The analysis from the charter school association, which used data collected by the Michigan Department of Education, concluded the largest gaps were found in the MEAP reading scores — as high as 9.3 percentage points difference in eighth grade; with 43.6 percent proficient for black urban students in charter schools, compared to 34.3 percent proficient for black
urban students in traditional public schools, said Buddy Moorehouse, spokesman for the state's charter school association.
Not exact matches
In the 25 years since Minnesota passed the first charter school law, these publicly funded but privately operated schools have become a highly sought - after alternative to traditional public education, particularly for underserved students in urban area
In the 25 years since Minnesota passed the first charter
school law, these publicly funded but privately operated
schools have become a highly sought - after alternative to
traditional public education, particularly for underserved
students in urban area
in urban areas.
Here is what we know:
students in urban areas do significantly better
in school if they attend a charter
schools than if they attend a
traditional public school.
But a decade ago several trends
in American education, and
in the Catholic Church, made a Catholic - operated
public school seem increasingly possible: 1) the
traditional, parish - based Catholic
school system, especially
in the inner cities, was crumbling; 2) equally troubled
urban public -
school systems were failing to educate most of their
students; and 3) a burgeoning charter
school movement, born
in the early 1990s, was beginning to turn heads among educators
in both the private and
public sectors.
In general, charter schools that serve low - income and minority students in urban areas are doing a better job than their traditional public - school counterparts in raising student achievement, whereas that is not true of charter schools in suburban area
In general, charter
schools that serve low - income and minority
students in urban areas are doing a better job than their traditional public - school counterparts in raising student achievement, whereas that is not true of charter schools in suburban area
in urban areas are doing a better job than their
traditional public -
school counterparts
in raising student achievement, whereas that is not true of charter schools in suburban area
in raising
student achievement, whereas that is not true of charter
schools in suburban area
in suburban areas.
In states like Colorado, where charters are perceived as public schools serving local students, advocates may find they can build bipartisan support, especially in light of traditional conservative support for charter schools and the sector's continued focus on serving disadvantaged, urban students, which appeals to liberal
In states like Colorado, where charters are perceived as
public schools serving local
students, advocates may find they can build bipartisan support, especially
in light of traditional conservative support for charter schools and the sector's continued focus on serving disadvantaged, urban students, which appeals to liberal
in light of
traditional conservative support for charter
schools and the sector's continued focus on serving disadvantaged,
urban students, which appeals to liberals.
On average, charter
schools show higher achievement than
traditional public schools, especially with traditionally underserved
student groups and
in urban environments.
While
urban students overall do better
in charter
schools than
in traditional public schools — a conclusion found by rigorous studies that account for any potential differences
in the
students going
in — the gap varies tremendously from place to place.
The statement concludes: «There is no reasonable rationale for using taxpayer funds to build more charter
schools until and unless the federal government provides resources to build and renovate our
traditional public schools, especially
in underfunded and overcrowded
urban districts, proportional to the number of
students currently enrolled
in them.»
Boston's Charter
Schools Show Significant Gains — Boston charter school students outperformed their counterparts at traditional public schools and at charter schools in other urban areas by a striking margin over a recent six - year span, a Stanford University study
Schools Show Significant Gains — Boston charter
school students outperformed their counterparts at
traditional public schools and at charter schools in other urban areas by a striking margin over a recent six - year span, a Stanford University study
schools and at charter
schools in other urban areas by a striking margin over a recent six - year span, a Stanford University study
schools in other
urban areas by a striking margin over a recent six - year span, a Stanford University study found.
Specifically,
students enrolled
in urban charter
schools receive the equivalent of 40 additional days of learning growth
in math and 28 days of additional growth
in reading compared to their matched peers
in [
traditional public schools].
Some of the most dramatic gains
in urban education have come from
school districts using a «portfolio strategy»: negotiating performance agreements with some mix of
traditional, charter and hybrid
public schools, allowing them great autonomy, letting them handcraft their
schools to fit the needs of their
students, giving parents their choice of
schools, replicating successful
schools and replacing failing
schools.
They are also graduating
students from high
school and enrolling them
in college at much higher rates than
traditional urban public schools.
The NAACP report documents the consequences of this abandonment: inadequate funding of
urban schools, a lack of accountability and oversight for charter
school, most of which are concentrated
in urban communities, the disproportionate exclusionary discipline of Black
students, high teacher turnover, and an absence of teachers of color
in both charters and
traditional public schools.
Nationally,
urban charter
schools on average achieved significantly greater
student success
in both math and reading than
traditional public schools, said the study, which covered the academic years 2006 - 07 to 2011 - 12.
Boston charter
school students outperformed their counterparts at
traditional public schools and at charter
schools in other
urban areas by a striking margin over a recent six - year span, a Stanford University study found.
Charter
schools attract a higher percentage of black
students than
traditional public schools,
in part because they tend to be located
in urban areas.
What policymakers are not regularly told is that although poverty level
in all
urban schools are high (both at charter and at
traditional public schools), the
students at many of Connecticut's
urban charter
schools are significantly «less poor» than the
students who attend the
public schools in those same communities.
He found that the studies show that while there are some examples of success, particularly
in large
urban school districts that primarily serve
students of color like those
in New York City and Boston, they also show that across the nation, there is little evidence that charters do better than
traditional public schools when it comes to
student test scores.
A 2015 study on
urban charter
schools by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes at Stanford University found that D.C. charter
students are learning the equivalent of 96 more days
in math and 70 more days
in reading than their peers
in traditional public schools.
Charters
students also demonstrated much less growth
in advanced scores of 5th graders than all other groups of
students, including those
in traditional urban public schools.
A recent study by the
Urban Institute compared college attendance rates of
students who participated
in the program to attend a tuition - based
school with their demographically - similar peers who attended
traditional public schools.
• There is no reasonable rationale for using taxpayer funds to build more charter
schools until and unless the federal government provides resources to build and renovate our
traditional public schools, especially
in underfunded and overcrowded
urban districts, proportional to the number of
students currently enrolled
in them.
The
public charter
schools actually showed a regression
in proficiency
in reading and writing for
students between Grades 3 and 5 while all other choice programs as well as
traditional urban schools demonstrated growth
in proficiency.
Overall,
students enrolled
in urban public charter
schools gained 40 additional days of learning
in math and 28 additional days
in reading compared to their
traditional public school peers.
An analysis of 2011 - 12 MEAP results by the Michigan Association of
Public School Academies concludes that black urban students perform better in charter schools than in traditional public schools in both math and read
Public School Academies concludes that black
urban students perform better
in charter
schools than
in traditional public schools in both math and read
public schools in both math and reading...
Students in traditional urban public schools tend to live in more intense poverty than those in charters (as measured by the % of students receiving free lunch - the commonly cited, and somewhat misleading, indicator of poverty is the undifferentiated free / red
Students in traditional urban public schools tend to live
in more intense poverty than those
in charters (as measured by the % of
students receiving free lunch - the commonly cited, and somewhat misleading, indicator of poverty is the undifferentiated free / red
students receiving free lunch - the commonly cited, and somewhat misleading, indicator of poverty is the undifferentiated free / reduced %).
Research from MIT, Stanford and Harvard have repeatedly documented that
in states with comprehensive charter
school laws,
public charter
schools outperform
traditional public schools, especially those serving
students who are low - income, living
in urban communities, are children of color and are English - language learners.
These results are highlighted
in CCSA's Chartering and Choice as an Achievement Gap - Closing Reform: The Success of California Charter
Schools in Promoting African American Achievement, which shows that, overall, charter schools in California are effectively accelerating the performance of African American public school students, and are earning higher Academic Performance Index (API) scores and proficiency rates statewide, in many urban districts and across all subjects when compared with traditional public s
Schools in Promoting African American Achievement, which shows that, overall, charter
schools in California are effectively accelerating the performance of African American public school students, and are earning higher Academic Performance Index (API) scores and proficiency rates statewide, in many urban districts and across all subjects when compared with traditional public s
schools in California are effectively accelerating the performance of African American
public school students, and are earning higher Academic Performance Index (API) scores and proficiency rates statewide,
in many
urban districts and across all subjects when compared with
traditional public schoolsschools.
Students enrolled
in urban charter
schools in New Jersey learn significantly more
in both math and reading compared to their
traditional public school peers.