However, at this point, no one has done a rigorous error or
uncertainty analysis on the data, so Landsea's statements about the trends are not supported by any rigourous analysis at this point.
The IPCC [the United Nations» Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change] took a shortcut on the actual scientific
uncertainty analysis on a lot of the issues, particularly the temperature records.
Not exact matches
In their
analysis of the new legislation, lawyers at McCarthy Tétrault warned its «broad concepts and elements of
uncertainty» could «place a heavy burden»
on foreign companies looking to invest in Canada; the risk of a meddlesome minister torpedoing a deal is just too high.
Important factors that could cause our actual results and financial condition to differ materially from those indicated in the forward - looking statements include, among others, the following: our ability to successfully and profitably market our products and services; the acceptance of our products and services by patients and healthcare providers; our ability to meet demand for our products and services; the willingness of health insurance companies and other payers to cover Cologuard and adequately reimburse us for our performance of the Cologuard test; the amount and nature of competition from other cancer screening and diagnostic products and services; the effects of the adoption, modification or repeal of any healthcare reform law, rule, order, interpretation or policy; the effects of changes in pricing, coverage and reimbursement for our products and services, including without limitation as a result of the Protecting Access to Medicare Act of 2014; recommendations, guidelines and quality metrics issued by various organizations such as the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, the American Cancer Society, and the National Committee for Quality Assurance regarding cancer screening or our products and services; our ability to successfully develop new products and services; our success establishing and maintaining collaborative, licensing and supplier arrangements; our ability to maintain regulatory approvals and comply with applicable regulations; and the other risks and
uncertainties described in the Risk Factors and in Management's Discussion and
Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations sections of our most recently filed Annual Report
on Form 10 - K and our subsequently filed Quarterly Reports
on Form 10 - Q.
Although there is substantial
uncertainty over the timing and size of expansions, the
analysis suggests that new capacity coming
on stream between mid 2004 and 2007 would imply an increase in overall production of around 28 per cent from the levels of 2003/04, corresponding to annual growth of about 9 per cent.
Further
analysis of the impacts of policies
on prices and bills, including
analysis on households medium - sized businesses and large energy intensive users and a breakdown by individual policy, will be published later this year alongside the Annual Energy Statement and should provide more detail
on the
uncertainty surrounding the true cost of the Government's policies.
Using a representative sample of 20 different methods for predicting extreme sea levels the researchers focused intensely
on the measures of
uncertainty that accompany any prediction, but that are particularly vexing in the
analysis of extremes.
Despite several new
analyses with improved cross-calibration of the 13 instruments
on different satellites used since 1979 and compensation for changes in observing time and satellite altitude, some
uncertainties remain in trends.
As it is explained in the «Notes for Lead Authors of the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report
on Addressing
Uncertainties»: Likelihood may be based
on quantitative
analysis or an elicitation of expert views.
The team admit there is some
uncertainty over the date when China may have become the biggest emitter of CO2, as their
analysis is based
on 2004 data.
However, one of the panel's reservations was that ``... a statistical method used in the 1999 study was not the best and that some
uncertainties in the work «have been underestimated,»...» The panel concluded «Based
on the
analyses presented in the original papers by Mann et al. and this newer supporting evidence, the committee finds it plausible that the Northern Hemisphere was warmer during the last few decades of the 20th century than during any comparable period over the preceding millennium.
Note that
uncertainty in forcings is partly obviated via the focus
on Earth's energy imbalance in our
analysis.
In addition, model intercomparison studies do not quantify the range of
uncertainty associated with a specific aerosol process, nor does this type of
uncertainty analysis provide much information
on which aerosol process needs improving the most.
This paper presents a review of existing literature
on emission factors, emission data collection techniques, and analytic approaches; presents the results of SAIC's
analysis of available CO2 and CH4 GHG emission data from chassis dynamometer tests of heavy - duty vehicle exhaust; and provides suggestions for further reducing this
uncertainty.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Joint Program
on the Science and Policy of Global Change
Uncertainty Analysis of Global Climate Change Projections: http://web.mit.edu/globalchange/www/rpt73.html
If she accepts that attribution is amenable to quantitative
analysis using some kind of model (doesn't have to be a GCM), I don't get why she doesn't accept that the numbers are going to be different for different time periods and have varying degrees of
uncertainty depending
on how good the forcing data is and what other factors can be brought in.
Of course, this would need to be justified by some
analysis, which itself would be subject to some structural
uncertainty... and so
on.
And, as Kevin Trenberth of the National Center for Atmospheric Research warned not long ago, the climate simulations run for the next report from the Intergovernmental Panel
on Climate Change (AR5 below) are likely to produce more
uncertainty than earlier
analyses:
We recently published a paper exploring the impact of observational
uncertainty on an attribution
analysis.
In the interview, with Andy Balaskovitz, I described the value of having a public more attuned to how science works — that new knowledge is what's left over after peers chew
on each others» data and
analysis, and that argument and
uncertainty are normal, that science is a journey, not a set of facts:
2)
Uncertainty / error
analysis based
on both the
uncertainties in the temperature reconstruction and in the TSI (allready mentioned here by rasmus and urs).
Note also that the raditiave
uncertainties surrounding sulphates are large, so any
analysis (like all of those discussed
on this thread) would be informative rather than conclusive.
A brief
analysis based
on multi-gas emission pathways and several climate sensitivity
uncertainty estimates.
Results do not address all sources of
uncertainty, but their scale and scope highlight one component of the potential health risks of unmitigated climate change impacts
on extreme temperatures and draw attention to the need to continue to refine analytical tools and methods for this type of
analysis
In the midst of such
uncertainty,
on Oct. 15 the EPA's Office of Inspector General announced it would conduct an independent inquiry into whether the agency properly updated its own life cycle
analysis in light of the 2011 National Academy of Sciences study.
So, while the environment that produces precipitation is affected by the observational
analysis, precipitation relies
on the model physics, and has significant
uncertainty.
What is needed instead is for economists to step up and do the
analyses of the costs and benefits of GHG emissions and of proposed policies — including stating the
uncertainties on their results.
With the far more common and widely accepted method, decision
analysis, the policy analysts need the projected costs and benefits, the probabilities that the costs and benefits will be achieved given the real world constraints, and the
uncertainties on the inputs.
If
analysis of historical data
on GHG rise and net effects of aerosols establishes beta = 0.5, then TCR = 1.2 C. But, beta is uncertain and might be as low as 0.4, in which case TCR = 1.3 C. But, TCR (1 + beta) = 1.8 C and only has
uncertainty introduced by
uncertainty in the historical GMST and CO2 level rise.
His research focuses
on the estimation of the «social cost of carbon,» including the proper discount rate to be used in cost - benefit
analyses and the implications of structural
uncertainty for policy solutions.
All the above concerns most clearly situations where we can not repeat experiments of identical setup to obtain an empirical distribution of results, but where the function that describes
uncertainties is based
on an
analysis of the empirical method.
«Rather than justifying a lack of response to climate change, the emphasis
on uncertainty enlarges the risk and reinforces the responsibility for pursuing successful long - term mitigation policy,» according to a 2010
analysis by researchers at Sandia National Laboratory.
As noted above, the
uncertainty estimates derived from a particular
analysis will tend to underestimate the true
uncertainty because they are conditional
on the
analysis method being correct.
In the 6 hours that I have been able to devote to this, here is my first take
on their
uncertainty analysis.
We've been working
on fairly abstruse aspects of the economics of
uncertainty, though with an eye to practical applications to issues like an
analysis of the precautionary principle.
This
analysis is based
on a set of interviews with decision - makers, in particular World Bank project leaders, and
on a literature review
on decision - making under
uncertainty.
The use of even more recently computer - reconstructed total solar irradiance data (whatever have large
uncertainties) for the period prior to 1976 would not change any of the conclusions in my paper, where quantitative
analyses were emphasized
on the influences of humans and the Sun
on global surface temperature after 1970 when direct measurements became available.
We applied the same method used in the observational
analysis on general circulation model data to decrease the statistical
uncertainty at the expense of an increased systematic
uncertainty.
«The language of denial: Text
analysis reveals differences in language use between climate change proponents and skeptics» «Comment
on «Climate Science and the
Uncertainty Monster» by J. A. Curry and P. J. Webster» «Guidance note for lead authors of the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report
on consistent treatment of
uncertainties»
A cost - benefit
analysis depends sensitively
on these
uncertainties.
Includes background information
on greenhouse gas emission inventories, an introduction to climate change, an overview of institutional arrangements and compilation process for this inventory, including methods, data, QA / QC and an
uncertainty analysis.
A pragmatic response is to acknowledge and highlight such unquantifiable
uncertainties but to present results
on the basis that they have zero effect
on our
analysis.
My reasoning: these latest estimates (unlike the 3.2 C estimate in AR4) are based
on analysis of the actual past record with some estimates made for natural forcing / variability (with some
uncertainty on whether these natural factors have been underestimated).
HadISDH provides values for the variables and their
uncertainties for 5 ° x5 ° grid squares, based
on direct
analysis of quality - controlled station data.
This study addresses the challenge by undertaking a formal detection and attribution
analysis of SCE changes based
on several observational datasets with different structural characteristics, in order to account for the substantial observational
uncertainty.
Even the original publications are often quite terse
on other
uncertainties than those given by the statistical
analysis directly.
On his blog, tamino does the statistical
analysis of the BEST data and finds that because the timeframe in question is so short, the
uncertainty is too large to say for certain that the short - term trend in question is any different than the long - term trend.
Harp DR, Atchley AL, Painter SL, Coon ET, Wilson CJ, Romanovsky VE, Rowland JC (2016) Effect of soil property
uncertainties on permafrost thaw projections: a calibration - constrained
analysis.
Sensitivity
analysis indicates that
uncertainty about the measure of surface temperature, anthropogenic sulfur emissions, or its conversion to radiative forcing has a small effect
on the model's simulated forecast for global surface temperature (SI Appendix: Section 2.4 and Figs S3, S4).
But I do know the difference between a simple linear interpolation and principal component
analysis, and I can calculate the two standard deviations range of
uncertainty on a white noise linear trend.