The case arose from a challenge, funded by anti-union organizations, to five California statutes that provide K - 12 teachers a two - year probationary period, stipulate procedural protections for non-probationary teachers facing termination, and emphasize
teacher seniority in reductions of force.
Not exact matches
By an overwhelming majority, (85 - 12), voters support the repeal of the «last
in, first out» rule governing
teacher layoffs, agreeing that the decision governing who loses a teaching job should be based on performance and not
seniority.
Mulgrew called the attacks on pensions, the threat of
teacher layoffs, the fight to change seniority layoff rules, the targeting of teachers in the Absent Teacher Reserve pool, and the record number of proposed school closings «part of the mayor's strategy to throw everything at us at once.
teacher layoffs, the fight to change
seniority layoff rules, the targeting of
teachers in the Absent
Teacher Reserve pool, and the record number of proposed school closings «part of the mayor's strategy to throw everything at us at once.
Teacher Reserve pool, and the record number of proposed school closings «part of the mayor's strategy to throw everything at us at once.»
Gov. Andrew Cuomo weighed
in this morning on the LIFO question
in the wake of this morning's Q poll that found 85 percent of New Yorkers support the idea that merit, not
seniority, should determine which public school
teachers get to keep their jobs.
Schools Chancellor Joel Klein said
in a memo to principals that because of
seniority rules, the city would be forced to lay off most of the elementary school
teachers hired since 2007.
School Chancellor Joel I. Klein is
in a high - stakes battle with the
teachers» union over
seniority rules.
At a news conference, the mayor said that Gov. Cuomo's bill does not rid the state of its
seniority - based layoff system
in time for his plan to lay off 4,600
teachers this year.
In other areas, such as a proposal to change seniority rules for school teachers or allocate $ 500 million next year in competitive school aid grants, a column titled «Compromise (if any)» is left blank, suggesting more distance between the three leaders at the time the memo was prepare
In other areas, such as a proposal to change
seniority rules for school
teachers or allocate $ 500 million next year
in competitive school aid grants, a column titled «Compromise (if any)» is left blank, suggesting more distance between the three leaders at the time the memo was prepare
in competitive school aid grants, a column titled «Compromise (if any)» is left blank, suggesting more distance between the three leaders at the time the memo was prepared.
The legislature must let school boards use
teacher performance, not
seniority,
in making layoff decisions.
The Big Dog, however, was willing to end welfare as we know it, infuriating the left; Cuomo has passed up the chance to challenge Democratic orthodoxy and tell the
teachers unions that
seniority protections need to end because the archaic rules are damaging the unions» credibility even more than they're hampering what goes on
in the classroom.
The mayor's assault on schools and
teachers reached a new low on March 1 when he convinced the New York State Senate to pass a bill that ended
seniority rules that guarantee impartiality
in layoffs.
The Department of Education on March 16 directed its employees to get students and parents involved
in the all - out war that Mayor Michael Bloomberg and the chancellor have been mounting
in Albany against
teachers»
seniority rights.
Earlier this week, Bloomberg warned that unless
teacher seniority rules are changed so good, newer
teachers could be retained over more senior but weaker instructors, the city could have to lay off nearly every
teacher hired
in the last five years.
The new timeline is a win for Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who has spent recent months vigorously lobbying to replace the state's «Last
in, first out»
seniority - based
teacher firing policy with one based on merit ahead of a massive layoff plan.
Despite the fact that the landmark
teacher seniority legislation passed the state Senate, it was stalled
in the Assembly.
Ending
seniority was easier
in Arizona, where Republicans control the Legislature, than it will probably be
in New York, where Democrats are
in power and the
teachers» union still has influence.
UFT President Michael Mulgrew issued a statement
in response to news that California millionaire David Welch's advocacy group, Student Matters, will fund and coordinate the lawsuit by the New York City Parents Union that seeks to invalidate due process and
seniority rights for
teachers.
But United Federation of
Teachers President Michael Mulgrew said that the
seniority rules are
in place for a reason.
To support the California
Teachers Union
in its fight to preserve due process and
seniority rights
in a lawsuit brought against it by an organization funded by a billionaire conservative activist;
The plaintiffs detailed the many ways
in which
seniority protection placed
teacher interests ahead of those of minority students.
In a new study, researchers find that seniority - based layoff policies — the norm in public schools — lead to higher numbers of teacher layoffs than would be necessary if administrators were allowed to make effectiveness the determining factor in issuing layoff notices, rather than length of servic
In a new study, researchers find that
seniority - based layoff policies — the norm
in public schools — lead to higher numbers of teacher layoffs than would be necessary if administrators were allowed to make effectiveness the determining factor in issuing layoff notices, rather than length of servic
in public schools — lead to higher numbers of
teacher layoffs than would be necessary if administrators were allowed to make effectiveness the determining factor
in issuing layoff notices, rather than length of servic
in issuing layoff notices, rather than length of service.
Confirming the disproportionate impact of current RIF systems on new
teachers, the study finds that approximately 60 percent of
teachers receiving layoff notices
in 2008 - 10 had two or fewer years of experience, and approximately 80 percent had two or fewer years of
seniority within their current district.
In other words, at least 16 percent of the total Stuyvesant staff was composed of
teachers who received their jobs because of
seniority (or race and ethnicity) rather than professional accomplishments.
For example,
in a
seniority - based system, black students are far more likely than other students to have been
in a classroom of a
teacher who received a RIF notice.
Perullo supported the goal of bringing
in more minority
teachers, but she bridled at the fact that the process was corrupted by the
seniority rule.
However, this difference «pales
in comparison to the difference
in probability that a first - year
teacher will be dismissed compared to a
teacher with 12 or more years of
seniority,» which is less than one - quarter of 1 percent.
In the Buffalo case, Arthur v. Nyquist, the appeals court held that
seniority - based layoffs, as called for under a
teachers» contract,...
Like every other public school
in the city, Stuyvesant is plagued by bureaucratic regulations and corrosive work rules that favor
seniority and paper credentials over a
teacher's knowledge and skill
in the classroom.
It is interesting to note, however, that some
teachers who receive layoff notices are well into their careers, implying that at least some districts
in the state are making judgments about which
teachers should be laid off based on criteria other than
seniority.
The authors next look at what would happen if the existing
seniority - driven system of layoffs were replaced by an effectiveness - based layoff policy,
in which
teachers are ranked according to their value - added scores and districts lay off their least effective
teachers.
A final way
in which
seniority - based systems may have consequences for student achievement is that strict adherence to
seniority would require at least some districts to lay off
teachers in subject areas with
teacher shortages, such as math and special education.
The database does not include a direct measure of a
teacher's
seniority in the current district, so we estimate
seniority based on how many years the
teacher has been employed by the same district.
This difference is statistically significant, but it pales
in comparison to the difference
in probability for a first - year
teacher compared to a
teacher with 12 or more years of
seniority: The estimated probability of a
teacher with 12 or more years of
seniority receiving a layoff notice is less than one - quarter of 1 percent for every endorsement area (see Figure 1).
Our analysis of these data provides strong evidence that
seniority plays an outsized role
in determining which
teachers are targeted for layoffs, likely
in part because collective bargaining agreements ordinarily require that the
teachers last hired are the first to be fired.
In other words, the fact that
teachers who received layoff notices were, on average, somewhat less effective than their peers is an artifact of the relationship between effectiveness and
seniority.
With a
seniority - based layoff policy, school systems may be forced to cut some of their most promising new talent rather than dismiss more - senior
teachers, who may not be terribly effective
in raising student achievement.
Our analysis of multiple factors indicates that, as expected,
seniority plays an important role
in determining whether
teachers receive a layoff notice.
Districts have negotiated contracts with
teacher unions that eliminate schools» discretion
in favor of
seniority preferences.
Teachers who join E4E are expected to support value - added test - score data
in evaluations, higher hurdles to achieving tenure, the elimination of
seniority - driven layoffs, school choice, and merit pay.
In New York City, Chancellor Joel Klein appealed to younger
teachers by giving principals the freedom to fill
teacher vacancies without respect to
seniority.
Before that, a group of 11
teachers affiliated with E4E developed a proposal for an alternative to
seniority in determining who would be let go
in the event of layoffs.
Besides challenging
seniority - based layoffs, the shortage of experienced math and science
teachers in inner - city districts — a problem that single salary schedules make worse — could inspire a lawsuit.
As Stephen Sawchuk notes, there has been a great deal of debate over whether
teacher layoffs should be based on inverse
seniority («last
in, first out,» which many union contracts and state laws require) or based on
teacher effectiveness.
School boards and superintendents are faced with a situation where they lose enrollment so quickly that the only thing they can do is close schools, lay off
teachers according to
seniority not quality (thanks to «last
in, first out» requirements), increase class sizes, and slash their central office staffing and support levels.
As noted earlier, one of the prevailing critiques of
seniority - based layoffs is that it is necessary to lay off more
teachers in order to attain a specified budget objective than it would be if districts used alternative criteria.
We calculate that districts would only have to lay off 132
teachers under an effectiveness - based system
in order to achieve the same budgetary savings they would achieve with 145 layoff notices under today's
seniority - driven system, a difference of about 10 percent.
But opportunities to advance were mostly based on
teacher seniority, the pay was low, and he was eager for a fresh challenge
in a new environment.
In the current system,
teachers unions tend to compress wages within a school district so that
teachers with the same
seniority and the same degree are likely to receive similar (if not identical) salaries.
• The state could prohibit collective bargaining agreements which elevate
seniority over competency
in layoffs and which facilitate the «Dance of the Lemons» (such as when senior
teachers are granted «bumping rights» over less senior
teachers working at other schools).
He also pressed for reform of the onerous work rules
in the
teachers» contract, including eliminating the
seniority provisions, making it easier to fire incompetents, and establishing a system of merit pay.