The Court
upheld punitive damage awards in both cases, but indicated that due process imposes an outer limit on remedies of this type.
In Mustagi, the British Columbia Court of Appeal
upheld a punitive damage award of $ 175,000 to a foreign nanny.
One response to this problem is to note that those situations simply won't occur too often, and if they do, these results should not be viewed as controversial compared to the various cases in which courts have
upheld punitive damages awards that constitute a far higher percentage of net wealth or value than what I've suggested under retributive dam - ages.
Not exact matches
The Court of Appeal
upheld all aspects of the jury's
award except for the amount of
punitive damages.
The Federal Court
upheld a $ 185,000
award for
punitive and aggravated
damages to a 30 year employee who was subjected to harassing and threatening conduct by his employer's executive director and then wrongfully dismissed without notice or cause.
A recent Supreme Court of British Columbia decision reveals that an
award for aggravated and / or
punitive damages is not automatic where termination for cause is not justified and
upheld by the court.
Following an appeal by Home Hardware the aggravated
damages were set aside and the
punitive damages were reduced to $ 75,000 however, the notice
award and defamation
damages in the amount of $ 60,000 were
upheld.
Obtained a
punitive damage award ($ 350,000) which is still the highest
punitive award against an insurer
upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal (Plester vs. Wawanesa)
The Court of Appeal for British Columbia
upheld the
award for mental
damages and also
awarded Ms. Fidler $ 100,000 in
punitive damages for bad faith conduct by Sun Life.
Although the Supreme Court of Canada
upheld the
award of
punitive damages against RBC it rejected the trial judge's conclusion that «courts are entitled to expect honest behaviour from the major chartered banks».
[61] That it did, however, does not alone mean the $ 150,000
award of
punitive damages should be
upheld.
This decision was
upheld on appeal except for the
punitive damages award.