Complicating the entire landscape is the push by President Donald Trump and his Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos to increase options for parents, which includes both charter schools and taxpayer -
supported vouchers for private schools.
Not exact matches
On issues like tuition
vouchers for families to send their children to
private and parochial
schools, Orthodox Jews have effectively allied themselves with Catholic and Evangelical Christian conservatives and have gained the
support of senators like Joseph Lieberman (D - Conn.)
DeVos» strong
support for taxpayer - funded
vouchers for private and parochial
schools has intensified trepidation about her nomination in New York.
Mr. Cuomo has also voiced
support for a bill, backed by the Catholic Church and advocates of
vouchers, that would offer tax credits to individuals and corporations who donate money to public
schools, or to scholarship programs that help poor and middle - class students attend
private schools.
Now, according to a poll just released by Associated Press and the National Opinion Research Center,
vouchers that use taxpayer funds
for low - income students to attend
private schools gathered
support from 43 % of the public, with only 31 % opposed.
Americans»
support for using public funds to pay
for students to attend
private schools apparently was growing even before the U.S. Supreme Court's June decision upholding the Cleveland
voucher plan, findings from this year's Phi Delta Kappa / Gallup poll on public attitudes about education suggest.
DeVos is certainly known
for her
support of various forms of
school choice, including
vouchers, but there are both practical and political obstacles to promoting
private school choice from DC.
Indeed, whereas the differences in enrollment trends between
voucher and non-
voucher private schools provide some suggestive evidence
for the Overregulation Theory, Harris provides no evidence to
support the Nonaligned Test Theory.
August 1, 2017 — The 2017 Education Next annual survey of American public opinion on education shows public
support for charter
schools has dropped, even as opposition to
school vouchers and tax credits
for private -
school scholarships has declined.
The 2017 Education Next annual survey of American public opinion on education shows public
support for charter
schools has dropped, even as opposition to
school vouchers and tax credits
for private -
school scholarships has declined.
Vouchers have come to include the use of
private funding as partial tuition
support for low - income students to attend
private schools (as in Washington, D.C., San Antonio, and New York); the use of public funds to allow a small number of low - income students to attend
private schools (as in Milwaukee and Cleveland); or, as in the case of Florida, the provision of public funds
for students to attend a
private school or another public
school if their current public
school has a poor aca - demic record.
When presented with research evidence that claims «students learn no more in
private schools than in public
schools,»
support for school vouchers dropped by 10 percentage points, an impact almost as large as the President's.
The former principal said he
supports the state's requirement that as a condition
for receiving
vouchers,
private schools must administer the state's proficiency tests to their
voucher students and report the results.
Proponents of a measure that would provide poor families in Arizona with state - funded
vouchers for private school tuition hope to coax enough
support from lawmakers this week to encourage Gov. Fife Symington to call a special legislative session to act on the plan.
Yet the high level of satisfaction with
private schools provides encouragement
for those who
support school voucher initiatives, which increase access to the
private sector by paying some or all of students» tuition.
Opposition to universal
vouchers, giving all families public dollars
for a «wider choice» of attending
private schools dropped from 48 to 41 percent, while
support increased from 37 percent to 41 percent.
In a recent New York Times op - ed, I argued that the case
for Betsy DeVos's Secretary of Education appointment rests on a very weak track record — in particular, the evidence does not
support her free market approach to
school reform that relies, first and foremost, on
school vouchers for private schools, as well as unregulated forms of charter
schooling.
(«
Support for Private School Vouchers Is on the Increase, Gallup Poll...
I played a tiny role in helping launch the D.C.
voucher program when I served at the U.S. Department of Education, and I
support the expansion of
private school choice programs
for low - income students.
While the Administration appreciates that H.R. 471 would provide Federal
support for improving public
schools in the District of Columbia (D.C.), including expanding and improving high - quality D.C. public charter
schools, the Administration opposes the creation or expansion of
private school voucher programs that are authorized by this bill.
Even with the reopening of the County's public
schools following the Griffin ruling, segregation
supported by a
voucher system and inequitable funding persisted.24 The County's board of supervisors devoted only $ 189,000 in funding
for integrated public
schools.25 At the same time, they allocated $ 375,000 that could effectively only be used by white students
for «tuition grants to students attending either
private nonsectarian
schools in the County or public
schools charging tuition outside the County.»
Alabama also enacted tuition grant state laws permitting students to use
vouchers at
private schools in the mid-1950s, while also enacting nullification statutes against court desegregation mandates and altering its teacher tenure laws to allow the firing of teachers who
supported desegregation.50 Alabama's tuition grant laws would also come before the court, with the U.S. District Court
for the Middle District of Alabama declaring in Lee v. Macon County Board of Education
vouchers to be «nothing more than a sham established
for the purpose of financing with state funds a white
school system.»
Many families
support voucher programs, as it allows them to use tax dollars they pay
for education, but aren't able to use otherwise if they elect to attend a
school other than the local
private school.
The LSU survey found that 58 percent of public
school parents
support for providing
vouchers to help pay
for students in underperforming public
schools attend
private schools.
Cities led by Milwaukee and Cleveland started programs providing tax -
supported vouchers for low - income children to take to
private schools.
In the 1950s, 1960s, and early 1970s,
private school advocates tried to build
support for tuition
vouchers, payments of public tax funds
for private school tuition.
That could end up being a gift, he said, from Duncan to Betsy DeVos, President - elect Donald Trump's nominee
for education secretary and a prominent proponent of taxpayer -
supported vouchers for private and religious
schools.
March 26, 2015: NSBA Signs on to NCPE Coalition Letter Opposing
Vouchers NSBA, along with 52 other members of the National Coalition
for Public Education (NCPE), writes the Senate to express our strong opposition to any amendments to the Fiscal 2016 Senate Budget Resolution (S. Con Res.11) that would
support the creation of a
private school voucher or tuition tax credit program.
Republicans and conservatives now control every level of government, the state's spending on taxpayer - funded
school vouchers for private schools has increased and the state's teachers union no longer plays an influential role in funding and
supporting Democrats.
The Madison
school district receives about $ 2,000 per pupil in state equalization aid, but will have to expend $ 7,200 - 7,800
for each
voucher student; a portion of our property and state income taxes will
support private, religious
schools.
She added that
voucher programs
for private schools, which DeVos
supports, have often failed students with disabilities —
private schools either aren't willing to serve them, or require them to waive their rights under federal laws such as the ADA and the IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Education Act).
In 2010, Gov. Martinez was public in her
support for private school choice: both
vouchers for students with special needs and tax - credit scholarships.
Mr. Cuomo has also voiced
support for a bill, backed by the Catholic Church and advocates of
vouchers, that would offer tax credits to individuals and corporations who donate money to public
schools, or to scholarship programs that help poor and middle - class students attend
private schools.
AFC also believes that Congress and the Administration should pursue additional and bold policies to fulfill the President's promise to expand
school choice, including: a K - 12 tax credit to leverage
private money in
support of scholarships
for lower income families;
vouchers for children of active duty military members so they can attend
schools of their parents» choice; Education Savings Accounts
for children in Bureau of Indian Education
schools; and more funding
for the D.C. Opportunity Scholarship Program.
56 — percentage of registered voters in North Carolina who do not
support using
school vouchers to help parents pay
for their children to attend
private or religious
schools instead of public
schools.
At the same time we are defunding public education, how long will it take before taxpayers are paying a billion or more dollars a year
for a statewide
voucher system that
supports unaccountable
private and religious
schools?
39 — percent of registered voters in North Carolina who
support using
school vouchers to help parents pay
for their children to attend
private or religious
schools instead of public
schools.
If research
supported the assertion that funding
private school vouchers resulted in better outcomes
for children, such a risk to the public
school system might be justified.
Much of that money would go toward the
private sector, and DeVos has also been challenged repeatedly
for supporting vouchers that allow parents to use government dollars to pay
for private,
for - profit and religious
schools, a cornerstone of Trump's stated plan.
Many in conservative circles see her primary role as using the bully pulpit to advance
school choice policies, but government - backed
school vouchers for private schools, which is something she's vigorously
supported for decades, have really taken a beating recently.
Scenario # 1: DeVos moves quickly to implement President - Elect Trump's plan to use $ 20 billion of federal funds
for block grants to states to
support vouchers for poor children to attend
private schools.
So proponents claiming the mantle of «education reform» have been quick to jump on the one - sided election results as proof - positive of widespread voter
support for their ideas, which include competitive charter
schools,
vouchers to transfer public education money into
private hands, and harsh accountability measures to punish
schools and teachers
for the circumstances they have very little control over.
Gov. Scott Walker framed his
support for private school vouchers in moral terms Monday while speaking to
school choice advocates in New Orleans.
When Ravitch first voiced enthusiastic
support for private -
school vouchers, they were largely untried.
That poll explicitly used the phrase «
school vouchers,» finding that 53 percent of likely 2016 voters
supported «
school vouchers to allow individual parents to use public funds to pay
for tuition at
private or religious
schools.»
In 1990, the charter idea gained further prominence after the state legislature in neighboring Wisconsin passed the nation's first
private school voucher law, providing public
support for low - income Milwaukee students to attend
private and parochial
schools.
Equity concerns surface in other ways, with few publicly
supported,
private school choice programs employing the sliding scales
for family income and scholarship value that liberal
voucher supporters in the «60s and «70s thought crucial.
Even after
vouchers supporting «segregation academies» were deemed unconstitutional, research showed that increases in
private school enrollment were accompanied by decreased
support for investments in public education.
The state's teachers union, the Wisconsin Education Association Council, feels the same, and to its credit, «we
support the same interventions
for private schools taking taxpayer - funded
vouchers,» said WEAC spokeswoman Christina Brey.
Tax credits command
support from a larger coalition of conservatives, free market advocates, and
private schools than do
vouchers, in large part
for the same reason they are more legally viable: they are not government funds and pose less danger to the autonomy of
private schools that accept them.