For one report, he traced the impact of the US Supreme Court's 2013 decision in Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics, Inc., in which the court
invalidated patents on naturally occurring DNA.
On November 14th 2017, the Court affirmed the March 31st 2017 ruling by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board of the United States Patent and Trademark Office,
invalidating all patent claims in United Therapeutics» key patent covering its products Remodulin, Tyvaso, and Orenitram.
But
in invalidating the patent with this Dec. 1 ruling, the Central District of California judge has rendered the infringement claim moot.
It may turn out that this dispute is irrelevant in the short term, as after the deal was announced, a federal
court invalidated the patents (that decision is on appeal).
Sean has been published in OC Lawyer opining on the risks of copyright infringement in social media, as well as Law360 where he wrote about his experience
invalidating a patent through an inter partes review proceeding before the USPTO.
[13] The different numbers arise from the fact that the 20 other cases relate to increased NOC proceedings which do
not invalidate a patent but make only preliminary findings of validity and infringement.
Particularly influential were last year's ruling in Association for Molecular Pathology v. Myriad Genetics Inc. that naturally occurring human genes can not be patented and the 2012 Mayo v. Prometheus decision,
which invalidated a patent on a method of adjusting drug dosage using measures of blood metabolites because it relied on a «law of nature.»
Roberts, Pryde and other academics are trawling the scientific literature for papers that could
invalidate the patent by showing that similar techniques were well known before September 1990.
«To
invalidate a patent solely on the basis of an unintentional overstatement of even a single use will discourage a patentee from disclosing fully, whereas such disclosure is to the advantage of the public.»
If a case for patent infringement goes to court, defendants can also try to
invalidate a patent using a summary procedure on the basis that it's directed at an ineligible subject matter: an abstract idea.
USPTO's PTAB has adopted practice of denying some grounds alleged in a petition seeking to
invalidate a patent as «redundant» over other grounds.
It was relatively cheap ($ 2,520 to file up until Sept 16, 2012), and allowed 3rd parties to attempt to
invalidate patents without having to go to court.
Design patent remedies, injunctive relief, partial summary judgment
over invalidated patents, the royalty base (a context in which I hope Apple will defeat Ericsson because it will discourage outsized royalty claims over standard - essential patents), and possibly some procedural issues concerning the interplay of infringement cases and FRAND contract cases in different venues.
In this article published by Bloomberg BNA's Patent, Trademark & Copyright Journal, Don Steinberg, Yung - Hoon Ha and Liv Herriot explore how the Patent Trial and Appeals Board has considered Applicant Admitted Prior Art (AAPA) when a petitioner has relied upon it as part of one or more of its grounds in its IPR petition requesting the
Board invalidate a patent.
Whatever one's opinion on the matter, the Supreme Court yesterday found that the U.S. Patent Office's inter partes review («IPR») proceeding, a process that can
invalidate patents many years after they issue, does not violate Article III of the Constitution.
In finding there was no «misleading / bad faith prosecution» invalidity argument available in Canada, the FCA refused to grant the draconian remedy
of invalidating a patent because an inventor had wrongly removed a co-inventor.
As part of its Patent Busting Project, the Electronic Frontier Foundation claims it has discovered a prior patent and published reference material that should
invalidate a patent granted to Acceris for implementing VOIP using analog telephones as endpoints
«We hope that lower courts will use this case to
quickly invalidate patent claims that do nothing more than claim abstract ideas in connection with generic computer components.
In one case, we achieved a settlement that guarantees that the patent owner may not enforce its patent against any business in the real estate industry, and in another case, one of our constituents won a
ruling invalidating a patent that was being asserted against a number of real estate firms.
Last fall, Eli Lilly launched a $ 500 - million complaint under the North American Free Trade Agreement claiming Canada violated obligations to foreign investors by allowing its courts to
invalidate patents for two of its drugs.
Patent owners unable to make claim amendmendts during IPRs, granted patents found invalid, due diligence that
invalidated patents through comprehensive searchs, where is the cost savings there?
We have a lot more certainty now that technical legal attacks on utility of a patent generally can
not invalidate the patent,» says Noel Courage, partner at Bereskin & Parr LLP in Toronto.
Los Angeles IP litigation partner Shawn Hansen is quoted in this article about drug maker Amgen Inc.'s request for a federal judge to
invalidate patents claimed by a rival company so it can create a generic, less expensive version of a popular cancer drug.
In a thoughtful opinion by Judge Lourie, joined by five of the ten judges, the
Court invalidated the patents, finding that they contained «nothing... that represents «significantly more» than the underlying abstract idea for purposes of § 101.»
But if lower courts interpret the decision broadly, that could
invalidate patents on other biological molecules, says Leslie Meyer - Leon, a registered patent and intellectual property lawyer.
Some companies have tried, with varying degrees of success, to
invalidate the patent being used to collect settlement money.
The company lost the appeals, as the courts upheld the decision to
invalidate the patents.
Technical specialists and patent agents also can become involved in everything from resolving inventorship disputes, infringement lawsuits, and
invalidating patents to public affairs, scrutinizing depositions, and designing your client's business plans.
The invalidated patent is one of several facing formal «oppositions» filed with EPO.
Judge Susan Illston wrote in her opinion that
she invalidated the patent, held by the San Diego, California - based company Sequenom, based on several recent rulings, including the Supreme Court's decision denying patent claims on BRCA genes used in cancer risk testing.
Currently, Japan has two options to
invalidate a patent: one is opposition and the other is trial for invalidation.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation calls Personal Audio a patent troll and has launched a campaign to
invalidate the patent.
«What was interesting is once the court heard the facts of the case, not only did it find the patent was invalid because it was obvious, the court also found that Packers Plus had publicly disclosed the alleged invention more than a year before they applied for the patent which in
itself invalidated the patent,» says Evan Nuttall, partner and head of patent litigation in BLG's Calgary office.
«So, the innovators are looking at Canada, saying, well, you know, this is a country that we invest research money in, we invest time and energy in, and they're
invalidating our patents, so do we want to be part of that bio-tech ecosystem?»
Courage says the ruling is important because it now means that companies looking to
invalidate patents, like some who manufacture generic drugs, will not be able to do so by arguing that a company that manufactures brand name drugs over-promised its intended uses in its initial patent application.
Noting April's Federal Court of Appeal in Bristol - Myers Squibb Canada Co. v. Teva Canada Limited, Van Barr says the «obvious to try» test, which can be used to extend obviousness and
invalidate a patent, «is a battleground right now.»
There are administrative procedures that have been introduced since 2013 called post-grant review and inter partes review that give alleged infringers avenues to
invalidate patents, Ripley says.
Under the subject matter framework laid out by the U.S. Supreme Court in Alice, courts have been denied patent protection and
invalidated patents, Caulder agrees, for software - implemented inventions on the basis that they are directed to a law of nature, natural phenomenon or an abstract idea and that the claims do not recite «significantly more.»
Achieved a significant victory for Unified Patents, Inc. when the PTAB held that a SportBrain Holdings LLC patent for fitness tracker technology was obvious,
invalidating a patent that dozens of companies have been accused of infringing.
See, e.g., 35 U.S.C. § 315 (a)(1)(IPR must be filed within one year of action by petitioner or real party in interest seeking to
invalidate patent) and § 315 (e)(estoppel bars petitioner from asserting in a later proceeding «any ground that that the petitioner raised or reasonably could have raised» during IPR proceeding).