However, we return to the point that the SGP applies «in relation to any grievance about action by the employer that could form the basis of a complaint by an employee to an employment
tribunal under a jurisdiction listed in Schedule 3 or 4» (emphasis added).
Not exact matches
[41][42] In May 2012, the
tribunal again
under a purported exercise of universal
jurisdiction took testimony from victims of torture at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, and convicted in absentia former President Bush, former Vice President Dick Cheney, former Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, former Deputy Assistant Attorneys General John Yoo and Jay Bybee, former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, and former counselors David Addington and William Haynes II for conspiracy to commit war crimes.
In a nutshell, the Court argued that if a court or
tribunal potentially rules on a matter «covered by EU law» (para. 55), and if that court or
tribunal is situated outside the EU judicial system, the autonomy of EU law is
under threat, even if EU law is only occasionally relevant to the disputes over which arbitral
tribunals exercise
jurisdiction.
Nor does it just say the council may consider a ruling, issued by a
tribunal constituted
under the Human Rights Act or a court of competent
jurisdiction under the Charter, that the university has violated the Human Rights Act or Charter,» the court of appeal also said.
First, the member state could argue that its obligations
under EU law take priority over its BIT obligations, in which case the priority of one obligation over the other can only be established by applying conflict rules, but such arguments have not been raised in intra-EU arbitrations (apart from conflict arguments challenging the
jurisdiction of the
tribunals which is a different matter).
The arbitration clause provided that the local arbitral
tribunal issuing the award only had
jurisdiction over «non-technical» disputes, and any «technical» disputes were to be resolved by an international arbitral
tribunal under the ICC Arbitration Rules.813
«Notwithstanding section (1), the parties may agree to exclude the
jurisdiction of the Court
under this section and an agreement to dispense with reasons for the arbitral
tribunal's award shall be treated as an agreement to exclude the
jurisdiction of the Court
under this section.»
An investor - State
tribunal, chaired by Neil Kaplan QC, has ruled that it has no
jurisdiction to hear Turkcell's claims against the Islamic Republic of Iran
under the Turkey - Iran bilateral investment treaty.
In relation to an award by an employment
tribunal or sum due
under an ACAS settlement, the High Court and County Courts
Jurisdiction (Amendment) Order 2009 (SI 2009/577) will allow beneficiaries to enforce by way of execution against goods in either the High Court or county court where the sum involved is less than # 5,000.
Summary: The appellant challenged a Swedish arbitral award
under Section 34 of the Swedish Arbitration Act, alleging that the arbitral
tribunal either exceeded its
jurisdiction or committed a...
In addition to the frustration this causes for US multinationals at the management level, it causes equal (if not more) frustration in the
jurisdictions where these actions are carried out, when employees and / or labor
tribunals perceive that Americans neither know nor have respect for employee protections
under local law.
Tribunal jurisdiction to hear claims
under SDA 1975 (now of course superseded) is contained within s 63 which states: «A complaint by any person («the complainant») that another person («the respondent»)-- has committed an act of discrimination or harassment... may be presented to an employment
tribunal.»
Solicitors for the Council wrote to the GMB and UNISON unions notifying them that should the claimants succeed in their group claim
under the Equal Pay Act 1970 and the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 (SDA 1975) then the Council would seek a contribution
under CLIA 1978, which the Council asserted the
tribunal had
jurisdiction to determine.
Some of the allegations relate to the broadcast of the offensive logo and team name, which is a federal issue, while hosting the game in Ontario sees the matter also fall
under provincial
jurisdiction, which is why applications were filed with both federal and provincial human rights
tribunals.
The term of legal autonomy comprises thus for Gragl four «imperatives» that the Court has developed, with the consequence of some serious constraints imposed by the CJEU
under its vigilant protection of legal autonomy on Member States choice and utilization of other international courts and
tribunals and on the
jurisdiction of such courts and
tribunals (p. 84).
The first issue is the
tribunal's
jurisdiction to decide only those matters arising
under the collective agreement.
In reaching this decision, the High Court undertook a review of past Singapore case law and legal commentary on the nature and purpose of Article 34 (2)(a)(iii), ultimately deciding that «as a matter of policy, to hold that Art 34 (2)(a)(iii) does not apply, where no other limb
under Art 34 (2) would be engaged, would allow an arbitral
tribunal to immunize its awards against judicial scrutiny by delivering its conclusions on both
jurisdiction and merits in a single award», which would have been an «unsatisfactory result».
As mentioned in Auto Equity Sales v. Superior Court before the California Supreme Court and as brought in the Wikipedia article on precedent: «
under the doctrine of stare decisis, all
tribunals exercising inferior
jurisdiction are required to follow decisions of courts exercising superior
jurisdiction.»
All of these issues fall
under the
jurisdiction of boards,
tribunals and government agencies that make rules affecting our daily lives...
In two of the new cases (the Bangladesh / Myanmar and the Panama / Guinea Bissau cases), the parties have agreed to refer to ITLOS, disputes which ordinarily were within the
jurisdiction of arbitral
tribunals under the dispute settlement system of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.
To do that it would need to show that the dispute it has submitted to the arbitral
tribunal falls outside China's exclusion of
jurisdiction under Art. 298 (1)(a).
In a unanimous decision, the
tribunal - which had been constituted
under the auspices of the World Bank's International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) Additional Facility Rules (the Additional Facility)- ruled that it lacked
jurisdiction over NSPI's claims because NSPI was not an «investor» who had made a qualifying «investment» in Venezuela as called for by the Canada - Venezuela Bilateral Investment Treaty (Canada - Venezuela Treaty).
Most workplaces will fall
under provincial or territorial
jurisdiction — but if you are uncertain, you can contact your province or territory's human rights commission or human rights
tribunal to find out.
The response to the notice of arbitration may also include: (a) Any plea that an arbitral
tribunal to be constituted
under these Rules lacks
jurisdiction; (b) A proposal for the appointment of a sole arbitrator referred to in article 8, paragraph 1; (c) Notification of the designation of an arbitrator referred to in articles 9 or 10; (d) A brief description of counterclaims or claims for the purpose of a set - off, if any, including where relevant, an indication of the amounts involved, and the relief or remedy sought; (e) A notice of arbitration in accordance with article 3 in case the respondent formulates a claim against a party to the arbitration agreement other than the claimant.
Counsel for Stans Energy Corporation before the High Court of England and Wales defending a challenge brought by the Kyrgyz Republic to the
jurisdiction of an arbitral
tribunal seated in London and hearing claims
under the Kyrgyz Foreign Investment Law.
Either party also may, without waiving any remedy
under this agreement, seek from any court having
jurisdiction any interim or provisional relief that is necessary to protect the rights or property of that party, pending the establishment of the arbitral
tribunal (or pending the arbitral
tribunal's determination of the merits of the controversy).
Supreme Court of Canada confirms that administrative
tribunals with the authority to decide questions of law are courts of competent
jurisdiction under s. 24 of the Charter.
The Supreme Court of Canada has confirmed that administrative
tribunals with the authority to decide questions of law are courts of competent
jurisdiction under s. 24 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
In other words,
under Singapore law, while a party that wishes to challenge the
tribunal's decision on its own
jurisdiction has a choice of electing between the active remedy
under Art 16 (3) of the Model Law and the passive remedy of resisting enforcement, such a party does not have a choice of electing between the active remedy
under Art 16 (3) of the Model Law and the active remedy of setting aside the award
under Art 34 (2)(iii) of the Model Law.
This means that the provisions of intra-EU BITs that provide for ISDS and form the basis of the consent of Member States to arbitration are inapplicable; hence, arbitral
tribunals lack
jurisdiction under intra-EU BITs.
Such a problem would not exist, were arbitral
tribunals, including the ICS to be considered a court or
tribunal of a Member State, as then it would be able to ask for a preliminary reference ruling
under Article 267 TFEU, thus engaging the
jurisdiction of the CJEU.
Representing Italy in a dispute with India before the International
Tribunal for the Law of the Sea and an arbitral
tribunal constituted
under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea concerning which of them has criminal
jurisdiction over two Italian marines accused of wrongdoing off the coast of India.
Thus it will be seen by these quotations from the opinion that the court, after stating the question it was about to decide in a manner too plain to be misunderstood, proceeded to decide it, and announced, as the opinion of the
tribunal, that in organizing the judicial department of the Government in a Territory of the United States, Congress does not act
under, and is not restricted by, the third article in the Constitution, and is not bound, in a Territory, to ordain and establish courts in which the judges hold their offices during good behaviour, but may exercise the discretionary power which a State exercises in establishing its judicial department and regulating the
jurisdiction of its courts, and may authorize the Territorial Government to establish, or may itself establish, courts in which the judges hold their offices for a term of years only, and may vest in them judicial power upon subjects confided to the judiciary of the United States.
3.4
Under what circumstances can a national court address the issue of the
jurisdiction and competence of an arbitral
tribunal?
A party's right to bring a challenge
under sections 67 and 68 may be lost if that party does not object to the
tribunal's
jurisdiction and / or procedural irregularities forthwith and continues to take part in the proceedings (section 73).
A party challenging the substantive
jurisdiction of the
tribunal under section 67 is entitled to a complete rehearing, rather than a review of the decision reached by the
tribunal (Azov Shipping Co v Baltic Shipping Co (No 1)[1999] 1 Lloyd's Rep 550; Dallah Real Estate & Tourism Holding Co v The Ministry of Religious Affairs, Government of Pakistan [2010] UKSC 46).
It is important to note that
under the British Columbia Administrative
Tribunals Act, [2] certain provincial tribunals including the RTB, do not have jurisdiction to consider constitutional q
Tribunals Act, [2] certain provincial
tribunals including the RTB, do not have jurisdiction to consider constitutional q
tribunals including the RTB, do not have
jurisdiction to consider constitutional questions.
(a) the complaint or that part of the complaint is not within the
jurisdiction of the
tribunal; (b) the acts or omissions alleged in the complaint or that part of the complaint do not contravene this Code; (c) there is no reasonable prospect that the complaint will succeed; (d) proceeding with the complaint or that part of the complaint would not (i) benefit the person, group or class alleged to have been discriminated against, or (ii) further the purposes of this Code; (e) the complaint or that part of the complaint was filed for improper motives or made in bad faith; (f) the substance of the complaint or that part of the complaint has been appropriately dealt with in another proceeding; (g) the contravention alleged in the complaint or that part of the complaint occurred more than 6 months before the complaint was filed unless the complaint or that part of the complaint was accepted
under section 22 (3).
By way of example only (and not by limitation), if the parties do not agree on whether a particular Dispute is subject to arbitration
under this arbitration agreement, the proper
tribunal to decide such Dispute is the United States District Court (for the appropriate district, as provided above) or, absent subject matter
jurisdiction in that United States District Court, in the appropriate state court (as described above).
assign sole
jurisdiction over claims
under the legislation on domestic relations and relevant claims
under the common law to the
tribunal, and remove the
jurisdiction of the civil courts;
As mentioned, this is the express authourity given to the cop to suspend a licence, and ALL licence suspensions
under s. 47 are appealable to the Licence
Tribunal under s. 50, thus the driver is statute barred from the ordinary courts as the
tribunal has exclusive
jurisdiction; yet the Licence
Tribunal is unlawfully refusing to hear appeals for short term drinking and driving or stunt driving licence suspensions.
(2) For the purposes of subsection (1), the appeal
tribunal may determine any matter that is relevant to the action and within the Board's
jurisdiction under this Act, including determining whether
A court may not recognize a foreign - country judgment if: the judgment was rendered
under a judicial system that does not provide impartial
tribunals or procedures compatible with the requirements of due process of law, as determined by the court using standards developed by the American Law Institute and the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law to govern resolution of transnational disputes; the foreign court did not have personal
jurisdiction over the defendant; or the foreign court did not have
jurisdiction over the subject matter.
Subsequently the Court of Appeal ruled that its decision in McDonagh v Ali should have precluded the employment
tribunal from finding
jurisdiction to hear complaints against the Labour party
under s 12.
However, he is not required (
under s 32 and Sch 4) to grieve as a precondition of presenting his claim, and the
tribunal will therefore not be deprived of
jurisdiction by his failure to do so.
The arbitral
tribunal has considered the objections raised by the respondents herein that the arbitral
tribunal did not have
jurisdiction to decide the allegations to forgery, fraud and fabrication and has rendered the jurisdictional award holding that
under law of Singapore, the arbitral
tribunal has
jurisdiction to decide such allegations.
Under Article 16 (2) of the Model Law attached to the Ontario ICAA, a plea that the arbitral
tribunal does not have
jurisdiction must be raised no later than the submission of the statement of defence, and a plea that the arbitral
tribunal is exceeding the scope of its authority must be raised as soon as the matter alleged to be beyond the scope of its authority is raised during the arbitral proceedings.
In this view of the matter and for the reasons that we have indicated, we have come to the conclusion that this Court has no
jurisdiction to entertain the petition
under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging an international commercial award of an arbitral
tribunal constituted by the Refined Sugar Association, London.
means a court (whether or not exercising
jurisdiction under this Act) and includes a
tribunal or other body concerned with professional ethics.