The U.S. Department of Education should require that
studies on charter schools meet rigorous research and reporting standards.
He has also taught at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, and has authored numerous reports and
studies on charter schooling and educational policy.
Here are some highlights from two separate
studies on charter schools that were released Tuesday: * Public charter schools generally receive less funding than traditional public schools, according to a new report released today, but most or all of these funding differences can be connected to the additional obligations that the traditional schools have.
The studies on charter schools certainly offer a mixed message.
Five years of
studies on charter schools prove they are meeting the needs of traditionally underserved children and forcing regular public schools to change for the better, the Center for Education Reform concludes in a report released last week.
And next month the agency wraps up a pilot
study on charter boats in Florida and North Carolina of electronic logbooks, which provide real - time reporting of catches.
Margaret Raymond, director of CREDO at Stanford University, sits down with Paul Peterson to discuss CREDO's latest
study on charter schools in New York City.
Harris» Times op - ed cited the 2013 CREDO
study on charter school performance nationwide.
And a new
study on charter schools around the country says New York offers a «balanced» picture when looking at enrollment and performance.
Yesterday, CREDO released a national
study on charter schools which suggests that about 3,000 of the nation's 4,700 charter schools are worse than the schools they are designed to replace.
In updating its 2009 national
study on charter schools, Stanford's Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) reaches the same conclusion it did in its previous study: The vast majority of charter schools in the United States are no better than public schools.
American Enterprise Institute New
study on charter school applications is useful, in measured doses
The new CREDO
study on charter school performance was released two weeks ago, and it continues to make a big splash.
Social media is abuzz with CREDO's latest
study on charter schools.
Not exact matches
A new
study says that
on average, New York City
charter school students show growth equal to 23 extra days of learning in reading and 63 more days in math each year, compared with similar students in traditional public schools.
It has also reviewed hundreds of thousands of reports to aid in distinguishing the best - quality research from weaker work, including
studies on such subjects as the effectiveness of
charter schools and merit pay for teachers, which have informed the ongoing debate about these issues.
Barbara
studied at Sanford Meisner's Neighborhood Playhouse, then went
on to become a
charter member of the Actor's Studio.
Numerous
studies, including six separate analyses by the U.S. Department of Education (each of which relied
on state - level data), have concluded that
charter schools are more segregated than traditional public schools.
On January 6, a team of researchers, led by Harvard Graduate School of Education Professor Thomas Kane and MIT Professor Joshua Angrist, released the results of a
study of Boston's
charter, pilot, and traditional public schools.
Rather, we found that the particular
charter schools in the Boston area (especially those that were part of the lottery
study) seem to be having large impacts
on student achievement.
The
study reported here thus differs from virtually all other published research
on charter schools in its reliance
on experimental methods to determine the schools» effectiveness.
Because most students enter
charter schools before the 3rd grade when state - mandated testing begins, only 36 percent of applicants in our
study have prior test scores
on record and this group is not representative of all applicants.
Brandon Wiley is the Director of Asia Society's International
Studies Schools Network, a design - driven network of 34 public and
charter schools, located in eight states, focused
on nurturing students to be globally competent and college and career ready.
In the months following the
study's release, Massachusetts Governor Deval Patrick and Boston Mayor Thomas Menino both revised their positions
on charter schools.
The schools that agreed to participate in the
study included 22 open - enrollment district schools, five oversubscribed
charter schools, two exam schools to which students are admitted based
on their grades and standardized test scores, and three
charter schools that were not oversubscribed at the time the 8th - grade students in our
study were admitted.
Eleven
studies have examined whether
charter schools will have positive or negative indirect effects
on students in district public schools.
These charges seemed odd, given that the best
studies available
on the subject — from Stanford University's Center for Research
on Education Outcomes (CREDO)-- show that Michigan
charter students make large academic gains relative to similar students at district schools, particularly in Detroit.
In Public Impact's latest Opportunity Culture case
study, Touchstone Education: New
Charter With Experienced Leader Learns From Extending Teachers» Reach, we look at how this teacher, Tiffany McAfee, led the school's teachers in their focus
on literacy, and how the school combined her leadership with online instruction.
When
studying the pattern of
charter school enrollment across the country, we took into account how each of three factors contributes to or retards
charter school growth: per pupil expenditures (also measured during the 1989 — 90 school year), length of time a
charter law was
on the books, and degree of permissiveness of each state's
charter school law, as measured by the CER index.
The
study, «Leveraging Local Innovation: The Case of Michigan's
Charter Schools,» found that the schools have mostly seized
on innovative practices already in use for years in regular public schools, rather than coming up with new ideas of their own.
Charters have flourished in particular in the Bay Area, the five - county region we focus
on in our
study: Alameda, Contra Costa, San Francisco, San Mateo, and Santa Clara.
The CREDO report
on New Jersey
charters said Newark has one of the highest - performing
charter sectors of any city that organization has
studied.
Mathematica's own defense of its research design was that it could do the
study more cheaply if it relied upon readily available data, even though Caroline Hoxby, facing similar data collection problems, nonetheless found a way of tracking students from first grade
on («How New York City's
Charter Schools Affect Achievement»).
He
studied eight of what he terms «no excuses»
charter schools in Boston that rely
on «passionate» recent graduates from some of the nation's most prestigious colleges and universities to produce...
In a new article for Education Next, Robin Lake, Trey Cobb, Roohi Sharma, and Alice Opalka of the Center
on Reinventing Public Education (CRPE)
study the factors holding back
charter growth in the Bay Area of San Francisco, where the recent slowdown in
charter expansion mirrors the national trend.
I'm aware of 4 rigorous
studies of the effect of
charter schools
on attainment.
In this part of our
study, we compared states based
on the rating of their laws by CER, which is an advocacy organization for
charter schools.
The
study intended to report
on, among other things, levels of racial segregation in
charter schools across the United States.
«As we approached the
study of education through the lenses of our research
on innovation,» they wrote, «our instinct was to frame
chartered schools as disruptive innovations, but upon reflection that was not correct.»
The editorial cites a new
study by the California
Charter Schools Association which
studied the state's Academic Performance Index (API), which runs
on a scale from 200 to 1000, and found that, according to the Journal,
In this
study we use data from Chicago and Florida to estimate the effects of attending a
charter high school
on the likelihood that a student will complete high school and attend college.
Placing public
charter schools
on a par with TPS in receiving local educational funds, as Colorado plans to do, would bring over half the cities in our
study to funding parity across the two public school sectors.
According to a recent
study by the Center
on Reinventing Public Education, by 2008 CMOs accounted for more than 10 percent of the
charter school market and had been the beneficiaries of at least $ 500 million in private philanthropy.
A Brookings Institution
study released in September 2002 concluded that student performance in
charter schools was significantly lower than that of district schools
on state tests in reading and math.
The founder of Match
Charter School, Michael Goldstein, wrote «
Studying Teacher Moves: A practitioner's take
on what is blocking the research teachers need,» for Education Next.
Although a number of recent
studies analyze the relationship between
charter school attendance and student achievement, this is the first analysis of the impacts of
charter school attendance
on educational attainment.
Our
study lacks data
on operations and instruction in the
charter schools, so we have little opportunity to explore the mechanisms contributing to their success.
A 2015
study by Stanford University's Center for Research
on Education Outcomes (CREDO) found Newark
charter schools outperformed traditional district schools: 77 percent of Newark's
charters were more effective at raising test scores in reading, and 69 percent were more effective at raising scores in math.
Another
study, by Michigan's Mackinac Center for Public Policy, found positive, but by their admission «not great,» results: Detroit
charter high schools performed somewhat better than predicted based
on their socioeconomic makeup, while Detroit Public Schools performed worse than predicted.
A Fordham Institute
study found that
on average
charters receive $ 1,800 less per student than traditional public schools, despite serving more disadvantaged students.