Not exact matches
He spearheaded the creation
of new
teacher evaluations allowing half
of a
teacher's rating to be
based on students» standardized
test scores.
I suspect our
teacher unions would not be adverse to let some portion
of their member
teachers compensation be
based on a
test score bonus rather than the meddling
of school boards.
Cuomo and lawmakers approve stricter rules raising the portion
of teachers» evaluations
based on student
test scores to approximately 50 percent.
Over the past five years, Duncan has used a combination
of financial incentives and regulatory waivers to push the use
of teacher performance ratings
based partly
on student
test scores.
Dr. Rosa's election is an indication
of how much both politicians and the public have turned against the policies promoted by Dr. Tisch, including the evaluation
of teachers on the
basis of state
test scores.
The statewide
teachers union filed a federal lawsuit late Wednesday over the state Department
of Education's policy
of requiring
teachers to sign confidentiality agreements before
scoring tests based on the Common Core standards.
At least going by his rhetoric, he seems to have almost declared war
on the
teacher unions and he has proposed a new system
of evaluation, which is more heavily
based on students»
tests scores than the one currently in use.
Most academic studies find that
teachers account for between 1 percent and 14 percent
of variability in student
test scores, while Cuomo wants to
base 50 percent
of teacher evaluations
on test scores.
His proposals to determine the fate
of teachers» pay and jobs and schools» funding and survival
based on students» standardized
test scores look like more pay - to - play politics in Albany.
Going forward, move toward
basing teachers» and principals» ratings, in part,
on a 3 - year average
of student
test scores.
Wednesday's decision states that although 40 percent
of a
teacher's evaluation can still be
based on test scores, half
of those
tests must be chosen by local school districts through collective bargaining with their union.
20 %
of teacher evaluations will be
based on student
scores on standardized
tests, and another 20 %
of the
teacher's grade will be
based on standardized
test scores, but there will be some leeway for interpreting those
test scores.
About 38,000
teachers, or 20 percent, had one - fifth
of their evaluations
based on their students»
scores in the fourth - through eighth - grade English and math
tests.
He spearheaded the creation
of new
teacher evaluations allowing half
of a
teacher's rating to be
based on students» standardized
test scores.
The law, which
bases as much as 50 percent
of teachers» job ratings
on student
test scores, was strengthened during a time when more rigorous standardized exams,
based on the national Common Core academic standards, were being introduced into classrooms.
ALBANY — A drive to repeal New York's legal requirement
basing teacher job ratings largely
on students» state
tests scores ignited debate Monday over the question
of whether repeal could mean «double
testing» for students.
Just about the same percentage
of voters say
teacher tenure should not be
based on test scores either.
7:15 pm: Juan asks DioGuardi: The NYC Department
of Education is poised to release to the public in the coming weeks
Teacher Data Reports, which are
based on student
scores on state
tests.
The contract cemented the practice
of evaluating
teachers based on students»
test scores.
Four - out -
of - five New York City voters (80 %) support a new
teacher evaluation system
based on both classroom observations and
test scores, with 56 % supporting such a system strongly.
The New York Daily News reports
on our poll that found that 80 %
of NYC voters support a new
teacher evaluation system
based on both classroom observations and
test scores.
The state aid increase should not have been tied to the governor's
teacher evaluation proposal, which in turn should not be increasingly
based on test scores, said David Gamberg, who is superintendent
of both the Greenport and Southold districts.
EDUCATION Mr. Cuomo proposed a new
teacher rating system that would
base 50 percent
of an instructor's evaluation
on student
test scores — an increase from 20 percent.
The New York Daily News blog reports
on StudentsFirstNY's recent poll that found that 80 %
of NYC voters support a new
teacher evaluation system
based on both classroom observations and
test scores.
Under his reform plan, Mr. Cuomo is suggesting that 50 percent
of teacher assessments be
based on student
test scores instead
of the current 20 percent.
Included among the proposed reforms is a
teacher evaluation system
based half
on student
test scores, an increase in the length
of time before a
teacher is eligible for tenure and allowing the state to take over failing schools and districts.
Whatever the parties negotiate or King decides, the evaluation system will be
based 20 percent
on standardized
test scores when applicable, 20 percent
on other evidence
of student learning and 60 percent
on classroom observation and other measures
of teacher effectiveness, in keeping with the 2010 state law
on teacher evaluation.
Contreras said no more than 30 percent
of teacher evaluations should be
based on student
test scores.
In a move that few would have predicted a year ago, the State Board
of Regents
on Dec. 14 voted nearly unanimously to eliminate state - provided growth
scores based on state
test scores from
teacher evaluations for four years.
In a move that few would have predicted a year ago, the State Board
of Regents
on Dec. 14 voted nearly unanimously to eliminate state - provided growth
scores based on state standardized
test scores from
teacher evaluations for four years.
It would seem that the ongoing discussions about «
teacher effectiveness» and the creation
of evaluation systems focused
on measuring a
teacher's capacity (increasingly
based on test scores) often do very little to actually develop that capacity.
A
teacher in New York State is considered to be ineffective
based on her students»
test score growth if her value - added
score is more than 1.5 standard deviations below average (i.e., in the bottom seven percent
of teachers).
But, as numerous studies have shown, having a master's degree is generally not correlated with measures
of teacher effectiveness,
based on student
test scores.
My colleague Katharine Lindquist and I used statewide data from North Carolina to simulate the impact
of opt - out
on test -
score -
based measures
of teacher performance.
We should be considerably more humble about claiming to know which
teachers, schools, and programs are good or bad
based on an examination
of their
test scores.
If parents think that certain
teachers, schools, and programs are good because there is a waiting list demanding them, we should be very cautious about declaring that they are mistaken
based on an examination
of test scores.
After extensive research
on teacher evaluation procedures, the Measures
of Effective Teaching Project mentions three different measures to provide
teachers with feedback for growth: (1) classroom observations by peer - colleagues using validated scales such as the Framework for Teaching or the Classroom Assessment
Scoring System, further described in Gathering Feedback for Teaching (PDF) and Learning About Teaching (PDF), (2) student evaluations using the Tripod survey developed by Ron Ferguson from Harvard, which measures students» perceptions
of teachers» ability to care, control, clarify, challenge, captivate, confer, and consolidate, and (3) growth in student learning
based on standardized
test scores over multiple years.
In an article for The 74, the new reform - oriented education news website launched by Campbell Brown, Matt Barnum looks at the impact
of the Obama administration's decision, in 2009, to push states applying for Race to the Top funds to evaluate all
teachers based in part
on student
test scores.
In response to the criticism that
teacher impacts
on student
test scores are inconsistent over time, the authors show that «although VA measures fluctuate across years, they are sufficiently stable» that selecting
teachers even
based on a few years
of data would have substantial impacts
on student outcomes, such as earnings.
Instead
of digging into that,
of course, Winerip jumps to the predictable conclusion that «evaluating
teachers based on their students
test scores may not be foolproof.»
The Houston school district has launched a large - scale plan to pay
teachers bonuses
based on the year - to - year improvement
of their own students»
test scores.
Of course, the effects of moving to a system of compensation based on assessment by principals depend on the relative importance they place on a teacher's ability to raise standardized test scores when making overall assessments of teachers» effectivenes
Of course, the effects
of moving to a system of compensation based on assessment by principals depend on the relative importance they place on a teacher's ability to raise standardized test scores when making overall assessments of teachers» effectivenes
of moving to a system
of compensation based on assessment by principals depend on the relative importance they place on a teacher's ability to raise standardized test scores when making overall assessments of teachers» effectivenes
of compensation
based on assessment by principals depend
on the relative importance they place
on a
teacher's ability to raise standardized
test scores when making overall assessments
of teachers» effectivenes
of teachers» effectiveness.
Several studies, including our own, clearly demonstrate that
teacher evaluation systems that are
based on a number
of components, such as classroom observation
scores and
test -
score gains, are already much more effective at predicting future
teacher performance than paper credentials and years
of experience.
This component makes up 50 and 75 percent
of the overall evaluation
scores in the districts we studied, and much less is known about observation -
based measures
of teacher performance than about value - added measures
based on test scores.
They will be able to hire and maintain a teaching force with the goal
of higher
test scores in mind, and they will have more flexibility than public schools do to reward or punish their
teachers on the
basis of test results.
Tilles raises legitimate concerns about the use
of these
tests — the quality
of the
tests, their snapshot nature, the unintended consequences
of their being high stakes — but seems to forget that 20 %
of the
teacher score comes from «locally - selected measures
of student achievement» and that 60 %
of evaluation is
based on «other measures.»
Principals can also evaluate
teachers on the
basis of a broader spectrum
of educational outputs in addition to
test scores that parents may value.
In our new study, published today in Education Next, my colleagues and I found that only 22 percent
of teachers were evaluated
based on test score gains in the four urban school districts we studied.
But the notion
of paying
teachers on the
basis of their ability to improve
test scores, often termed «merit pay,» while earnestly debated by education policy researchers, is strongly opposed by
teachers unions and is a political nonstarter in many parts
of the country.
Meanwhile, in school districts from Washington, D.C., to Los Angeles and Seattle,
teacher unions and superintendents have clashed over the use
of new evaluation systems that
base compensation
on student
test scores.