If courts can strike down
teacher tenure laws as a violation of the rights of poor and minority children (see «Script Doctors,» legal beat, Fall 2014), why not use the results from CCSS assessments to go after the drawing of school boundaries in a way that perpetuates economic school segregation and denies children equal opportunity?
Not exact matches
As CalWatchdog.com's Chris Reed argued, «That is good news for those considering taking on public employee unions in 2016 with ballot measures putting limits on government pensions or scrapping state
laws allowing
teachers to receive lifetime
tenure after less than two years on the job.»
Education reform groups like StudentsFirstNY and the New
Teacher Project say a lawsuit against New York State inspired by the Vergara case could change local
tenure laws and present a long - awaited opportunity to legally assess long - term sticking points with the unions, such
as merit pay and seniority rules.
Cohen and Walsh point out that it is state
law which drives
tenure policy and which frequently mandates much of the anachronistic step - and - lane pay schedule
as well
as the restrictions on
teacher evaluation.
Statewide
tenure laws remain largely intact,
as do
laws that require a specific set of education - school courses before a
teacher can be certified, despite the paucity of evidence that such courses (or certification) yield benefits in the classroom.
In the K — 12 world, however,
tenure remains the norm for public school
teachers in the district sector, vouchsafed in most places by state
law and big - time politics,
as well
as local contracts, even in so - called «right to work» states.
The lawsuit is the first of what many analysts expect will be numerous legal challenges around the country following a landmark decision in June by a California Superior Court judge who struck down the
tenure system there
as unconstitutional under state
law, saying it unfairly saddled students in high - needs schools with low - performing
teachers.
Louisiana state
law illustrates the relative ease in earning
tenure: «Such probationary
teacher shall automatically become a regular and permanent
teacher in the employ of the school board of the parish or city,
as the case may be, in which he has successfully served his three - year probationary term.»
States should improve their
teacher licensing processes to ensure that the effectiveness of all
teachers is assessed on a regular basis
as a condition for the granting and renewal of a state teaching license — regardless of the particular criteria for evaluation and
tenure laid out in state
tenure laws and collective bargaining contracts
Fordham's Mike Petrilli and AEI's Mike McShane discuss the spread of legal challenges to state
laws governing
teacher tenure, dismissal, and seniority in the wake of the Vergara v. California ruling, in which a court struck down California's
laws governing
teacher employment
as unconstitutional.
Maine's school boards are being urged to eliminate seniority clauses from
teachers» contracts
as the result of a state high - court decision, handed down this summer, that state
law does not protect
tenured teachers at the expense of nontenured
teachers in layoff decisions.
Perhaps the higher levels of support we observed in 2014 reflected temporary shocks to public opinion stemming from events such
as Wisconsin governor Scott Walker's recall election and the landmark Vergara v. California decision that struck down California's
teacher evaluation and
tenure laws, both of which took place while our survey was in the field.
As mayor, he attempted to take control of LA Unified and supported Vergara v. California, which challenged
teacher tenure laws.
The appeal decision will be closely watched throughout the state and beyond,
as the future of California's
teacher employment
laws surrounding
tenure, seniority and dismissal hang in the balance.
One of the hottest tickets was a session led by Charlotte Danielson, the architect of a
teacher - evaluation model being used in a majority of New Jersey school districts
as part of the state's new
tenure - reform
law, which aims to hold
teachers more accountable for student performance.
As part of Michigan's
teacher tenure reform
law, the Michigan Council of Educator Effectiveness was established by the Legislature in June 2011 with the charge of creating a «fair, transparent and feasible evaluation system for
teachers and administrators.»
SGOs are one of three measures used to judge
teacher effectiveness
as part of the
teacher tenure reform
law that went into effect last year.
The Wright v. New York case was first filed in 2014, when nine families from across the state brought suit against the State of New York and others, claiming that
teacher tenure, dismissal, and quality - blind layoff
laws deprive New York children of their right to a sound basic education
as guaranteed under the New York State Constitution.
The state Department of Education last week released a mostly positive report on the initial year of the system
as dictated under the TEACHNJ
tenure reform
law, citing some challenges but praising the progress in meeting requirements for additional observations and goal setting for
teachers.
The tests would still be rolled out
as planned if the legislation passed but the results would not count toward
teacher evaluations, the centerpiece of the
teacher tenure reform
law signed by Christie in 2012.
And Anderson said while she recognized that the new
teacher tenure law known
as TEACHNJ provided some avenues for removing the least - effective
teachers, the district needed to move more quickly than through a process that can include extensive documentation and arbitration.
Under previous and current state
law, districts laying off
tenured teachers must do so in order of seniority, a practice known
as «last in, first out,» or LIFO.
This was one of the key lessons learned early on by EPAC and led to the recommendation to delay full implementation of the evaluation system by a year: 2012 - 2013 was scheduled in the
tenure reform
law as a capacity - building year for districts to choose, train in, and practice using a
teacher practice instrument.
This alignment of goals contributed to the rash of statehouses that reformed
teacher tenure and evaluation
laws from 2010 to 2014, with prominent Democrats such
as New Jersey Sen. Corey Booker, Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet and New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo championing the cause.
But the stakes in this second year under the new system will only be higher,
as the
law gives school districts the power to bring
tenure charges against
teachers who don't fare well in a second consecutive year, putting new pressures on
teachers and placing new responsibility on schools.
He said he is open to revising the
law that grants
teachers tenure after two years and including student test scores
as «a tool in the toolbox of
teacher evaluation.»
Defendants in the case, the state and
teacher unions, are trying to prove that these other factors make it difficult for the nine - student plaintiffs to show that state
laws governing
teacher dismissal, seniority and
tenure should be struck down
as impediments to a quality education.
Represented by Los Angeles
law firm Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, the plaintiffs allege
teacher protections such
as tenure, seniority rules in layoffs and other
teacher dismissal statutes disparately keep ineffective
teachers in the classroom in violation of the state constitution's equal protection clause.
The union campaign depicts Brown, who leads a group that has filed a New York State lawsuit modeled on the Vergara v. California case that found
teacher tenure laws unconstitutional,
as the puppet of former D.C. schools chancellor Michelle Rhee and Brown's husband, GOP policy adviser Dan Senor.
The California Supreme Court will decide this summer whether to take up an appeal by nine students in the historic Vergara vs. California case challenging our unusually protective
teacher tenure laws,
as well
as a seniority - based layoff system that often keeps ineffective
teachers in district classrooms while letting more talented but less senior
teachers go.
The California
laws at issue mandated that
teachers receive specific job security protections, known
as tenure, after two years in the classroom.
The Vergara decision, striking down
tenure and dismissal
laws in California
as depriving the state's most vulnerable students equal access to a quality education, was widely seen
as a blow to the
teachers union and has moved public opinion toward agreeing with change.
The California Supreme Court's decision on whether to take up Vergara v. California, a landmark ruling that challenged
teacher tenure and declared some school employment
laws unconstitutional, could come
as early
as this afternoon.
The stage was set with the two public education luminaries, ready to square off on such lightning rod issues
as tenure and
teacher dismissal
laws in the wake of last month's Vergara trial: Randi Weingarten, leader of the nation's second largest
teachers organization, AFT, and Superintendent John Deasy, leader of the second largest school district in the...
The regulations adopted by the New York State Board of Regents based on the 2010
law changing how the evaluations must work includings a line that says the new evaluations must be «a significant factor in employment decisions such
as promotion, retention,
tenure determinations, termination, and supplemental compensation,»
as well
as how
teacher and principal development is approached.
Superior Court Judge Robert Hobgood ordered a permanent injunction against the implementation of the
law that ends career status, known
as teacher tenure.
I've asked Korn to tell me exactly where the
law specifies this, and when I hear back from him, I will update this post.UPDATE: The
teachers» union, to back up its assertion, is citing a memo from the state department to the Board of Regents last year which contains this background sentence about the evaluation
law: «
Tenured teachers and principals with a pattern of ineffective teaching performance — defined by
law as two consecutive annual «ineffective» ratings — may be charged with incompetence and considered for termination through an expedited hearing process.»
Judge Robert Hobgood ordered a permanent injunction against the
law, which would eliminate career status — commonly known
as teacher tenure — by 2018.
The plaintiffs said the school system did not follow
teacher tenure law in the layoffs, and that they should have been systematically rehired
as schools reopened, either in the Orleans system, in the state Recovery School District or
as charters.
Under the new Louisiana
law,
teachers must be rated
as «highly effective» in the state's evaluation system for five consecutive years before they can be granted
tenure.
They come on the heels of the state's new
teacher tenure law, which reinforced the requirements for mentors of first - year
teachers,
as well
as those new to a school.
In addition to training
teachers, administrators, and other school leaders on issues such
as tenure, special education, employment discrimination, employee whistleblowing claims, student harassment and anti-bullying
law, ethics, governance, and student rights, Teresa has argued before the New Jersey Supreme Court, has substantial experience in federal and state courts, and has tried numerous disputes to conclusion in the New Jersey Office of Administrative L
law, ethics, governance, and student rights, Teresa has argued before the New Jersey Supreme Court, has substantial experience in federal and state courts, and has tried numerous disputes to conclusion in the New Jersey Office of Administrative
LawLaw.
Of that, $ 1.25 million will be made available to districts in grants to help pay for training of administrators and
teachers in the state's new
teacher - evaluation system under the
tenure reform
law known
as TEACHNJ.
Acting Education Commissioner Christopher Cerf said he is glad the bill, if enacted into
law, would end
tenure as lifetime job security, and require that
teacher ratings play a significant role in determining who would be let go during layoffs.
Other national groups also propose parent trigger
laws as part of agendas that favor charter schools, eliminating
teacher tenure, and restricting
teachers» unions.
As the Christie administration's new regulations for
teacher evaluation near a critical juncture, the prime author of the landmark
tenure reform
law behind the proposed rules said the administration may be moving too aggressively in some places.
TRENTON — After 18 months of negotiation, a proposed
law that would end
teacher tenure as a largely automatic and careerlong right cleared an important hurdle with the blessing of the state's
teachers unions and bipartisan political support.
Mackinac's director of labor policy is Vincent Vernuccio, who chairs a committee of the labor task force of the Bradley - supported American Legislative Exchange Council and previously has worked at the Bradley - supported Capital Research Center and Bradley - supported Competitive Enterprise Institute... MCLF spent much of last year helping to defend the new right - to - work
law, in policy and legal arguments,
as well
as in the larger public discourse in the state and nationally... MCLF is working with the Bradley - supported National Right to Work Legal Defense Foundation on this and several other legal matters surrounding implementation of right to work in Michigan... On education, among other things, Mackinac is analyzing mroe [sic] than 200 collective - bargaining agreements (CBAs) in the state, covering some 75 % of the state's public - school students, to see if and if so, how, they are adhering to the
teacher -
tenure and - evaluation policy changes.