where indie authors who
tried trad publishing are migrating back to indie publishing because indie publishing suits the author's economic and personal interests better (Here's a link again to my interview with Jamie).
I'm an indy - author since
trying the trad - publishing route in 2005 - 06 with my first two books (historical novels, which several agents looked at, and said regretfully that they were very good... but just not marketable.)
Oh, I'll also hedge my bets and
try the trad route too — but not with one of the Big 5 and not with an agent who would probably fight me tooth and nail on my choice of where to send my work and then happily take their 15 % or more of what I might make.
Wouldn't it profit a «new» author to
try trad publishing first, just to get her / his name out there?
In an effort to help make this decision easier, I've listed some important considerations when contemplating whether you should go indie or
try the trad route.
Not exact matches
They're
trying to avoid the crap with ebooks being the same cost (or more) than paper like so many
trad publishers are doing.
You're doing the exact same thing to Hugh that you claim he's
trying to do to
trad.
If going
trad, decide if you are going to
try for publishers where you need an agent or if you are going to a publisher that has open submissions.
Unless you were able to leverage Hugh Howey - levels of ebook sales (in which case I'm guessing Amazon would
try to snap you up), I doubt a
trad pub would want print rights only.
As for the other 99 %, I agree
trad publishing should be
trying something different, because they're absolutely failing to make those assets pay off like they could.
I'd rather stay low and not even
try to compete with
trad pub, because I don't need to.
I look at indie publishing as a way to show the
trad publishing industry just what an author has and what they can do for themselves, kind of like a «
try before you buy» with little risk to them and, actually, little risk — even financially — to the authors.
Even the
trad pubbed books are pricing some at a lower price as they
try to attract those readers shopping at a lower price point.
Given the big difference between
trad's payment percentages and indy's, there should be enough money there to fund the service house AND tempt the orphaned mid-lister into
trying.
Naturally this means the lion's share goes to the author, and with all the publishers
trying so hard to be competitive they're doing that on a slim percentage, with well over half (increasing with sales) of the money coming to the author it's a great time and reason to stick to
Trad.
Many of these books will be marginal or won't have withstood the test of time, but supply will increase even more as
trad pubs
try to duke it out for dwindling reader dollars.
(http://grumpyoldbookman.blogspot.co.uk/) Mr. Allen very kindly advised that I should give a go for a year to go the
trad - pub route, which involved
trying to attract the interest of an agency — and then, if nothing came of it, going indy.
I
tried going the
trad pub way at first.
I'm
trying to serve a market that the
trads won't serve, and so far, it seems I'm doing fairly well with that.
I wanted to thank you, not just for this article but for all your articles that
try to understand the «big picture» of
trad and digital publishing, and the evolving landscape for indie authors.
You should definitely be covering the issue, though I confess that I gave up on
trying to sell my occasional sf novel through a
trad publisher.
Oh, and it would give the
Trads even more reason to price their backlog ridiculously, since I can't be the only one who's considered it for the really old e-books they're selling for four to six bucks — so you'd be, in the long run, shrinking your share of the pot by making it so that people mostly
try the really expensive books and don't even
try sanely priced books, thus never getting exposed to your writing and it not leading to them buying your books outside the program.
I was pointing up the differences and I think that's a point where they differ (self - pub authors generally aren't
trying to get into bookstores)-- and it struck me in Saundra's article (also Elana's later) that there was as much emphasis on pitching directly to booksellers for
trad - pub authors.
Damian has been frantically kissing up to
try and get himself in with one of the
trad pubs — probably Tor or the like, in my opinion.
Prior to Amazon I spent years
trying to make my way into the
trad world and now looking at their standard contract practices I'm glad I never made it and never will
try again.
For example, they offered me their services as an agent to
try to get my book picked up by a
trad publisher.
I'm still going to
try and
trad pub my trilogy of novels.
He also
tried to market an ebook like a
trad - pubbed book (# 7).
Joanne Phillips made the observation in her post that indie authors
trying to do the work of a whole publishing house's publicity department is never going to work, and we had to realise that indie publishing is completely different from
trad.
I think what he is
trying to say is before self publish authors defend Amazon so much and blame
trad publish, they should understand what would happen in the future when Amazon has destroyed their competitors.
I guess the point I'm
trying to make is:
trad.
I come from an entrepreneurial business background and I had been writing probably for on and off just to amuse myself for the last 15, 20 years but I never really submitted anything or considered
trying to go the
trad route.