My trad pubbed ones aren't and likely won't be (they don't relinquish the rights, but they never use them, as you're saying).
Not exact matches
One of the things that struck me, and probably many others, about his report and its conclusions, is that self -
pubbed titles tend to average higher review ratings than
trad -
pubbed books.
I'd say, if I were curious / interested in
trad pub and I was a self -
pubbed author, I might consider offering up a purely commercial
one - off, standalone.
But none in the traditional publishing arena, because, however lousy
one reader or another may think a
trad -
pubbed book, at the very least SOMEBODY liked it besides the author.
When you think about it, it makes sense: back when
trad pub limited us to
one book a year per author, there were still plenty of people who became fans of Terry Prachett, Mercedes Lackey, Patricia Briggs and David Weber.
Here's my answer to the inevitable discussion of how
Trad Pub is «the
one true path» and if you aren't
Trad Pub'd, you aren't a real writer:
I seem to be perfectly able to separate out good indie reads from bad
ones and really I'd have to go through that process of elimination with
trad pubbed books as well.
But
one reason I won't be publishing a lot more middle grade is because I also like to sell books... and it's just very hard to do that in indie MG (or
trad -
pub MG, to be honest — the market is simply smaller).
Don't get me wrong, guys — I'm not down on
trad pub, and I'm not
one of the folks saying that «traditional publishing is doomed».
One con to the
trad pub method is that publishers don't mirror the wants of the actual market.
The problem is I think the same amount of work and effort needs to go into a self -
pubbed book as a
trad -
pubbed one.
But when I think about the NA I'd have missed covering if I only covered the
trad -
pubbed stuff, I'd have missed all but
one of my five - star titles.
One trad -
pubbed novel can set you back $ 9.99 or more, and a single audiobook costs easily twice that.
And
one of the biggest negative effects we've now created as indie authors is denigrating the value of ebooks — specifically indie ebooks, as you'll find the
trad pubs don't do much, if any, free promo — in the eyes of the audience that buys them.
At any rate, the income threshold that self -
pubbed authors must meet ($ 3,000) is that same
one that
trad -
pubbed authors must meet.
Kindle subcontracts editing to Kirkus and, according to Max, «it was strictly a
one way street,» unlike the give and take in the
trad pub editing process.
It's
one thing to say that indie publishing is a successful alternative to
trad publishing and worth pursuing, and that there are notable success stories — especially among trained, highly motivated authors — most of them with established name from
trad pub backgrounds.
But when you look at the «prizes,» it gives
one pause: enough of an advance to last maybe three or four months, and a contract that exemplifies the worst of
trad pub practices.
Out of my ginormous TBR list, I've read only two
trad -
pubbed books this year:
one, a book by Darcie Chan, who had been an indie author; and two, David Levithan's marvelous YA novel, Two Boys Kissing, which I picked up at BEA and couldn't stop reading.
That
one I will market to
trad pubs, or what system is around by the time I finish the book in the next year or so.
(I was not
one of them, likening
trad -
pub to the fighter who would not go down, Jake «Raging Bull» LaMotta.)
So many indies think they need a «professional website» as well as a blog in order to be «real authors», but here you are — a
trad pubbed author — supporting my advice:
One site is plenty, people!
My writer's group had a discussion about this last night, and no
one's happy about it, even
trad -
pubbed authors.
Every single
one of these changes hurts indies far more than it hurts the
trad -
pubbed authors.
Some come to self -
pubbing with a backlist, some start with self -
pubbing and move existing series to
trad pub, some have entirely new books they sell to
trad pub (that's my case, just
one title).
It might also be interesting to take
one genre (because of the amount of data) and use a larger depth to see if indies at the lower end are making more than
trad pub authors at the lower end of the rankings (since many of us sit down here too!)
I know brilliant writers, like RS Guthrie (whose new
one, Blood Land, is a standout example of why some indie authors are completely capable of sitting at the big table with the
trad pub boys), whose work isn't getting nearly the visibility it deserves.
It sounds like she is
one of those «
trad pub or no
pub» at all types.
Rights are
one area where there is a huge positive difference from
trad pub.
One recent call for reviewers (of a
trad pub novel that shall remain nameless) required me to apply for a limited number of paper arcs, and a slightly less limited number of eARCs, with a small essay explaining why my blog was worthy of «winning» an arc for review (when I know very well the eARCs involve no cost whatsoever).
Damian has been frantically kissing up to try and get himself in with
one of the
trad pubs — probably Tor or the like, in my opinion.
And then I remembered, I had an agent, a great agent, I wrote great books (so all the rejecting editors told me) and yes, you are right, self
pub has given my stories a voice and an ear and the chance to be read, when they otherwise would have still been gathering dust on my hard drive, yet, on the other hand this is hard, REALLY HARD, it is SO hard to find your way to a readership as a SP, with limited funds (dwindling)... and the glimmer of
trad pub — with their power to splash your name around established circles of readers, and their ability to secure a great number of reviews where, as a self
pub, doors have been slammed in my face — becomes temptingly shiny again, (it's like childbirth, you forget all the painful stuff with time)... and it all gets very tempting... almost tempting enough to consider sacrificing
one work JUST
one artistic premise for the trade off of visibility... and then perhaps, just perhaps THEN, my SP efforts will finally sprout wings... but then I hear you and other say, it wasn't worth it, you'd never do it again, and I sigh... And then I wake up the next morning and think of packing it all in, and going to work for Walmart and steady shitty pay... lol And then along comes this blog post.
I'm a little late to this party but... this is
one of the things the self -
pub committee is working on for SFWA: we want to make the organization a brand where people can go to find
trad, hybrid, and indie writers with proven track records, writing in the genres they already know they love.
Pop into
one of the
pubs for a festive «
trad session,» and then continue to your hotel, nestled in the heart of the Burren.