Not exact matches
The letter, written by a
top Cuomo aide, says the student test scores are «unacceptable,» and asks Board of Regents Chancellor Merryl Tisch and outgoing Education Commissioner John King what to do about an
evaluation system that
rates just 1 percent of all of the
teachers in the state as poorly performing.
It was a dramatic increase from the existing
evaluation rubric, settled with
teachers unions as part of the state's Race to the
Top deal, that used state tests as 20 percent of a
teacher's
rating.
In Tennessee, a Race to the
Top grant winner and another state regarded as an exemplar of
teacher -
evaluation reform, 98 % of
teachers were
rated at or above expectations.
More specifically, observers in states in which
teacher evaluation ratings include five versus four
rating categories differentiate
teachers more, but still do so along the
top three
ratings, which still does not solve the negative skew at issue (i.e., «too many»
teachers still scoring «too well»).
Related, Kraft and Gilmour found that «some new
teacher evaluation systems do differentiate among
teachers, but most only do so at the
top of the
ratings spectrum» (p. 10).
Until recently,
teacher evaluations were little more than a formality in most school systems, with the vast majority of instructors getting
top ratings, often based on a principal's superficial impressions.
by Jack Jennings Apr 5, 2015 academic standards, accountability, Common State Standards, education research, federal education policy, federal funding, graduation
rate, NAEP, No Child Left Behind, private schools / vouchers, Race to the
Top, school reform,
teacher evaluations, testing 0 Comments
by Jack Jennings Apr 4, 2015 academic standards, accountability, Common State Standards, education research, federal education policy, federal funding, graduation
rate, NAEP, No Child Left Behind, private schools / vouchers, Race to the
Top, school reform,
teacher evaluations,
teacher performance,
teachers, testing 0 Comments
It was a dramatic increase from the existing
evaluation rubric, settled with
teachers unions as part of the state's Race to the
Top deal, that used state tests as 20 percent of a
teacher's
rating.
During the forum,
teacher and administrator representatives agreed that improving quality instruction for students should be the
top priority of the
evaluation initiative, though DelPlano and Tenturier conceded they were apprehensive over how any implemented program might impact their ultimate
ratings, particularly using student performance as a criteria.
If there are no consequences for
rating a
teacher at the
top, the middle, or the bottom, if everyone is getting paid the same, then why would a principal spend a lot of time doing a careful
evaluation?
The group's recommendations include increasing the starting salary by a third; creating a «career ladder» so
teachers can be rewarded for strong performance without leaving the classroom; introducing bonuses for
teachers who receive
top ratings on new
teacher evaluations; and paying more to draw
teachers to hard - to - staff subjects, such as science or special education.
It does not call for merit pay tied to student test scores, which Bloomberg has supported and the city
teachers union has said it would never accept, nor does it support Bloomberg's recent proposal to offer permanent pay raises to
teachers who earn
top ratings on new
evaluations.
We are extremely proud of many of the results, whether it is supporting
teachers to improve their on task engagement by 55 % (or more), or supporting the leaders at East Tech in Cleveland to raise their graduation
rate from 46 % to 73 % and scoring in the
top 1 % nationally for growth on the NWEA, or working with
teachers unions to support their
teachers with quality professional development to support new
evaluations systems.
The state is even having a tough time getting
teacher evaluation ratings from the 61 charter schools that are participating in Race to the
Top.
The state, which promised to improve education school accountability in its Race to the
Top grant, has since stopped publishing the results in anticipation of the state's new
teacher evaluation process, which will use student test scores to
rate teachers.
In Florida, where every district was required to implement a new
teacher -
evaluation system in 2011 - 12, data released in December show that 97 percent of
teachers received one of the
top ratings.
We will work with the
Teacher Evaluation Advisory Committee developed pursuant to the First to The
Top Act to include tenure - granting
rates in principal
evaluations.
For example, section (D)(2)(ii) of the Race to the
Top application (U.S. Department of Education, 2009) asks states to «design and implement rigorous, transparent, and fair
evaluation systems for
teachers and principals that... differentiate effectiveness using multiple
rating categories that take into account data on student growth... as a significant factor» (p. 34).
The new issue describes how major initiatives like the Race to the
Top competition, the No Child Left Behind state waiver requirements, and the Common Core State Standards have propelled state efforts to rapidly overhaul their
evaluation systems and link
teacher ratings to student outcome data.
In response first to the federal Race to the
Top grant and then the NCLB waiver mandates, Connecticut developed a
teacher and principal
evaluation system calling for student standardized test scores to be a part of a
teacher and principal's effectiveness
rating.
by Jack Jennings Apr 4, 2015 academic standards, accountability, Common State Standards, education research, federal education policy, federal funding, graduation
rate, NAEP, No Child Left Behind, private schools / vouchers, Race to the
Top, school reform,
teacher evaluations,
teacher performance,
teachers, testing
* Under current
teacher evaluation systems, it is hard for a
teacher who doesn't have
top students to get a
top rating.
Most recently, 89 percent received one of the
top two
ratings, and only 1 percent were ineffective, which Scott Thompson, the deputy chief of human capital for
teacher effectiveness for D.C. public schools, said was evidence that the
evaluations were making
teachers better.
In the report, When Principals
Rate Teacher, researchers showed that most principals score well in identifying
teachers in the
top and at the bottom of an
evaluation performance criteria rubric.