NEW YORK (CBSNewYork)-- A stunning decision to overturn
teacher tenure laws in California has New York City parents mobilizing to seek the same thing here.
After three and half years, much of it mired in controversy over technology missteps like the rollout of a $ 1.3 billion iPad program and a court case that struck down
teacher tenure laws in California, the schools chief and the board have agreed to part ways.
Opponents of the nation's teacher unions won a landmark victory last year in a California lawsuit that challenged tenure protections, a case that became the beginning of a national effort to roll back
teacher tenure laws in state courts.
In California, the state Supreme Court has decided not to hear an appeal in Vergara vs. California, which means that
teacher tenure laws in the state will stand.
The plaintiffs said the school system did not follow
teacher tenure law in the layoffs, and that they should have been systematically rehired as schools reopened, either in the Orleans system, in the state Recovery School District or as charters.
Not exact matches
NYSUT was opposed to the tax credit, but the labor union had its hands full on other key issues, including Gov. Andrew Cuomo's effort to once again overhaul
teacher evaluations, weaken
teacher tenure laws and strengthen charter schools
in addition to the perennial push for more school aid.
The city's
teachers union this week failed yet again
in its effort to stop a lawsuit that aims to prove that the state's
tenure laws and «last
in, first out»...
The suits were prompted by a California judge's ruling
in June striking down that state's
teacher tenure laws.
He said Tuesday that he needed to do further research on a court ruling
in California that struck down
teacher tenure laws there, but he was cautiously supportive.
The statewide
teachers union, NYSUT, whose political influence is strongest
in the Democratic - led Assembly, has railed against the new evaluation
law and how it is tied to
teacher tenure.
As CalWatchdog.com's Chris Reed argued, «That is good news for those considering taking on public employee unions
in 2016 with ballot measures putting limits on government pensions or scrapping state
laws allowing
teachers to receive lifetime
tenure after less than two years on the job.»
''...
Teacher tenure laws need to be strengthened because the country is bleeding
teachers — especially
in large urban districts.
In 2014, a trial court agreed that the
law violated the property and contractual rights of already
tenured teachers but not the rights of those yet to receive
tenure.
State
laws governing
teacher tenure in most states make implementation of such plans unlikely.
In a stunning decision, a judge in the California Superior Court has ruled that, because education is a fundamental right of California youth, the laws governing teacher tenure, teacher dismissal and rules for layoffs are unconstitutiona
In a stunning decision, a judge
in the California Superior Court has ruled that, because education is a fundamental right of California youth, the laws governing teacher tenure, teacher dismissal and rules for layoffs are unconstitutiona
in the California Superior Court has ruled that, because education is a fundamental right of California youth, the
laws governing
teacher tenure,
teacher dismissal and rules for layoffs are unconstitutional.
In April, the California Court of Appeal overturned the trial court's ruling in Vergara v. California [i], in which a group of families had challenged the constitutionality of state laws governing teacher tenure [ii](California state law automatically grants tenure to teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency in layoff decisions
In April, the California Court of Appeal overturned the trial court's ruling
in Vergara v. California [i], in which a group of families had challenged the constitutionality of state laws governing teacher tenure [ii](California state law automatically grants tenure to teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency in layoff decisions
in Vergara v. California [i],
in which a group of families had challenged the constitutionality of state laws governing teacher tenure [ii](California state law automatically grants tenure to teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency in layoff decisions
in which a group of families had challenged the constitutionality of state
laws governing
teacher tenure [ii](California state
law automatically grants
tenure to
teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to
teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency
in layoff decisions
in layoff decisions.)
Iron - clad seniority and
tenure rights codified
in state
laws and collective bargaining agreements make it nearly impossible for boards to remove ineffective
teachers.
Statewide
tenure laws remain largely intact, as do
laws that require a specific set of education - school courses before a
teacher can be certified, despite the paucity of evidence that such courses (or certification) yield benefits
in the classroom.
In the K — 12 world, however, tenure remains the norm for public school teachers in the district sector, vouchsafed in most places by state law and big - time politics, as well as local contracts, even in so - called «right to work» state
In the K — 12 world, however,
tenure remains the norm for public school
teachers in the district sector, vouchsafed in most places by state law and big - time politics, as well as local contracts, even in so - called «right to work» state
in the district sector, vouchsafed
in most places by state law and big - time politics, as well as local contracts, even in so - called «right to work» state
in most places by state
law and big - time politics, as well as local contracts, even
in so - called «right to work» state
in so - called «right to work» states.
Under the new
law in New York, the length of the probationary period will be lengthened from three to four years and no
teacher rated «ineffective»
in their fourth year would be able to earn
tenure.
If courts can strike down
teacher tenure laws as a violation of the rights of poor and minority children (see «Script Doctors,» legal beat, Fall 2014), why not use the results from CCSS assessments to go after the drawing of school boundaries
in a way that perpetuates economic school segregation and denies children equal opportunity?
The lawsuit is the first of what many analysts expect will be numerous legal challenges around the country following a landmark decision
in June by a California Superior Court judge who struck down the
tenure system there as unconstitutional under state
law, saying it unfairly saddled students
in high - needs schools with low - performing
teachers.
Louisiana state
law illustrates the relative ease
in earning
tenure: «Such probationary
teacher shall automatically become a regular and permanent
teacher in the employ of the school board of the parish or city, as the case may be,
in which he has successfully served his three - year probationary term.»
In short, when it comes to the teacher - tenure laws in most states, less than half of teachers and fewer than 1 in 10 Americans prefer the status qu
In short, when it comes to the
teacher -
tenure laws in most states, less than half of teachers and fewer than 1 in 10 Americans prefer the status qu
in most states, less than half of
teachers and fewer than 1
in 10 Americans prefer the status qu
in 10 Americans prefer the status quo.
(California state
law automatically grants
tenure to
teachers after sixteen months, provides extra due process protections to
teachers over and above those available to other state workers, and requires schools to use seniority rather than competency
in layoff decisions.)
Teacher - tenure laws leaped on to the front page of the national media in 2014 when a California judge responded favorably to a plaintiff's argument that the state's teacher - tenure laws violate its state consti
Teacher -
tenure laws leaped on to the front page of the national media
in 2014 when a California judge responded favorably to a plaintiff's argument that the state's
teacher - tenure laws violate its state consti
teacher -
tenure laws violate its state constitution.
Dean James Ryan comparing the ruling
in Vergara v. California, which stated that the state's strong
teacher tenure laws were unconstitutional, to school finance reform, which said you had to have equal resources
in order to have equal educational opportunity.
On Wednesday, the Star Tribune's Beena Raghavendran reported that the Minnesota Court of Appeals heard oral arguments for a lawsuit
in which a group of parents are challenging the constitutionality of Minnesota's
teacher tenure, dismissal, and «last
in, first out»
laws.
In the wake of a crushing defeat for a landmark challenge to California's
teacher tenure laws, the battle for change has shifted from the courts to the state Legislature.
In his 2014 ruling, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu said the
tenure and seniority
laws make it prohibitively time - consuming and expensive to remove incompetent
teachers.
«This was a very cynical statement that she doesn't believe
teachers and schools can make a difference
in high - poverty areas,» says Colorado State Senator Mike Johnston, a former
teacher and principal whose sweeping
tenure - reform
law is a national model.
According to the Court, the
laws in question —
laws that govern
teacher tenure, dismissal, and layoffs — impose substantial harm on California's students by forcing administrators to push passionate, inspiring
teachers out of the school system and keep grossly ineffective
teachers in front of students year after year.
ALBANY, N.Y. March 31, 2015 — New York State United
Teachers today said changes to the
teacher evaluation and
tenure laws contained
in the state budget are a disgrace.
States should improve their
teacher licensing processes to ensure that the effectiveness of all
teachers is assessed on a regular basis as a condition for the granting and renewal of a state teaching license — regardless of the particular criteria for evaluation and
tenure laid out
in state
tenure laws and collective bargaining contracts
Fordham's Mike Petrilli and AEI's Mike McShane discuss the spread of legal challenges to state
laws governing
teacher tenure, dismissal, and seniority
in the wake of the Vergara v. California ruling,
in which a court struck down California's
laws governing
teacher employment as unconstitutional.
Maine's school boards are being urged to eliminate seniority clauses from
teachers» contracts as the result of a state high - court decision, handed down this summer, that state
law does not protect
tenured teachers at the expense of nontenured
teachers in layoff decisions.
Perhaps the higher levels of support we observed
in 2014 reflected temporary shocks to public opinion stemming from events such as Wisconsin governor Scott Walker's recall election and the landmark Vergara v. California decision that struck down California's
teacher evaluation and
tenure laws, both of which took place while our survey was
in the field.
In California, the state Supreme Court has decided not to hear an appeal in Vergara vs. California, so teacher tenure laws will stan
In California, the state Supreme Court has decided not to hear an appeal
in Vergara vs. California, so teacher tenure laws will stan
in Vergara vs. California, so
teacher tenure laws will stand.
Last week, an appeals court
in California reversed a lower court ruling
in Vergara v. California that had struck down several state
laws involving
teacher tenure.
Two years ago, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Rolf Treu ruled that
tenure laws were unconstitutional because they made it virtually impossible to fire incompetent
teachers, and that especially hurt students
in poor neighborhoods.
The
teacher evaluation issue got off to a less than auspicious start when the educator effectiveness report envisioned
in the 2011
teacher tenure reform was first slated to be finished April 30, 2012, nine months after Snyder signed the bill into
law.
Delaware's
teacher - effectiveness plan includes a new
law that allows
teachers with
tenure to be removed from their jobs if they are given «ineffective» ratings for two to three consecutive years, and
teachers can only be given an «effective» rating after demonstrating adequate growth
in their students» academic achievement.
Alabama also enacted tuition grant state
laws permitting students to use vouchers at private schools
in the mid-1950s, while also enacting nullification statutes against court desegregation mandates and altering its
teacher tenure laws to allow the firing of
teachers who supported desegregation.50 Alabama's tuition grant
laws would also come before the court, with the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Alabama declaring
in Lee v. Macon County Board of Education vouchers to be «nothing more than a sham established for the purpose of financing with state funds a white school system.»
Teachers and administrators alike had been anxiously waiting for more details about the evaluations since Gov. Chris Christie signed a new
tenure law that permits them to be evaluated, at least
in part based on their students» test scores and other measurements of achievement.
Speaking to a downtown meeting of California newspaper publishers, the mayor said he would lobby for changes
in state
law that would alter the rules for evaluating
teachers and for granting
tenure to
teachers.
The standards were supposed to be
in effect this school year under a 2011 Republican - backed
law that revised
teacher tenure rules.
The appeal decision will be closely watched throughout the state and beyond, as the future of California's
teacher employment
laws surrounding
tenure, seniority and dismissal hang
in the balance.
The plaintiffs — nine students
in five California public school districts — argue that five
laws governing
teacher dismissal,
tenure, and «last
in - first out» layoff...
In the 2015 - 16 school year, 50 percent of a
teacher's evaluation will be based on much students improve on a statewide M - STEP test that will have only been given twice, one short of the three years originally envisioned under the
teacher tenure law.
One of the hottest tickets was a session led by Charlotte Danielson, the architect of a
teacher - evaluation model being used
in a majority of New Jersey school districts as part of the state's new
tenure - reform
law, which aims to hold
teachers more accountable for student performance.