocate is because of the misleading information and attempts to hide the truth from women
about the real numbers behind the
studies.
And we look forward to more research
studies using the MANA Stats Registry —
about many aspects of planned
home birth — from outcomes, to cost savings for insurers, to women's own experiences of childbirth.
«One could spend days sorting through the claims and counterclaims,» Goldberg writes
about the only recent
study of American
home births, which Tuteur has been beating up on for years and to which the authors, for better or worse, have been responding.
We could pick through those
studies» respective strengths and weaknesses, talk
about why we'll never have a «gold - standard» randomized controlled trial (because women will never participate in a
study that makes
birth choices for them), and I could quote a real epidemiologist on why determining the precise risk of
home birth in the United States is nearly impossible.
While Rosa did not talk specifically in the Save the Children video
about postpartum depression, research shows that stressful life events, including premature
birth, are risk factors for maternal depression.24 Evaluation
studies confirm that women who participated in
home visiting programs were less likely to demonstrate symptoms of depression and reported improved mental outlook when compared with control groups of women who did not participate in home visiting.25 For example, parents participating in the Child First model — one of the 20 evidence - based models eligible to receive funds from the Maternal, Infant, and Early Childhood Home Visiting program — experienced lower levels of stress and depression at the end of the program compared with parents who did not participat
home visiting programs were less likely to demonstrate symptoms of depression and reported improved mental outlook when compared with control groups of women who did not participate in
home visiting.25 For example, parents participating in the Child First model — one of the 20 evidence - based models eligible to receive funds from the Maternal, Infant, and Early Childhood Home Visiting program — experienced lower levels of stress and depression at the end of the program compared with parents who did not participat
home visiting.25 For example, parents participating in the Child First model — one of the 20 evidence - based models eligible to receive funds from the Maternal, Infant, and Early Childhood
Home Visiting program — experienced lower levels of stress and depression at the end of the program compared with parents who did not participat
Home Visiting program — experienced lower levels of stress and depression at the end of the program compared with parents who did not participate.26
Buying, selling, or making renovations to a
home is
about as emotionally stressful as illness, death, car repairs, marriage, or
birth, according to a Texas A&M University
study that ranks «high - emotion events» in a person's life.
We did a
home study first, not affiliated with an agency, and were getting ready to call agencies when a friend who works at a hospital called us in the middle of the night to say «there is a young mom who just gave
birth to a healthy baby girl and she is interested in an open adoption and I told her
about you guys.»