Fraisse's response: «I have not seen a better or more objective
system than seniority.»
Not exact matches
For example, in a
seniority - based
system, black students are far more likely
than other students to have been in a classroom of a teacher who received a RIF notice.
Next we examine the implications of employing an effectiveness - based layoff policy rather
than the
seniority - driven
system currently in place.
With a
seniority - based layoff policy, school
systems may be forced to cut some of their most promising new talent rather
than dismiss more - senior teachers, who may not be terribly effective in raising student achievement.
If you are forced by an outdated
seniority system to pay some teachers more
than they are worth or could get in private industry, or accept less effort, resources are being expended based on what is good for the union and teachers and not what is best for kids.
Or teacher quality, of course that's taboo to talk about even though LA's results showed some teachers are far better
than others and some young teachers provide over double the value of teachers earning more
than them by our outdated and ineffective
seniority - based pay
system.
The perfect evaluation
system doesn't exist yet, but we do have access to measures of teacher performance that are far better
than seniority: teacher ratings, classroom management, teacher attendance, specific licensure, peer or principal review, value - added student data.
(1) The Vergara Decision: This case pits nine Oakland public school students against the State of California, arguing that (a) granting tenure after less
than two years, (b) retaining teachers during layoffs based on
seniority instead of merit, and (c) the near impossibility of dismissing incompetent teachers, is harming California's overall
system of public education, and is disproportionately harming public education in low income communities.
The unions also proposed that evaluations be clearly tied to a teacher obtaining due process rights, usually known as «teacher tenure» and that decisions about layoffs in times of fiscal crisis include performance evaluations rather
than a
system based solely on
seniority.
And Rhee exercised unique powers granted to a D.C. chancellor to impose a teacher evaluation
system based partly on student outcomes and to lay off teachers based on a lack of merit rather
than a lack of
seniority.
Three widespread practices in particular are in need of major revision: teacher evaluation and tenure
systems that do not distinguish effective teachers from ineffective ones; forced placement, where teachers are assigned to schools based on
seniority rather
than the match of teacher skills to school preferences and needs; and LIFO (last in first out), by which teacher lay - offs are based entirely on
seniority rather
than teacher effectiveness.
For example, the judge wrote that the state's teacher evaluation
system is «little more
than cotton candy in a rainstorm» since «[s] tate standards are leaving teachers with uselessly perfect evaluations and pay that follows only
seniority and degrees instead of reflecting need and good teaching.»
unsatisfactory business operations, including difficulty for teachers and administrators getting the basic necessities to operate schools and classrooms, and traditions of promotion based more on
seniority and politics
than on evidence of skill and commitment to
system efforts to improving education quality
Because once such a
system is in place, some teachers will be found to be better
than others, which could lead to ditching an arbitrary
seniority system should layoffs be a necessity.
to take any action otherwise prohibited under subsections (a), (b), (c), or (e) of this section where age is a bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of the particular business, or where differentiation is based on reasonable factors other
than age; to observe the terms of a bona fide
seniority system or any bona fide employee benefit plan such as a retirement, pension, or insurance plan, which is not a subterfuge to evade the purposes of this Act, except that no such employee benefit plan shall excuse the failure to hire any individual; or to discharge or otherwise discipline an individual for good cause
The two firms currently operate pure locksteps, the traditional compensation
system employed by U.K. law firms under which an equity partner's profit share automatically rises each year based on
seniority, rather
than on merit.
Exceptions apply for
seniority or merit
systems,
systems measuring earnings by quantity or quality of production, or factors other
than sex or employment status.