This report presents an in - depth discussion of the technical methods, findings, and implications of the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) project's random assignment study of
teaching effectiveness measures.
John has been a vocal opponent of
teaching effectiveness measures used for consequential decisions such as tenure or termination.
Teaching effectiveness measures have great potential to provide teachers with feedback as they work to hone their craft and to help school system leaders understand where support for better teaching and learning is needed, whether that support is effective, and, ultimately, how to design a system of supports to get better results.
John mentioned the need to put safeguards in place before
teaching effectiveness measures are used for consequences.
But while I certainly don't want to see effective teachers labeled ineffective, it would be a grave mistake to simply abandon
teaching effectiveness measures.
The most under - discussed, but valuable, aspect of
teaching effectiveness measures is their ability to inform system - wide teaching improvement efforts.
Not exact matches
I often say that the best
measure of my own
teaching effectiveness is whether or not I am having fun.
A composite
measure on teacher
effectiveness drawing on all three of those
measures, and tested through a random - assignment experiment, closely predicted how much a high - performing group of teachers would successfully boost their students» standardized - test scores, concludes the series of new papers, part of the massive Measures of Effective Teaching study launched more than three ye
measures, and tested through a random - assignment experiment, closely predicted how much a high - performing group of teachers would successfully boost their students» standardized - test scores, concludes the series of new papers, part of the massive
Measures of Effective Teaching study launched more than three ye
Measures of Effective
Teaching study launched more than three years ago.
The Training Arcade offers a library of fun, casual games that can be rapidly customized with any content to reinforce educational material, assess knowledge retention,
measure overall
teaching effectiveness, and improve learning outcomes.
The key issue is the availability of valid
measures of
teaching effectiveness.
While
measuring scholarly excellence is somewhat less contentious than is the case of evaluating
teaching effectiveness, it is nonetheless fraught.
[vi] What is needed are
measures of
teaching effectiveness that are not subject to these types of biases.
Unfortunately, that kind of analysis is hampered by two issues — the difficulty in
measuring teaching effectiveness, and the difficulty in comparing research success across a wide range of academic fields.
We also
measured how
teaching effectiveness improves with experience in New York City public schools.
It turns out the same is true for
measures of
teaching effectiveness: each has its strengths and weaknesses, and by combining them you can capitalize on the former and minimize the latter.
We identify a number of background characteristics (e.g., undergraduate GPA) as well as screening
measures (e.g., applicant performance on a mock
teaching lesson) that strongly predict teacher
effectiveness.
We work with education leaders to
measure the
effectiveness of teachers, principals, and schools; to examine the equitable distribution of effective
teaching; and to understand the factors that help educators have a greater impact on the students they serve.
«The MET findings reinforce the importance of evaluating teachers based on a balance of multiple
measures of
teaching effectiveness, in contrast to the limitations of focusing on student test scores, value - added scores or any other single
measure,» Weingarten said.
In July 2009, NCTE commenced a six - year effort to join disparate strands of education research, and develop a deeper and more comprehensive understanding of how to
measure teacher and
teaching effectiveness.
The foundation also announced today that as part of its plan to promote and support effective
teaching it is investing $ 45 million in research to better understand what makes a teacher effective and how such
effectiveness can be
measured.
Because using test scores as a way to gauge teacher
effectiveness is new and largely untested, it is important that Oregon proceed in a thoughtful,
measured way that continues to put most emphasis on how well teachers use research - proven methods of engaging and
teaching all students, he said.
The
Measures of Effective
Teaching (MET) project proved it is possible to measure teaching effect
Teaching (MET) project proved it is possible to
measure teaching effect
teaching effectiveness.
When school systems begin to use
measures of effective
teaching to assess the
effectiveness of their own efforts, teachers will understand that the burden for improving
teaching does not sit upon their shoulders alone.
We find that observation
measures of
teaching effectiveness are substantively related to student achievement growth and that some observed
teaching practices predict achievement more than other practices.
Acknowledging the «unfairness» of the evaluations, Walker said that a system should
measure the individual
effectiveness of each teacher, but noted that the «FCAT VAM has been applied to teachers whose students are tested in a subject that teacher does not
teach and to teachers who are
measured on students they have never
taught....
Teaching is entirely over scrutinized — what other profession has a multitude of evaluators who sit in the worker's cubicle, office, or warehouse and take verbatim notes of what is seen and heard, then evaluates them with no objective means because there is simply no way to objectively
measure a teacher's
effectiveness to ALL students.
We find it important to note that researchers, who often represent opposing views about the characteristics that define effective
teaching, do agree on the dangers of using the VAM student growth model to
measure teacher
effectiveness.
Evidence of
effectiveness in
teaching the state's academic content standards, including the common core and English language development standards as
measured by more than one year of summative and formative assessment data.
Armed with the knowledge that quality
teaching matters most for student learning, policymakers from state to state are racing to adopt new educational accountability
measures that seek, among other things, to evaluate teacher
effectiveness with more rigorous, evidence - based instruments.
Success in the role is exhibited through student academic growth and increased teacher
effectiveness as
measured by the Danielson Framework for
Teaching (2011).
Teaching effectiveness is being
measured by instruments that do not specifically include descriptions of CRP practices.
As examples, studies that use student test performance to
measure teachers»
effectiveness — adjusted for prior achievement and background characteristics — demonstrate that, on average, teachers add more to their students» learning during their second year of
teaching than they do in their first year, and more in their third year than in their second.
There may also be ways of improving predictions for both new and more experienced teachers using multiple
measures of
teaching effectiveness.
This will dramatically improve student response rates and
measure the
teaching effectiveness and course quality.
We can think of value - added estimates as
measuring three components: (1) true
teaching effectiveness that persists across years; (2) true
effectiveness that varies from year to year; and (3) measurement error.
The District and School Improvement team provides schools with unparalleled levels of service to ensure that the district effectively and efficiently implements continuous improvement systems that support,
measure, and inform the district's work in the areas of
Teaching and Learning, Professional Development, and the Educator
Effectiveness.
Accordingly, and also per the research, this is not getting much better in that, as per the authors of this article as well as many other scholars, (1) «the variance in value - added scores that can be attributed to teacher performance rarely exceeds 10 percent; (2) in many ways «gross» measurement errors that in many ways come, first, from the tests being used to calculate value - added; (3) the restricted ranges in teacher
effectiveness scores also given these test scores and their limited stretch, and depth, and instructional insensitivity — this was also at the heart of a recent post whereas in what demonstrated that «the entire range from the 15th percentile of
effectiveness to the 85th percentile of [teacher]
effectiveness [using the EVAAS] cover [ed] approximately 3.5 raw score points [given the tests used to
measure value - added];» (4) context or student, family, school, and community background effects that simply can not be controlled for, or factored out; (5) especially at the classroom / teacher level when students are not randomly assigned to classrooms (and teachers assigned to
teach those classrooms)... although this will likely never happen for the sake of improving the sophistication and rigor of the value - added model over students» «best interests.»
Along with creating and sharing quality examples of standards - based learning and
teaching, the secondary goal of this project is to demonstrate how theatre educators — classroom teachers and
teaching artists alike — can
measure the
effectiveness of their
teaching and the learning of students.»
The Student Performance and Improvement team provides schools with unparalleled levels of service to ensure that the district effectively and efficiently implements continuous improvement systems that support,
measure, and inform the district's work in the areas of
teaching and learning, professional development, and educator
effectiveness.
They will
measure individual student growth toward college and career readiness and provide data that can inform decisions regarding
teaching and learning, program improvement, and educator
effectiveness.
Only when similar sources of evidence support similar inferences and conclusions can our confidence in the sources as independent
measures of the same construct (i.e.,
teaching effectiveness) increase.
Finally, studies focused on the development of
measures of teacher competence have documented that teachers» ability to analyze student thinking as portrayed in brief video clips of classroom lessons is predictive of their
teaching effectiveness (Kersting, Givvin, Thompson, Santagata, & Stigler, 2012).
In our continuous efforts to provide top quality education to all our nation's students, we must also consider related efforts to improve our teacher pipeline, such as strengthening pathways into
teaching (traditional and alternative); providing meaningful professional development, and focusing on
measuring and improving educator
effectiveness.
Through the Intensive Partnerships for Effective
Teaching initiative, the three sites and CMOs committed to giving teachers the feedback and support they need by incorporating multiple
measures of teacher
effectiveness — including classroom observations, student achievement
measures, and student surveys — in their evaluation systems.
His research interests include
teaching effectiveness,
measures of that
effectiveness, and the interaction of practitioners and policymakers in the service of student learning.
Districts should report on the
effectiveness of professional - development activities by
measuring improvements in classroom
teaching and administrative activities that lead to increased student achievement.
Setting out desired learning outcomes prior to the start of a course makes it possible to
measure the
effectiveness of course content,
teaching strategies, and other pedagogical components at the end of a given course.
The report, entitled «Learning About
Teaching: Initial Findings from the
Measures of Effective
Teaching Project,» reportedly gives the strongest evidence to date of the validity of the value - added model as a tool to
measure teacher
effectiveness.
A composite
measure on teacher
effectiveness drawing on all three of those
measures, and tested through a random - assignment experiment, predicted fairly accurately how much high - performing teachers would successfully boost their students» standardized - test scores, concludes the series of new papers, part of the massive Measures of Effective Teaching study launched three ye
measures, and tested through a random - assignment experiment, predicted fairly accurately how much high - performing teachers would successfully boost their students» standardized - test scores, concludes the series of new papers, part of the massive
Measures of Effective Teaching study launched three ye
Measures of Effective
Teaching study launched three years ago.
«The MET findings reinforce the importance of evaluating teachers based on a balance of multiple
measures of
teaching effectiveness, in contrast to the limitations of focusing on student test scores, value - added scores, or any other single
measure,» AFT President Randi Weingarten said in a statement.